Property Offenses Flashcards
Larceny (Thieves Took Carmen’s Purse and Issac’s Passport)
Larceny consists of:
–Trespassory
–Taking and
–Carrying away the
–Personal Property
–Of another, with the
–Intent to
–Permanently deprive that person of their interest in the property
Trespassory Element (Larceny)
means wrongful or unlawful - without the consent or by consent induced by fraud
Taking and Carrying Away Element (Larceny) (Asportation)
The property must be moved, but the slightest movement of the property is enough
Custody or Possession Element (Larceny)
The property must be taken from the custody or possession of another
If the defendant lawfully has custody of the property, the defendant cannot be guilty of larceny (even if the defendant doesn’t own it)
Conversely, the defendant can be guilty of larceny for taking their own property if someone else had lawful custody of the property when the defendant took it
Intent to Permanently Deprive Element (Larceny)
Generally, larceny requires that at the time of the taking, the defendant intended to permanently deprive a person of their property.
If the defendant intends to give the property back, the taking lacks the intent to steal that is necessary for larceny.
HOWEVER – An intent to create a substantial risk of loss, or an intent t sell or pledge the goods to the owner, is sufficient for larceny
Erroneous Takings Rule
A taking under a claim of right is never larceny, even if the defendant erroneously believed the property is theirs
Continuing Trespass
If a defendant wrongfully takes property without the intent to permanently deprive, and later decides to keep the property, the defendant is guilty of larceny when they decide to keep it. The initial trespassers taking is considered to have continued. If the taking was not wrongful, the defendant does not commit larceny.
NOTE — this creates an exception to the concurrence principle
Embezzlement
Embezzlement is:
–The fraudulent (specific intent to defraud)
–Conversion (dealing with property in a manner inconsistent with the arrangement by which the defendant has possession)
–Of personal property
–Of another
–By a person in lawful possession of that property
Specific Intent to Defraud
Intent to Restore (Embezzlement)
If the defendant intends to restore the exact property taken, it is not embezzlement
However, if the defendant intends to restore similar or substantially identical property, it is embezzlement. (money qualifies)
Claim of Right (Embezzlement)
As in larceny, embezzlement is not committed if the conversion is pursuant to a claim of right to the property. Whether the defendant took the property openly is an important factor.
Larceny v. Embezzlement
Embezzlement the defendant misappropriates property while it is in the defendant’s rightful possession
In larceny the defendant misappropriates property not in their possession
Custody v. Possession
possession involves a greater scope of authority to deal with the property than does custody
generally the defendant has possession if they were given discretionary authority over the property and has custody if they were given limited authority over the property
Ordinarily, low level employees have only custody of an employer’s property so they are guilty of larceny for taking it rather than embezzlement
False Pretenses
The offense of false pretenses is:
–Obtaining title
–To Personal property of another
–By an intentional false statement of a past or existing fact
–With intent to defraud the other
Misrepresentation Required (False Pretenses)
The victim must actually be deceived by, or act in reliance on, the misrepresentation, and this must be a major factor (or sole cause) of the victim passing title to the defendant
NOTE – Under MPC and model view, the misrepresentation can relate to future performance (false promise to perform in the future)
Intent to Defraud (False Pretenses)
Depending on the statute, the defendant must have known the statement to be false or have intended that the victim rely on the misrepresentation
Most states hold a defendant knew of the falsity of a statement when, after being put on notice of the high probability of the statement’s falsity, they deliberately avoided learning the truth
False Pretenses v. Larceny
In larceny, the defendant only gets custody of the property
In false pretenses, the defendant gets title (ownership) of the property
Larceny by Trick
If the victim was tricked - by a misrepresentation of fact - into giving up mere custody of property, the crime is larceny by trick.
Robbery
Robbery consists of:
–A Taking
–Of Personal Property of another
–From the other’s person or presence (including anywhere in the vicinity)
–By Force or threats of immediate death or physical injury to the victim, a family member, or some person in the victim’s presence
–With the intent to permanently deprive them of it
Specific Intent to Steal
Presence Requirement (Robbery)
The victim’s presence includes a location reasonably close to the victim - for example rooms in a house other than the room in which the victim is located
Force and Threat Requirement (Robbery)
Force – any amount of force sufficient to overcome resistance is sufficient
Threats – the threat must be of immediate death or physical injury
If a person obtains property through threats of future harm, they commit extortion not robbery
GA Armed Robbery
GA provides for the offense of armed robbery
this is committed when, with the intent to commit theft, a person takes property of another from the other’s person or immediate presence by use of an offensive weapon, or by use of any replica or device having the appearance of such a weapon
Extortion
Common law extortion consists of the corrupt collection of an unlawful fee by an officer under color of office
Under modern statutes, extortion consists of obtaining property by means of threats to do harm or to expose information
Extortion v. Robbery
Extortion differs from robbery because in extortion the threats may be of future harm and the taking does not have to be in the presence of the victim
GA Theft by Extortion
Extortion is known as theft by extortion in GA
It is committed by unlawfully obtaining property of or from another person by threatening to:
1) inflict bodily injury on someone (or to commit any other criminal offense)
2) accuse someone of a criminal offense
3) Disseminate information tending to subject a person to hatred, contempt, or ridicule, or to impair their credit or business reputation
4) take or withhold action as a public official or cause an official to take or withhold action
5) bring about or continue to strike, boycott, or other collective unofficial action where the property is not obtained for the benefit of the group in whose interests the defendant purports to act
6) testify or provide information (or withhold information) with respect to another’s legal claim or defense