Property Flashcards
Fee Simple
Largest estate recognized by law, it can be sold, divided, devised, or inherited and has indefinite or potentially indefinite duration. Presumed unless express contrary intent.
Fee Simple Determinable
A fee simple determinable terminates upon the happening of a stated event and automatically reverts to the grantor. Created by durational language such as “for as long as”, “while”, “during”, or “until”.
Automatically creates a possibility of reverter in grantor which is transferable, descendible, and devisable.
NOTE: Statements of motive or intent do not create a determinable fee (e.g, “for the purpose of” or “to be used for”)
Fee Simple Subject to Condition Subsequent
An estate where the grantor reserves the right to terminate the estate upon the happening of a stated event. The conditional words must be clear and definitive, not aspirational.
The possible future interest of grantor (the right of entry) must be EXPRESSLY reserved.
Fee Simple Subject to an Executory Interest
Where a fee simple estate terminates upon the happening of a stated event (whether determinable or condition subsequent) and passes to a third party.
Conditions and Limitations Violating Public Policy
- Penalizes marriage
2. Encourage divorce
Fee Tail
Only goes to lineal heirs. Most have abolished and it just creates a fee simple.
Life Estate
An estate to a person for the duration of their life.
- Measured by the life of the grantee.
- Measured by the life of another.
- Can also be defeasible (i.e., To X for life unless B occurs, then to C”
- Life estate holder can themselves transfer their interest to another.
Rights and Duties of a Life Tenant
Life Tenant is:
- Entitled to ordinary uses and profits of land.
- Limited in exploitation of natural resources to situations where (i) necessary for repair or maintenance; (ii) land only suitable for such use; or (iii) expressly permitted or implied by grantor (but only to the extent in existence, cant expand operations).
Life Tenant: Permissive Waste
LT is obligated to:
- Preserve land and structures in reasonable state of repair;
- pay interest on mortgage NOT PRINCIPAL;
- pay ordinary taxes on the land; and
- pay special assessments for public improvements of short duration.
LT is NOT obligated to:
- Insure the premises
- Perform any of the aforesaid to the extent it exceeds the total income or profits generated from the land.
Life Tenant: Ameliorative Waste
Change that benefits the property. Permissible if:
- Market value of future interest is not diminished; AND
A. the remainderman do not object; or
B. a substantial permanent change in the neighborhood conditions has deprive the property in its current form of reasonable productivity or usefulness. (if worthless may seek partition sale).
Reversion
Whenever you convey less than you own. All reversionary interests are vested and not subject to RAP.
Remainder
A future interest in a third person that can become possessory on a natural expiration of the preceding estate. Cannot divest a prior estate, and NO GAP. Must be EXPRESSLY created (To A for life then to Be and his Heirs)
Indefeasibly Vested Remainder
Created in an existing and ascertained person and not subject to a condition precedent, i.e., can take immediate possession upon termination of the prior estate. Is one that is not subject to diminution or divestment.
Vested Remainder Subject to Open
A certain vested remainder, but subject to diminution, e.g, birth of additional children who will share in the remainder.
Vested Remainder Subject to Total Divestment
A vested remainder that is itself subject to a condition subsequent.
“to a A for life, then to B and his heirs, but if B dies unmarried then to C and his heirs”
Contingent Remainder
Remainders (i) created in unborn or unascertained persons; or (ii) subject to a condition precedent.
Contingent Remainder: Subject to Condition Precedent
A condition is precedent if it must be satisfied before the remainderman has a right to possession.
“to A for life then to B and his heirs IF B marries C”
Contingent Remainder: Unborn or Unascertained Persons
A remainder created in unborn or unascertained persons is contingent because until the remainderman is ascertained, no one is ready to take possession if the preceding estate ends.
“To A for life then to the children of B”
Doctrine of Merger
When one person acquires all of the present and future interests in land except a contingent remainder, under common law, the contingent remainder is destroyed.
Example: “from O to A for life then to B’s children” if O buys A’s life estate, it merges and the contingent remainder in B’s children is destroyed.
Rule in Shelley’s Case
Old rule in common law: if a life estate given to A and a remainder to A’s children, the remainder is destroyed and A takes both. A RAP issue avoidance mechanism.
THIS IS A WRONG ANSWER ON MBE
Doctrine of Worthier Title
Under the DOWT, a remainder in the Grantor’s heirs is invalid and becomes a reversion in the grantor.
“O grants to A for life then to theirs of O” under DOWT, A has a life estate and O has a reversion.
DOWT is a rule of construction, and will not counter express contrary intent in the language (generally only applies if words “heirs” is used).
Executory Interests
Executory interests are future interests in third parties that either divest a transferees preceding freehold estate or follow a gap in possession or cut short a grantor’s estate.
