Quaternary: Lectures 20-26 Flashcards
Define rapid/abrupt climate change. What is the importance of this?
“When climate system is forced to transition to a new climate state at a rate more rapid than rate of change of external forcing”
Events (excluding the 100k yr period glacial-interglacials) in the Holocene on sub-Milankovitch timescales e.g. 4.2 kyr, stadials, interstadials
Describe the Last Glacial-Interglacial Transition. Outline the key events leading to the Holocene.
LGIT - sequence of rapid events leading into the Holocene
- ‘Type site’ Lake Windermere in UK providing cores showing sharp transitions (light-to-dark; soil-to-marine)
Devensian (last glacial) –> Bolling-Allerod (interstadial) –> Younger-Dryas (stadial) –> Holocene
What evidence of the LGIT has there been?
Cores (Cumbria):
- Lake sediments; temp proxies
- Multi-proxy approach
Pollen:
- Woodland species indicated warmth e.g. birch
- Grassland indicate transition periods
- Tundra indicates cold e.g. sedge
What is the Younger Dryas?
- Dramatic return to LGM temps
- The most pronounced stadial of LGIT lasting 1100 yrs
- Temp shifts in just 40 years
- Reduction of >15C in Greenland, 5C in Britain
Global evidence of the Younger Dryas?
Tropics:
- Cariaco basin, Venezuela; varves (annual bands), anoxic conditions, sensitive to ITCZ changes = N Atlantic changes affecting tropics
- Dongge/Hulu speleothems suggest weakening summer monsoon
- Lake Huguan Marr China; strengthening winter monsoon
= teleconnections
ITCZ southerly migration indicated by weaker summer monsoon and stronger winter monsoon
Driver of the Younger-Dryas? What has been linked to this event?
- N. American pro-glacial Lake Agassiz collapses = freshwater influx (AMOC disruption)
- Different events at tropics; SH as a driver itself due to previous meltwater pulse 14.7ka and B-A interstadial
- Bi-polar seesaw; mechanism debated
- Rejected/controversial suggestion of impact event
Links to…
- Sudden disappearance of Clovis culture in N America
- Megafaunal extinction
- Natural vs. anthro?
What is the 8.2 kyr event? What is the significance of this?
Smaller, post-YD event within Holocene, cold snap
- Temp decrease by 4-8C in 150 years
- 14% CH4 reduction
Significance?
- Holocene relatively stable compared to LGIT
- But considerable variability
- Internal forcings to investigate
- Further events e.g. 4.2 (on societal timescales)
- Helps predict future of GL ice sheet
Why is it important to study the Holocene, what is it?
The present interglacial:
- Period of relative stability
- We’re in it
- Climatic events
- Anthropogenic change in past context
- Dawn of modern civilization (Neolithic revolution)
- Anthropocene?
- Range of potential forcing mechansisms
- Wealth of natural archives
What are the characteristics of the Holocene? Who first noticed its instability?
Blytt-Sernander; patterns of peat decomposition
Von Post & Godwin; pollen changes
Divided into 3 main periods:
- Rapid warming (early); Boreal trees
- Thermal maximum (mid); Atlantic, maritime environment
- Cooling (late); sub-Boreal
Why did we enter this period of relative warmth (early Holocene) and what evidence do we have?
LGIT = increased northern latitude summer insolation
Last set of Devensian ice sheets melting
Temp reconstruction:
- NW, CW Europe regional variation with latitude
- Greater seasonality in N
- Short-term variability
Main changes identified?
- Declining northern mid-latitude summer temps (GL ice core)
- Declining Asian summer monsoon, reduced continental heating (Dongge Caves)
- Glacial re-advance in NH mostly
How has cyclicity in the Holocene been described/explained?
‘Bond’ events are the ice-rafted debris events in the Holocene (D-O, and Heinrich in Pleistocene)
- 1470 (+-500yrs) periods associated with cooling
- Linked to LIA, 8.2, YD, 4.2, 2.8 climate events
What is the 4.2 kyr event? What evidence is there?
Sudden dry period, a centennial scale drought (300-400 yrs)
- Associated with societal disruption/collapse of ancient civilizations
- With Bond IRD event 3
Global evidence:
- 117 records across 7 continents = abrupt change
- Significant teleconnections (monsoonal regions)
- Consistent drying in mid-latitudes, wetting in NH
What are the potential drivers of climate changes in the Holocene, such as the 4.2 kyr event?
4.2 = solar activity vs. glacial melt water vs. volcanism vs. imaginary vs. artefact
Forcing? Orbital Volcanic Solar GHGs (natural vs. anthropogenic)
What can be said about the climate in the last 1000 years? What evidence of change is there?
Temp now unlike any point in last 1000 years
With higher ppmv (>400), never seen in last 20,000 or even 800,000 yrs
2050 ppmv predictions will take us to unseen levels for last 10 Myrs
Evidence for climate change events over last 1000 years:
- Medieval Warm Period (vikings, scot wine) and Little Ice Age (frost fayers)
What initially dominated glacial-interglacial cycles? How has this changed?
Initially by obliquity (41 ka tilt cycle)
Last 1 Myrs by eccentricity (100 ka shape cycle)
What is MIS 5e?
The Last Interglacial; Ipswichian
130-115 ka
What evidence is there for MIS 5e?
Landforms:
River terraces
Raised beaches
Caves
e.g. Bobbits hole (UK ‘type site’, 3.5m organic-rich mud, banded terraces) or Trafalgar Square (terrace deposits, evidence of Hippos/Hyenas)
Flora, fauna and humans:
- Flora from pollen record; warmth (lime, elm), cold (pine, grasses)
- Fauna; hippos, bison, lions, Elk, Auroch, water vole
- Hominids; no evidence of humans in British Isles within MIS5e (not until 900 ka)??
How has MIS 5e evidence varied between the Arctic and tropics?
Arctic - deposits, trees, (120ka GL) cores, sea level:
- Warm-indicator fossil sea shells
- Ice-free
- Sea-ice 800km further north
- Sea level 8m higher
- Trees 80km north of current extent in N America
Tropics - foraminifera, Mg, warmer:
- More Mg suggests warmth
- 1-2C warmer
- Corals 500km beyond current range by W Australia
Average 1.5C warmer than today - analogue for future IPCC 2C scenario?
Is the Ipswichian a good analogue?
Not really because it was wetter, warmer, had higher sea-levels and smaller ice sheets
Also, earth was closer to sun, the perihelion was in the NH Summer (but is in NH Winter today)
What is a better analogue for our current interglacial and why?
MIS 11
Similar orbital forcing to today experienced 400 ka
- A prolonged warm period 31,000 years long BUT LESS EVIDENCE FOR IT BCOS OLDER
How did the idea of evolution and the search for evidence progress since mid-1800s?
1856 - Remains of neanderthal in Germany??
1859 - Darwin natural selection
1871 - Ascent of Man, selection in relation to sex
1891 - Most significant finding of Homo erectus in Java
1920s - Hominins in Africa
Outline the scientific classification system from animals to us.
Kingdom Phylum Class Order Family Genus Species
How has the Hominidae family been further classified to get to us?
Family Subfamily Tribe Subtribe Genus: homo Species: sapiens