Psychology and Crime Flashcards
- lecture - schizophrenia talk - textbook: Ch9
Mental Health Continuum
severity of illness can change over time, pass through various stages of mental illness. not one state of illness all the time. every individual has diff degree of severity
Ashley Smith Case
- pre-teen sent to youth detention centre
- minor deviance, appeared in court 14 times. found no evidence of mental illness
- then diagnosed with ADHD, narcissistic personality traits.
- sentenced to 4 years, went thru many provinces + transfers.
- she choked herself to death in her cell, while being monitored
prevalence of mental health in canada
- have disorder
- know someone with disorder
- 20% have
- 80% know someone with a disorder
- 50% of ppl experience mental disorder by 40 yoa, 65-70% experience by 90 yoa.
world wide prevalence of mental health
450 million affected
- 1/3 of all disabilities
Old view of crime + mental illness
crime was a symptom of mental illness
prevalence of mental disorder in correctional facilities
- greater than general population.
- most inmates have substantial mental health needs
- many have co-occurring disorders; subs abuse is a huge one - v hazardous
- deinstitutionalization movement may be related
- mental disorder may be lower in prisons than in jails
studies on inmates + mental illness
bc: 30% of inmates with mental illness, 12% with psychotic disorder
other:
40% of incoming males had symptoms of mental illness - double since 1990.
- under-reported bc stigma
- inmates face victimization bc of it
mental health care system + criminal justice system - relationship
hydraulic. as one increases, the other decreases
mentally disordered inmates are more likely to? (4)
- be disruptive
- commit suicide or self harm
- be victimized
- be institutionally maladjusted
mental disorder + CJS
- police contact
- predictor of violence?
- combatting mental disorder + criminality?
- 40% of police contact with individuals with mental health issues was for non-criminal behaviour
- NOT a good predictor of violence, good predictor of violent victimization
- combat mental disorder is similar to desist from criminality (housing, employment, social support)
Vincent Li
Greyhound bus beheading
- NCRMD
– onus to prove on accused. risky because agreeing to guilt.
- only 9% of the 1% of NCRMD were violent
-
recidivism of NCRMD
17% of recidivism for ncrmd after 3 years of release. recidivism of violent crime ~0.
- 35% recidivism rate in general population.
what is the deinstitutionalization movement?
closing of mental institutions to treat in community.
pushed for treatment within communities rather than institutions
- no community services were increased = few options to deal with mentally ill, so they go to jail/prison
- mentally ill more likely to be arrested than non-mentally ill, NOT for more serious crime tho.
best approach for mentally ill
medication + support
- need community care.
- many have fallen through the cracks
nimby:
not in my backyard.
- place services in disadvantaged because don’t want nearby.
- greater political strength, money + unity to keep services out of richer neighbourhoods.
psychological vs sociological theories of crime
socio: explain society, large group. miss individualistic perspectivve
psych: explains individual behaviour but not social interactions.
complement
psych focus of criminality?
personality or learning that affect behaviour
2 assumptions that most psych theories have?
- assumption of offender deficit
2. assumption of discriminating traits
effective deinstitutionalization needs 4 things?
- supportive family network
- an accepting community
- adequate community resources
- a place to live
when effective deinstitutionalization is inefficient can lead to? (2)
- homelessness: 25-50% of homeless have mental disorders
2. criminality: 700 mental health beds in cjs + 1500 who require care
Freud’s psychoanalytic theory of personality (3)
id: biological drives. act on pleasure principle.
ego: direct impulse of id; reality tester. act on reality principle.
superego: conscience; moral compass, values
psychoanalytic theory and crime
crime results when ego + superego are unable to control the id.
- caused by failure to pass thru early stages of development
- superego is inadequately developed/deficient = antisocial behaviour
theories of moral development
Piaget
- criminal behavior understood by focusing on how we develop a sense of morality + responsibility
- learned in stages, parallels cognitive abilities
3 stages of kohlberg’s theory of moral development
- preconventional: egocentric
- conventional: social expectations (adult/teen years)
- Postconventional: universality - hard to attain; what’s best for all, not just me.
according to kohlberg’s theory of moral development at what stage does crime occur?
stuck at egocentric, preconventional level.
- stuck thinking about one’s own desires.
social learning theory: central concept?
based on cognitive functioning and learning through modelling.
- look at how enviro influences; learn from others’ mistakes.