PSYC 501 Principles of Cognitive & Behavioral Change Flashcards
ABA or reversal design
a single-subject research design that systematically introduces and withdraws treatment (the independent variable) to see what happens to target behavior (the dependent variable). That is, does the target behavior “reverse” to levels observed in the initial baseline phase?
A = baseline
B = treatment
A = reversal of treatment; intervention withdrawn
The purpose of the reversal phase is to determine whether the behavior would have remained unchanged if the intervention had not been introduced
If the treatment is responsible for the change in the target bx, then the target bx will return to near baseline levels when the therapy is withdrawn in the treatment reversal phase.
Limitations:
Lack generalizability
Only useful when behavior is maintained by external factors
Withdrawal of tx may be unethical
Learned skill(s) may not be able to be unlearned
Called single subject because each subject is his or her own control
EXAMPLE: Researchers are investigating the effects praise has on childhood bx issues like tantrums. They send therapists to visit the homes of the children and acquire a baseline of each child’s bxs. Researcher then teaches the parents how to properly use praise as form of positive reinforcement. Therapists then come back to the home to measure the frequency of tantrums. To prove that the praise is responsible for the change, the researchers ask the parents to remove the praise and collect data once more. This is an example of an ABA Design because baseline measurements were taken, praise was introduced, and then withdrawn/reversed.
Acceptance and commitment therapy
3rd generation CBT developed by Steven Hayes. Says that psychopathology comes from experiential avoidance and over-control or unwillingness to remain in direct contact with painful experiences. Paradoxically the process of avoiding yields more distress. The primary goal of ACT is to create psychological flexibility in clients. This is done through acceptance and mindfulness skills and commitment and behavior change skills.
Six Therapeutic Components:
Be here now: Making contact with the present moment.
Defusion: Separating/detaching from private thoughts; holding on to thoughts lightly, not tightly.
Acceptance: Opening up and making room for all experiences, including so-called unpleasant ones
Self-as-context: The observing self determines context and is the entity through which awareness happens.
Values: The goals you desire and the activities/beliefs that matter to you.
Committed action: Doing what you need to do to move toward and live by your values.
EXAMPLE: A woman suffers from depression and anxiety and comes into tx. The patient identifies parenting as an important value. Woman’s daughter will graduate from high school soon and she would like to attend graduation but she is afraid of not being able to find the energy. If she does not attend the graduation , she is not living in accordance with her parenting value. Instead of making therapy about how to get rid of her depression, therapy is about how to be at her daughter’s graduation in spite of her sxs. (psychological flexibility) the therapist ACT in hopes that the client can become more accepting of her feelings and thoughts so that she can tolerate them better.
Anxiety/fear hierarchy
used in systematic desensitization; a detailed list of stimuli that trigger a fear response in the client. The list is organized from the things that produce the least intense fear response (low subjective unit of distress SUDs) to the things that produce the most intense fear response (high SUDs).
EXAMPLE: a soldier suffering from PTSD (Post Traumatic Stress Disorder) is now terrified by guns. Even a picture of a gun can elicit a fear response in the soldier. Handling a gun could cause a serious fear response. In this case, the soldier could choose looking at pictures of guns as the least intense fear for his anxiety hierarchy, and holding or shooting a gun could be the most intense fear for his anxiety hierarchy.
Assets
one aspect investigated using behavioral analysis; what the client does well
Assets can be internal (such as commitment to learning, positive values, and social competencies) and internal (such as support, empowerment, boundaries, and expectations)
Can be systematically used to overcome behavioral problems
Ignored in traditional DSM assessment
Examines the client’s repertoire of behaviors they already have
Also assessed when conducting a positive asset search
EXAMPLE: You have a client that is struggling with debilitating social anxiety. He comes in because he is worried about going off to college next year; he frequently skips class now and knows that this will become a problem. During the assessment you’ve uncovered the fact that he has a very strong commitment to learning. This is an asset of his that you plan on using to help overcome some of his class skipping bxs.