Types of Restraints on Alienation
Three types:
- Disabling restraints under which attempted transfers are ineffective (VOID);
- Forfeiture restraints, under which an attempted transfer forfeits the interest (MAYBE VOID); and
- promissory restraints under which an attempted transfer breaches a covenant (MAYBE VOID).
Restraints on Fee Simple
All absolute restraints on Fee Simple are void. Partial restraints are not.
Joint Tenancy: Definition
Is a joint tenancy with a right of survivorship. When one JT dies the property is freed from the concurrent interest (AKA, the other JT takes the whole property.
JT: Creation
Must take identical interests, at the same time, by the same instrument, with the same right of possession.
Four Unities:
- Time
- Title
- Interest
- Possession
Also requires a CLEAR EXPRESSION of right of survivorship. Otherwise a conveyance to two or more persons is presumed to create a tenancy in common.
JT: Severance
- A voluntary or involuntary conveyance by a JT of her undivided interest destroys the JT. It is converted to a tenancy in common AS TO THE TRANSFEROR’s INTEREST. If there is more than two JT’s, then JT remains in place for the non-transferring tenants.
- Contract to convey a JT’s interest signed by the JT.
- Agreement of all JT’s.
- Murder of a JT by another, or simultaneous death of all JTs.
Exceptions:
- Judgment Lien: does not sever it until foreclosure sale.
- Mortgage in LIEN THEORY states.
- Usually a lease does not sever but it may under traditional common law.
Tenancy by the Entirety
This is a marital estate similar to a JT. If a conveyance to spouses is unclear most presume a TE. Only severed by:
- Death
- Divorce
- Mutual agreement; or
- Execution by a joint creditor of BOTH SPOUSES.
Remember requires BOTH SPOUSES.
Tenancy in Common
Concurrent estate with no right of survivorship. Presumption of creating a Tenancy in Common where there are multiple grantees.
Rights and Duties of Tenants: Possession
Each co-tenant has the right to possess all portions of the property, but has NO EXCLUSIVE right of possession of any part.
A co-tenant out of possession cannot bring a possessory action unless she is OUSTED (e.g., another tenant claims exclusive possession).
Rights and Duties of Tenants: Rents and Profits
Right to retain profits from her own use of the property, no need to share profits with other co-tenant.
HOWEVER must share net RENTS from third parties and net PROFITS from exploitation of the land.
Rights and Duties of Tenants: Effect of One Concurrent Owner’s Encumbering the Property
A JT or TC may encumber their own interest, but not that of any other tenant.
Rights and Duties of Tenants: Partition
Right to seek partition either in kind (physical division) or by sale and division of the proceeds.
Rights and Duties of Tenants: Expenses for Preservation of Property - Contribution
- A TiC who pays more than their pro rata share of NECESSARY expenses is entitled to contribution from the other TICS provided they have notified the other TICs of the need for repairs.
- No right to collect contribution for improvements (even if a tenant is not in possession), but you can deduct from rent paid to other TICs.
- Contribution for taxes and mortgages are OK.
Tenancy for Years
- Normal leasehold (i.e., a lease for X number of years)
- Landlord retains “right of entry” (i.e., right to terminate the lease if tenant breaches lease covenants)
- Even in absence of ‘right of entry’ in most jurisdictions failure to pay rent authorizes right of reentry.
- Surrender can also terminate the lease (must be surrendered in same form as its creation, e.g., writing).
Periodic Tenancy
For successive periods e.g., month to month. Created by:
- Express agreement; (ex. self-explanatory, a written agreement).
- Implication; (ex. “lease for $1,000 a month) or
- Operation of law (ex. T remains after expiration and L treats it as a periodic tenancy)
Periodic tenancy automatically renews until proper notice of termination, usually must be one full ‘period’ in advance (i.e., for a month to month, one month in advance, but for a year its only 6 months for some reason).
Tenancy at Will
Terminable by either party at any time. Created by:
- Express agreement; or
- Implication due to periodic rent payments.
If only LL has right to terminate, it will be inferred that TT also has right, but vice versa does not apply.
Terminated by:
- Notice + reasonable time to quit;
- Operation of law (death, etc.)
The Holdover Doctrine
If TT continues in possession after right has expired then LL may:
- evict him
- bind him to a new periodic tenancy, generally governed by terms and conditions of the prior lease, and generally month to month for residential TT regardless of the prior term (commercial TT can be held to a year to year lease IF the original lease was for 1 year or more, otherwise month to month)
- If LL lets TT know of new holdover terms prior the lease expiration, and TT holds over, then these new terms apply. EXCEPT where (i) marginal delay; (ii) delay not TT fault; or (iii) a seasonal lease.
