Public health Flashcards
Define health need
The ability to benefit from a intervention
Define demand
What people ask for
Define supply
What is provided
What makes up Bradshaw’s Taxonomy of Need
- Felt need - individual perceptions of variation from normal health
- Expressed need - individual seeks help to overcome variation in normal health
- Normative need - professional defines intervention appropriate for the expressed need
- Comparative need - comparison between severity, range of interventions and cost
Define health needs assessment
A systematic method of reviewing the health issue facing a population, leading to agreed priorities and resource allocation that will improve health
What approach to health needs assessment has been used in the following case?
A public health consultant is asked by a local politician what the major health issues are in a small town within their constituency.
She cannot find an existing health needs assessment so she conducts one herself. She does this by arranging focus groups with local healthcare professionals, teachers, social workers, business leaders and charities.
She also invites local residents to attend public meetings and sends emails to them to identify issues that they feel are important.
Corporate approach
What are the advantages of a corporate approach to health needs assessment
- Based on the felt and expressed needs of the population in question
- Recognises the detailed knowledge and experience of those working with the population
- Takes into account wide range of views
What are the limitations of a corporate approach to health needs assessment
- Difficult to distinguish ‘need’ from ‘demand’
- Groups may have vested interests
- May be influenced by political agendas
What approach to health needs assessment has been used in the following case?
The health status of South Hill is compared with a nearby town ‘North Hill’, which is a similar size and affluence. You find that South Hill has a higher prevalence of cardiovascular disease and COPD than North Hill. However, it has a lower rate of injuries and death from road traffic accidents
Comparative approach
What are the advantages of a comparative approach to health needs assessment
- Quick and cheap if data available
- Indicates whether health or services provision is better/worse than comparable areas (gives a measure of relative performance)
What are the limitations of a comparative approach to health needs assessment
- May be difficult to find comparable population
- Data may not be available/high quality
- May not yield what the most appropriate level (e.g. of provision or utilisation) should be
Describe the epidemiological approach to health needs assessment
Uses a source of data i.e. disease registry, hospital admissions, GP databases, mortality data, primary data collection (e.g. postal/patient survey) to look at:
a. Disease incidence & prevalence
b. Morbidity & mortality
c. Life expectancy
d. Services available (location, cost, utilisation, effectiveness etc)
What are the advantages of a epidemiological approach to health needs assessment
- Uses existing data
- Provides data on disease incidence/mortality/morbidity etc
- Can evaluate services by trends over time
What are the limitations of a epidemiological approach to health needs assessment
- Quality of data variable
- Data collected may not be the data required
- Does not consider the felt needs or opinions/experiences of the people affected
What are the three approaches to health needs assessment and briefly describe them
- Epidemiological: Uses existing data to look at:
a. Disease incidence & prevalence
b. Morbidity & mortality
c. Life expectancy
d. Services available (location, cost, utilisation, effectiveness etc) - Comparative: compares the health or healthcare provision (i.e. health, service provision/utilisation, health outcomes) of one population to another - spatial (e.g. different towns) / social (e.g. age, social class)
- Corporate: Ask the local population what their health needs are and uses focus groups, interviews, public meetings. Wide variety of stake holders: teachers, healthcare professionals, social workers, charity workers, local businesses, council workers, politicians
Give one health related example of something that
you consider is demanded but not needed or
supplied & explain the reasoning behind this
example
?
Give one health related example of something that
you consider is wanted and needed but poorly
supplied & explain the reasoning behind this
example
Mental health services i.e. counselling & psychological therapy demanded & needed however services are facing budget cuts and are struggling to supply this.
IVF: needed and demanded for patients with infertility however not widely available on the NHS and there can be long waiting lists
Yellow fever vaccine: only available privately, but demanded and needed if travelling to an endemic area to prevent infection
Give one health related example of something that
you consider is wanted and supplied but not needed explain the reasoning behind this
example
Antibiotics for an uncomplicated viral upper respiratory tract infection. This can be demanded by the patients parents and supplied in severe cases however antibiotics do not treat viral infections therefore is not needed.
Give one health related example of something that
you consider is needed and supplied but not always wanted/demanded explain the reasoning behind this
example
Smoking cessation services is supplied and needed for health promotion however not everyone will demand for this service.
Give one health related example of something that
you consider is needed, wanted and supplied explain the reasoning behind this
example
Childhood vaccinations
Free contraception
Ambulance services
Define primary prevention
Interventions that aims to remove or reduce a risk factor or introduce a protective factor to prevent a disease before it has developed
Define secondary prevention
2 definitions:
- Trying to catch a disease at an pre-clinical/ early stage to alter the course of disease
- Interventions that prevent recurrence of disease
Define tertiary prevention
Interventions that aim to minimise disability and
prevent complications one disease is diagnosed
What type of prevention is this?: GP practice sets up a diabetes clinic to try to improve the glucose control of its diabetic patients. Patients are provided with education and support, along with lifestyle advice and regular screening of their eyes, kidneys and feet.
Tertiary
What type of prevention is this?:
Referral to smoking cessation for patients with COPD.