Automatic thought
term coined by Aaron Beck; part of Beck’s cognitive therapy; spontaneous thoughts that appear plausible and often occur in response to an event or situation (trigger)
Can include cognitive distortions such as dichotomous thinking, personalization, emotional reasoning, etc.
Can be maladaptive and persistent - need to be challenged
In Beck’s cognitive therapy, pt and therapist monitor, identify, and categorize dysfunctional automatic thoughts; pt taught to consider automatic thoughts as hypotheses to be tested.
Downward arrow technique explores underlying assumptions and schemas related to automatic thoughts; meant to help pt recognise how their core beliefs affect them
Contribute to and maintain depression/anxiety
EXAMPLE: Your client is upset because Bob, the new co-worker, won’t talk to her. She states it is because she is worthless and no one likes her. As a therapist conducting Beck’s cognitive therapy , you would view this is an automatic thought riddled with absolute thinking and jumping to conclusions. Your next step might be utilizing the downward arrow technique to get at the deeper schema/core belief.
Behavior activation therapy
based on Lewhinson’s theory of depression that says depressed individuals tend to engage in increasing avoidance and isolation, which serves to maintain or worsen their symptoms.
The goal of treatment is to work with depressed individuals to gradually decrease their avoidance and isolation and increase their engagement in pleasant activities
Activities are typically things enjoyed before depression, activities related to values, or even everyday items that get pushed aside.
Examples include exercising, going out to dinner, learning new skills, showering regularly, completing chores.
Occurs via:
Self-monitoring of activities and mood
Scheduling Activities
Mastery and pleasure ratings
EXAMPLE: Brandy, age 18, comes into therapy because she is struggling with symptoms of depression. Brandy complains of always feeling tired, lethargic and not wanting to engage in activities that she used to enjoy, such as going out for coffee in the mornings. Brandy finds it difficult to get out of bed in the mornings, which in turn adds to her feelings of lethargy. Brandy’s therapist suggests that throughout the week, Brandy try turning on some music when she wakes up (something uplifting) and listen to it as she makes her bed. After a week of this and Brandy monitoring how it this scheduled activity affects her lethargy, the therapist suggests that Brandy add the activities of brushing her teeth and washing her face. After engaging in these scheduled activities and adding a little bit of behavior activation at a time, Brandy begins to feel less lethargic.
Behavior therapy
a type of psychotherapy that uses principles of learning & conditioning (classical and operant) to reduce maladaptive behaviors & to increase adaptive behaviors.
Originally based upon Pavolv’s theory of classical conditioning & focused on problem bxs that were directly observable - ignored cognitions
Present-focused & generally brief
Behavior therapy began developing as a reaction to psychoanalysis
focus is on the behavior itself and the contingencies & environmental factors that reinforce or maintain the behavior rather than exploring the underlying causes of the behavior
six steps: clarifying the problem, formulating initial goals for therapy, identifying target behavior, designing a treatment plan, evaluating the success of the plan, and identifying the next target behavior. During the course of therapy, the client and the therapist work collaboratively.
Pavlov, Wolpe, Watson & Skinner all contributed to the early development of Behavior Therapy.
EXAMPLE: John is a 12 year old client whose parents brought him to therapy because he has been acting out in school, yelling at his peers when he feels angry, and throwing things in the classroom. The therapist uses principles of behavior therapy in order to reduce these undesired maladaptive behaviors and to increase more adaptive behaviors. The therapist talks to John about his anger and suggests that rather than yelling at his peers when he feels angry, that he instead take a moment and think about something that makes him happy (like playing beach volleyball) and take 3 deep breaths. This suggestion is meant to replace John’s maladaptive bx.
Chaining
part of operant conditioning;an instructional procedure used to teach a person to engage in a complex behavior that has multiple components.
Therapist conducts a task analysis that breaks down the chain into stimulus-response components.
Teach one bx at a time and chain the bxs together. In this way, each response cues the next, and the last response is reinforced.
