PS 241 Exam 1 Flashcards
First step of comparative method
Choose phenomenon of interest
Second step of comparative method
Translate phenomenon into a variable with values
Third step of comparative method
Develop a hypothesis about the relationship between another variable and our outcome of interest
Fourth step of comparative method
Design a test to track whether changes in IV result in hypothesized effect on DV
Optional fifth step of comparative method
Explore specific case to explore why variable has impact on another
Final step of comparative method
Reflect on validity of hypothesis given the evidence
Causes change in the DV
Independent variable
Measured outcome
Dependent variable
Why IV produces change in DV, links IV and DV
Mechanism
Belongs on Y axis
DV
Argue that the establishment of strong domestic institutions is the key to ending poverty
Page and Pande
Argue that foreign aid is unlikely to resolve the issue of poverty, and invisible infrastructure is
Page and Pande
Social and human systems that enable
citizens to realize their capabilities and escape poverty
Invisible infrastructure
Provider or regulator of invisible infrastructure
Domestic state
Idea that states needed to become weaker and liberalized
Washington Consensus
Argues that states need to be stronger within a smaller scope in order to become economically optimal
Fukayama
Argues that life is brutish and short, necessitating the need for an all-powerful ruler
Hobbes
How states emerged in Europe
Small political units border each other, rulers invade neighbors to acquire valuable land, need taxation to win wars, need legitimacy to tax, winning leaders establish legitimacy
Best theory of creation of states
Charles Tilly
2 dimensions of a state
Strength and Scope
Argues a lack of inter-state war in Africa led to weak consolidation of power and a lack of nationalism
Herbst
Taxes increase during wartime, don’t fully regress after
Ratchet effect
Large territory ruled by single body that is deemed legitimate, able to extract resources and rule over people
Result of state building in Europe
Argue that civil wars occur when conditions favor insurgency
Fearon and Laitin
Frustration because opportunities for growth block out minority groups
Ethnic nationalism
Ways government can lead counterinsurgency
Knowing how to recognized insurgents from noncombatants, preserving noncombatants
3 Theories Fearon and Laitin had
Culture leads to civil war, grievances lead to civil war, feasibility leads to civil war
3 IVS of correct theory Fearon and Laitin had
Weak state capacity, mountanious terrain, population size
Argues that increasing force to regain order in failed, weak states is not the answer, derived from experiences in DRC
Milli Lake
Exogenous
Came from outside, placed in a place
Endogeneity
IV impacted by confounders that also impact DV
Exclusion Restriction
Instrument cannot be related to DV in any other way
Instrumental variable
Only affects IV, which affects DV, used as IV stand-in
AJR’s DV
Economic development today