Tertiary
What type of prevention is this?:
Mammography screening to detect early breast cancer
Secondary
What type of prevention is this?:
Advising pregnant mothers to take folic acid
Primary
What is the population approach to prevention
A preventative measure delivered on a population wide basis and seeks to shift the risk factor distribution curve i.e. dietary salt reduction through legislation to reduce BP distribution curve
What is the high risk approach to prevention
Identifies individuals above a chosen cut-off and treat them i.e. screening for high BP and treating
What is the prevention paradox
A preventive measure which brings much
benefit to the population often offers little to
each participating individual
What is screening
A process which sorts out apparently well
people who probably have a disease (or
precursors or susceptibility to a disease)
from those who probably do not. NOT diagnostic.
List the 5 types of screening
- Population-based screening programmes
- Opportunistic screening
- Screening for communicable diseases
- Pre-employment and occupational medicals
- Commercially provided screening
Based on the Wilson and Jungner criteria of screening what criteria comes under “the condition”
- Natural history well understood
- Has a detectable early/pre-clinical phase
- Considered as an important health problem
Based on the Wilson and Jungner criteria of screening what criteria comes under “the test”
- Suitable (sensitive, specific, inexpensive)
- Acceptable to population
- Should be repeated and not on a one off basis
Based on the Wilson and Jungner criteria of screening what criteria comes under “the treatment”
- Facilities for diagnosis and treating available
- Acceptable and effective
- Adequate health service provision should
exist for people found positive on screening
Based on the Wilson and Jungner criteria of screening what criteria comes under “risk and benefits”
1. Should be an agreed policy on whom to treat 2. Costs should be balanced against benefits 3. Risks ( psychological and physical, should) be less than the benefits
Describe selection bias associated with screening
People who choose to participate in screening may differ from general population:
- May be at higher risk (family history of breast cancer, more likely to attend)
- May be at lower risk (higher socioeconomic group – may be more likely to attend)
Describe led-time bias associated with screening
By detecting the presence of disease earlier, screening can appear to increase length of survival even if it has no impact on the course of the disease
Describe length-time bias associated with screening
Disease detected through screening is less aggressive than disease detected because it causes symptoms. Screening can suggest that those who are screened have a better prognosis due to the screening, rather than because they have a less aggressive form of the disease.
Give 3 disadvantages of screening and an example for each
- Exposure of well individuals to distressing or harmful diagnostic tests i.e. colonoscopies for those with positive faecal occult blood tests
- Detection and treatment of sub-clinical disease that would never have caused any problems i.e. non-aggressive prostate cancer in elderly men
- Preventive interventions that may cause harm to the individual or population i.e. the potential for increased antibiotic resistance if all mothers were screened for group B streptococcus in pregnancy
The UK National Screening Committee is evaluating the breast cancer screening programme.
One member of the committee highlights some research that found women with cancers detected through screening had a lower mortality than those detected after they became symptomatic.
Other members of the committee suggest that bias could have contributed to this apparent difference.
Which type of bias from the following list are they referring to?
Length time bias
Define sensitivity
The proportion of people who have the disease who are correctly identified
Define specificity
The proportion of people without the disease who are correctly excluded
Define positive predictive value
The proportion of people with a positive test who have the disease
Define negative predictive value
The proportion of people with a negative test who don’t have the disease
An elderly man asks his GP why all men do not get screened for prostate cancer using PSA tests. The GP replies that few patients with high PSA turn out to have prostate cancer. What does this suggest about PSA as a screening test for prostate cancer?
Positive predictive value is low
What type of bias is this describing:
A comparison of survival in screen detected patients with non-screen detected patients may be biased as there will be a tendency to compare less aggressive with more aggressive cancers
Length time bias
Give 4 examples of an observational epidemiological study
- Descriptive:
a. Ecological - Descriptive and analytical:
a. Cross-sectional - Analytical:
a. Case-control
b. Cohort studies
Give an example of an experimental/interventional study
Randomised controlled trial
What is a cross-sectional study?
AKA Prevalence study
Divides population into those with & without disease and collects data on them at a single point in time.
Finds associations between disease prevalence and exposure.
What are the advantages of a cross sectional study?
- Relatively quick and cheap
- Provide data on prevalence at a single point in time
- Large sample size
- Good for surveillance and public health planning
What are the disadvantages of a cross sectional study?
- Risk of reverse causality (don’t know whether outcome or exposure came first)
- Cannot measure incidence
- Risk recall bias and non-response
What is a case-control study?
Retrospective study.
Identifies those with the outcome/disease and match then to people without the outcome/ disease for age/sex/class.
Study previous exposure to potential risk in hypothesis.
What are the advantages of a case-control study
- Good for rare outcomes (e.g. cancer)
- Quicker than cohort or intervention studies (as the outcome has already happened)
- Can investigate multiple exposures
What are the disadvantages of a case-control study
- Difficulties finding controls to match with cases
- Most prone to recall bias when people are required to remember and record information from events that happened in the past
- Also prone to selection bias
What is an ecological study?
Uses routinely collected data to show trends in the data :
a. Ecological trends: prevalence of disease in different population groups (i.e. different areas)
b. Time trends: prevalence of disease over time
What are the disadvantages of an ecological study
Does not show causation
What is a cohort study?
Starts with a population without the disease in question and follow up study participants over time to see if they are exposed to the agent in question and if they develop the disease in question or not.
What are the advantages of a cohort study
- Can follow-up a group with a rare exposure (e.g. a natural disaster)
- Good for common and multiple outcomes
- Less risk of selection and recall bias
What are the disadvantages of a cohort study
- Takes a long time
- Loss to follow up (people drop out)
- Need a large sample size