There are two types of chaining: forward and backward chaining
frequently used for training behavioral sequences (or “chains”) that are beyond the current repertoire of the learner such as in ABA w/ autistic children
EXAMPLE: An autistic child learning to wash her hands independently. Therapist implements the chaining process: The therapist defines the target behavior: washing hands independently.
Task analysis breaks it down into: learning to turn on the faucet, rinse hands, lather soap, rinse hands, turn off faucet, dry hands on towel. Therapist reinforces successive elements of the chain: After child master’s step 1, the parent is sure to praise him and provide positive reinforcement. Then the child moves on to step 2 and so on.Important that the therapist goes back and work on any link in the chain process that seems weak.
Classical/respondent conditioning
a form of learning discovered by Ivan Pavlov; a form of associative learning in which an unconditioned stimulus (US; that naturally and automatically produces a response) is repeatedly paired with a conditioned stimulus (CS; a previously neutral stimulus) in order to evoke an unconditioned response (UR; an unlearned natural response/reaction). Eventually, the US is removed and the CS comes to elicit the CR on its own.
Principles emphasized in Behavior Therapy
CR is stronger if; CS precedes UCS by short vs long time
Phases of conditioning: acquisition, extinction, spontaneous recovery, reconditioning, and counterconditioning
EXAMPLE: Pam comes to therapy complaining of phobia of the dark. She tells the therapist that, when she was little, she was sexually molested by her uncle, who would come to her room when it was completely dark. The therapist hypothesized that classical conditioning played an important role in the acquisition of her phobia: the molestation (US), which elicited fear (UR), came to be associated with the dark (CS), which then elicited the same response (CR).
Confounding variable
part of research; factors other than the independent variable that may affect the dependent variable
Controlling extraneous variables:
Random selection and/or random assignment
Counterbalancing
Utilizing blind or double-blind studies
Also called extraneous variables; 4 types: situational, participant, and demand characteristics
Threatens internal validity
EXAMPLE: You are conducting a study on memory at a local community college. Depending on the composition of your sample, age could be a confounding variable because in general younger people have better memory. That is, age would have an effect on the dependent variable.
Cognitive fusion
associated with ACT. The state of mind in which a person is so fused with their thoughts that they consider them to be synonymous with fact; tendency to take thoughts literally
Can contribute to psychopathology and maladaptive sxs
Causes person to focus attention on the contents of their mind (our thoughts, memories, assumptions, beliefs, images etc) rather than what they are experiencing through the five senses.
Person then makes decisions and takes action based on their internal experience (thoughts, memories etc) rather than what is really going on in the world.
ACT helps client achieve defusion- where they can observe thoughts and see them for what they area - they may or may not be true, and may not reflect the physical world.
EXAMPLE: A client is struggling with cognitive fusion in that when she has a thought of “I am stupid” or “He thinks I’m stupid”, the client actually believes that she is stupid. The therapist helps the client to recognize the thoughts of “I am stupid” or “He thinks I’m stupid” as thoughts and not fact. Therapist explains to the client that just because she thinks it, that doesn’t mean it’s true.
Cognitive restructuring
therapeutic technique used in Beck’s cognitive therapy and REBT; teaches clients to identify and change distorted and maladaptive cognitions
Based on the idea that the client has an excess of maladaptive thoughts
Helps client identify self-talk and thoughts
Client is encouraged to identify cognitive distortions that are maladaptive, challenge the validity of these distortions, and explore more adaptive alternatives
Crucial questions during cognitive restructuring
What is evidence for/against this belief?
What are alternative interpretations of this event?
What are the implications, if the belief is correct?
EXAMPLE: A Grad student comes into therapy experiencing great anxiety about her comps exam in the fall. She reports having thoughts like, “I’m stupid and I can’t do this,” every time she sits down to study. The cognitive therapist points out these maladaptive cognitions and uses the cognitive restructuring to challenge their validity. She asks questions like “What evidence do you have for and against this belief?”
