Public Goods Flashcards
Public good refers to two concepts
- The definition that economists use
- How the term is understood by the public
Rival
consumption by one party reduces the ability of others to consume it
Excludable
people can be prevented from consuming it
- non-excludable have a positive provision externality
Private Goods
excludable and rival
- efficiently provided for by the private sector
ex: Most consumer goods
Club Goods
excludable but non-rival
- efficiently provided for by the private sector
ex: Many goods on the internet
Pure Public Goods
non-excludable and non-rival
positive production externality
ex: National defense
Common Goods
non-excludable but rival
- ex: natural resources & public services
Tragedy of the Commons
common goods are over-used & degraded
Common goods have two types of externalities
negative usage externality
positive provision externality
Common goods have two market failures
Overused by the market & under provided by the market
market eq
PMB = PMC
also where, SMB = SMC
Market supply curve
PMC. If no externalities, PMC = SMC
Market demand curve
the horizontal sum of the individual. demand curves
– Is also the private marginal benefit curve, the PMB
– Represents the benefits to consumers from purchasing one more unit
– If no externalities, PMB = SMB
SMB curve
the vertical sum of the individual demand curve
Lindahl Pricing
Charge each person a price = to their marginal WTP at the efficient q
Lindahl pricing has two nice features
Feasible & Efficient
Lindahl Pricing rules
- Pooling our resources and buying a q. where the sum of m. WTP = MC
- Charging each person their marginal WTP at this quantity
Free Riding
People under-report their demand and consume the good without paying
Bc of free-riding
Lindahl pricing leads to underprovision
Tiebout Model
local governments provide public goods and differ in the amount they tax their citizens for the good. People move to the town that provides the amount of the goods they want at the level of taxes they want
Tiebout Model Assumptions
- Infinite # of towns that differ in taxes & public goods
- People are fully informed about each town’s offerings
- People have free mobility between towns
- Towns charge residents a fixed (“lump-sum”) tax
Tiebout Model Implications
- There is no way for someone to free-ride by understating their demand
- The world reaches an equilibrium called the Tiebout equilibrium
- . The Tiebout equilibrium involves perfect residential sorting
Efficiency of the Tiebout Model
- Efficient level of public goods spending
- Efficient payment structure for public goods
- Efficient conversion of tax revenue into public goods provision
Issues of Tiebout Model
Assumptions are not true - too simplified and unrealistic
what local provision does
– Converts non-excludable public goods into excludable club goods
– The exclusion happens at the level of the municipality
Equity Implications of the Tiebout Model
People with fewer resources get worse public goods and thus the tiebout model causes poorer people to get worse public goods
equity implications can be fixed
by supplementing with federal funding