Cognitive therapy
developed by Beck; evolved into Cognitive-Behavioral therapy; focuses on cognitions as the origin of psychopathology;
Assumptions - link between cognitions and behavior, Cognitive activity is potentially observable, it can be monitored, counted, altered, Client is considered expert and collaborator
Two main components are BA and cognitive restructuring
Levels of cognitive distortions (triggered by event)
Automatic thoughts: spontaneous thoughts that appear plausible. Includes dichotomous reasoning, personalization, emotional reasoning etc.
Assumptions: abstract ideas that have generalized rules; often if-then statements
Schemas/Core beliefs: cognitive structures that organize and process info; deepest most ingrained level of cognitions e.g. negative cognitive triad (self, world, future)
Type and content are analyzed
Goals:
Correct faulty information processing
Modify beliefs maintaining maladaptive behaviors and emotions
Provide skills for adaptive thinking
Techniques include: downward arrow, psychoeducation
Focus: more on present vs. less on past, pathology and assets, objective data vs. projective tests, interventions and their evaluation
EXAMPLE: A Grad student comes into therapy experiencing great anxiety about her comps exam in the fall. She reports having thoughts like, “I’m stupid, I can’t do this,” etc. when she sits down to study. The cognitive therapist points out these automatic thoughts and uses the downward arrow technique to begin exploring the client’s schemas and core beliefs so that they can work to change/correct them.
Conditioned and unconditioned responses
part of classical/respondent conditioning; the unconditioned response (UR) is the individual’s response to the unconditioned stimulus (US) which occurs without any conditioning. The conditioned response (CR) is the learned response to the conditioned stimulus (CS); basically the CR and UR are the same response.
EXAMPLE: A client comes to therapy complaining of phobia of the dark. She tells therapist that she was sexually molested as a child on many occasions by her uncle who would come into her room when it was completely dark. The molestation (UCS) which elicited fear (UCR), came to be associated with the dark(CS), eventually eliciting the same response (CR=fear.)
Conditioned and unconditioned stimuli
part of classical/respondent conditioning; the conditioned stimulus (CS) is the neutral stimulus which gains the power to elicit the response through pairing with the US. The US is the stimulus which elicits the reflexive response without any conditioning
EXAMPLE: A client comes to therapy complaining of phobia of the dark. She tells therapist that she was sexually molested as a child on many occasions by her uncle who would come into her room when it was completely dark. The molestation (UCS) which elicited fear (UCR), came to be associated with the dark(CS), eventually eliciting the same response (CR=fear.)
Contingency
part of learning principles and behavior therapy ; an if/then relationship between a behavior and its consequences, i.e. a schedule of reinforcement.
The delivery of the reinforcer is contingent upon a certain behavior or response.
Commonly used in behavioral modification.
Schedules of reinforcement may be continuous or partial/intermittent.
Intermittent schedules of reinforcement tend to make the behavior or response more resistant to extinction.
Used in Contingency Management
EXAMPLE: At the treatment center if the recovering alcoholic attends an AA meeting every day, he receives a voucher at the end of the week and he can use it to be exempted from clean-up duty. This is an example of an individual contingency in which AA attendance (bx) is reinforced with the exemption from clean-up (consequence)
Cue exposure therapy
a specialized form of exposure with response prevention, often used for substance-related disorders, OCD, and eating disorders
Client is exposed to cue for eating/substance abuse/obsessive thoughts but is unable to eat, use drug, or engage in compulsions; goal is to decrease responsiveness to cues
Based on Pavlov’s classical conditioning, specifically extinction
Initial sessions consist mostly of repeated cue exposure; cravings will subside based presentation of CS without US
Later sessions consist of cue exposure with coping/social skills as alternative responses
EXAMPLE: You’re treating a client that is struggling with alcohol use disorder. You are working with her to try and decrease her urges to drink when she’s out at a restaurant. She is extremely used to ordering drinks every time she goes out. You suggest cue exposure therapy and decide to go out to dinner with her at several restaurants without allowing her to order a drink. By preventing her from ordering drinks, you are helping break that association between going out to dinner and drinking.
Decision balance matrix
technique used in motivational interviewing and often used in working with ambivalence in people who are engaged in behaviors that are harmful to their health i.e. problematic substance abuse, over eating
therapist asks the client to list the pros and cons of making a changing or staying the same
Constructed in a decisional matrix consisting of four blocks: advantages of the status quo, disadvantages of the status quo, advantages of changing, disadvantages of changing
Informal measure of client’s readiness for change
EXAMPLE: You’re working with a teenager that is using substances to a dangerous extent. You are considering a substance use disorder diagnosis; the client is extremely ambivalent, and still in denial. You explain to her that it can be good to think through all of the pros and cons of change. You work with her to fill out a decision balance matrix worksheet that assesses all of the costs and benefits. After completing the worksheet, you spend time discussing and exploring her answers to see if her ambivalence has been resolved. That is, is the client more or less ready to change?
Dialectical behavior therapy
a 3rd wave CBT developed by Marsha Linehan as a treatment for suicidality, self-harm, and BPD; a third-generation CBT that seeks to creat acceptance that allows change
There is an empathic understanding and validation of the client’s emotions. This allows the client to remain amenable to therapist’s suggestions for change
The second core strategy of DBT is problem-solving and creating change. This comes from 1st and 2nd generation behavior therapies such as skills training, exposure therapies, contingency management, and cognitive restructuring.
DBT focuses on providing therapeutic skills in four key areas - mindfulness, interpersonal effectiveness, emotion-regulation, and distress tolerance
Mindfulness skills (finding a reasonable response that exists in the middle of one’s reasonable mind vs. emotional mind vs. wise mind);
Interpersonal effectiveness skills (teaching how to be assertive but not aggressive; problem-solving);
Emotion-regulation skills (observing and describing own emotions, goes hand-in-hand with mindfulness);
and distress tolerance skills
Often consists of weekly individual and weekly group therapy sessions
EXAMPLE: Debbie enters therapy because she has BPD; her immediate problem is that she is frequently cutting her arms b/c of recent break up. The therapist uses DBT and validation/acceptance strategies. She tells her “Your emotions can be very upsetting, and it makes sense that you would want to alleviate them, which you do by cutting yourself. Perhaps you can learn other, less destructive ways to do that.” Saying this creates a space to use problem-solving strategies to help the client find more skillful ways of regulating her emotions.
Differntial reinforcement of other behavior (DRO)
a procedure that uses differential reinforcement to decrease/eliminate a target behavior; in this schedule, reinforcer is delivered after an interval of time in which the problem bx does not occur; based on operant conditioning principles
Reinforcement is contingent upon the absence of the problem behavior- but you do not identify an alternate behavior to reinforce, you simply reinforce all other behaviors
Goal is to decrease the target behavior
the “other” behaviors are often incompatible with the target behavior
Can be time consuming
Other schedules: DR of low rates of responding (DRL) and DR of alternative behaviors (DRA)
EXAMPLE: Curtis, a 13-year-old boy with autism, has a problem with aggression (problem bx). After conducting a Functional Analysis, the therapist was able to confirm that the target behavior (aggression) was maintained by social reinforcement. A DRO schedule was created in which he received a reward (praise) every 3 minute interval in which no aggression occurred. There was no alternate bx required for praise, simply the absence of aggression.
Discriminative stimulus
part of operant conditioning; the stimulus or cue that is present when the behavior is reinforced; helps person learn to exhibit target bx in its presence
Consequence is contingent on the occurrence of the behavior only in the presence of the specific antecedent stimuli
Discriminative stimulus → response → reinforcement
Often called ABCs (antecedent, behavior, consequence)
Three term contingency
EXAMPLE: During parent-child therapy, parent brings in child because they are not following the rules at home. The therapist recommends displaying pictures of clocks labeled with activities that the child should be engaged in at the specific time in the day. (7am-wake up, brush teeth, get dressed. 4pm-homework. 7pm get ready for bed, brush teeth.) The clocks serve as a discriminative stimulus by signaling to the child what and when behaviors should occur to avoid punishment and to gain reinforcement (praise)
Efficacy expectations
part of Bandura’s self-efficacy theory that says people have a wide variety of beliefs and expectancies of self, others, world, etc. that are determinants of behavior
Two types of expectancies:
Outcome: belief that a behavior will produce a particular outcome [independent of SE]
Self- Efficacy: belief that one can perform a given behavior successfully or master a situation
Related to person’s locus of control
Fundamental to behavior change
Self-efficacy or skill?
When SE (self-efficacy) is manipulated and skill is equal, SE predicts behavior
Is situation specific and not an overall trait
Determinant of behavior initiation, maintenance, and energy expenditure
Can be increased via modeling and skills therapy
Influences a person’s goals
EXAMPLE: Frank comes to therapy with feelings of anxiety related to leading small groups at work. He believes that he is not equipped with the skills to speak publicly.. Therapist knows that Actual performance accomplishments are the most influential source of efficacy expectations. Therapist works w/ Frank on his efficacy expectations by providing experiences where Frank can feel as though he is able to successfully lead a small group, done through role play and various exercises.
Empirically supported therapy/treatments
part of clinical practice; (EST) interventions that have been found to be efficacious for one or more psychological conditions
Prior to 90s, there were no specific guidelines regarding which treatments for which conditions. In 93, a task force was appointed by the APA to develop a set of criteria for, and provisional list of, ESTs.
ESTs are therapies that have demonstrated: (criteria for EST)
(a) superiority to a placebo in two or more methodologically rigorous controlled studies,
or
(b) equivalence to a well-established treatment in several rigorous and independent controlled studies,
or
(c) efficacy in a large series of single-case controlled designs (>9)
EXAMPLE: Jane uses CBT in her practice to treat generalized anxiety disorder because it is an empirically supported tx. She stays up to date on new research and findings in order to assure she is providing the best treatment to her clients.
Escape/avoidance
part of operant conditioning and types of negative reinforcement; Escape is when the occurrence of behavior results in the termination of aversive stimulus that was already present when the behavior occurred; Avoidance is when the occurrence of the behavior prevents the presentation of the aversive stimulus
In both cases, the behavior is strengthened via negative reinforcement
In escape learning, the individual experiences relief from the aversive stimulus through the escape behavior; in avoidance learning, the individual experiences relief from the anxiety of almost experiencing an aversive stimulus.
EXAMPLE: You are treating a client with a phobia of dogs. Like most typical phobia patients, he does not go anywhere that there might be dogs present. During the psychoeducation phase of treatment, you explain to him that avoidance is maintaining his phobia of dogs. Because he is avoiding all interactions with dogs, the potential for an unpleasant interaction with one is removed, thereby negatively reinforcing his fear.
Exposure with response prevention
(ERP) a type of exposure therapy in which client is exposed to fearful cues and therapist prevents escape/avoidance - both behavioral & cognitive
Obtain detailed description of the situation and context of the problem, define explicit behavior, thoughts, and feelings leading up to it and explore consequences
Exposure can be graduated or prolonged, in vivo and imaginal
Therapist prevents escape or avoidance during exposures, review coping mechanisms
Used for OCD, substance use, eating disorders with purging sub-type
Based on classical and operant conditioning principles [breaking association between CS and CR; reinforcer maintaining behavior removed]
EXAMPLE: You are utilizing ERP with a client that has bulimia nervosa. You have pt eat her favorite binging food in therapeutic setting until she begins experiencing the urge to purge (anxiety). Purging (escape) is prevented and fear gradually decreases over time. You stay w/ Pt and help her engage in coping skills. Her binge urge and associated anxiety subsides slightly after some time has passed. It shows her that the urge to purge can go away with time, without actually purging.