Tenancies at Sufferance
Created when Tenant wrongfully remains in possession. It lasts only until the LL takes step to evict the TT, no notice required.
Leases and Covenants
Generally a breach of a covenant, where it is a material part of the lease, excuses performance.
Leases and Options
- Options generally last as long as the lease.
2. Falls within the SOF.
Three Types of Waste
- Affirmative waste is where TT intentionally or negligently damages property or exploits resources.
- Permissive waste, is when TT fails to take reasonable steps to protect premises from damage. TT generally liable for ordinary repairs/wear & tear. If lease shifts this to LL, TT must report it promptly to LL.
- Ameliorative waste, when TT takes action that increases its value. Generally liable for restoration, but under the modern view if it is a long term tenancy the TT does not have to.
Destruction of Premises Without Fault
If the premises are destroyed without fault by LL or TT neither party has the obligation to restore, and in the absence of lease language to the contrary the TT has the obligation to continue paying rent.
Tenant’s Liability for Covenant to Repair
- Even if a residential TT covenants to repair, the LL NEVERTHELESS remains obligated to repair under implied warranty of habitability.
- If it is a nonresidential TT, then the covenant to repair is enforceable.
- A TT who covenants to repair is not usually liable to rebuild after casualty destruction unless the covenant expressly includes it. Covenant may exclude wear and tear, but usually includes it.
Security Deposit
May not retain beyond the damages actually suffered. Only able to retain it beyond that if it is a bonus.
Remedy for Failure to Pay Rent
Modern law allows a LL to sue for unlawful detainer and evict; old approach only allowed money damages. The ONLY ISSUE IN UNLAWFUL DETAINER is whether TT has right of possession, no counterclaims allowed.
Tenant Abandonment
If TT unjustifiable abandons the property, then majority view is LL has the duty to mitigate by seeking to re-let the premises.
- If LL does not accept the abandonment, i.e., does not accept the ‘surrender’ by repossessing this for himself, and instead seeks to relet the premises, then TT is liable for the difference between the promised rent and FMV rent.
- If LL repossesses the property for himself it is deemed a surrender and TT is free from any rent accruing after abandonment.
NOTE: Under common law rule a LL can simply do nothing and TT remains liable for rent until the end of the lease.
Basic LL Duties
- At common law LL has no duty to repair or maintain premises. Modified in most states for residential tenancies.
- Duty to deliver ACTUAL possession to the TT.
Quiet Enjoyment
The implied covenant that neither the LL nor any paramount title holder (e.g., mortgagee who forecloses) will interfere with Tenant’s quiet enjoyment and possession of the premises. Breached as follows:
- Actual eviction (i.e., excluded from possession of the ENTIRE leased premises by LL, paramount title holder, or holdover tenant)—terminates TT obligation to pay rent.
- Partial eviction by LL ONLY relieves TT obligation to pay rent for entire premises, but partial eviction from a third person results in a proportionate reduction in the rent.
- Constructive Eviction:
(i) LL breached a duty to TT
(ii) the breach substantially and materially deprived the TT of the use and enjoyment of premises
(iii) TT gave LL reasonable notice and time to cure; and
(iv) after reasonable time the TT vacated the premises.
TT can then terminate the lease and seek damages.
Implied Warranty of Habitability
Implied into RESIDENTIAL leases. NOT WAIVABLE. In the event of a breach the TT may:
- Terminate the lease;
- Make repairs and offset against future rent;
- abate the rent in an amount equal to the fair rental value in light of defects; or
- remain in possession, pay full rent, and sue for damages.
Retaliatory Eviction
Penalized if done. Presumed if LL acts within a certain amount of time after TT exercisers her rights.
Assignments and Subleases
For the exam a transfer will be considered a sublease, rather than an assignment, only when the original TT reserves time for herself.
Lease: Latent Defect
If, at the time the lease is entered into, the landlord knows of a dangerous condition that the tenant could not discover upon reasonable inspection, the landlord has a duty to disclose the dangerous condition. Failure to disclose the information about the condition results in liability for any injury resulting from the condition.
Consequences of Assignment
- Assignee and LL in privity of estate, each is liable to the other for all covenants that run with the land.
- Original TT no longer in privity, but TT remains liable on original K obligations.
- If Assignee fails to pay rent the LL can sue the assignee OR the original TT.
- If Assignee of LL breaches then TT can see LL and Assignee of LL.
Consequences of Sublease
Tenant of original lessee, not an assignment. Created when TT ‘assigns’ less than all of the remaining leasehold.
- Sublessee NOT personally liable to LL for rent or performance of covenant UNLESS the sublease EXPRESSLY says so.
- LL may terminate lease with TT if there is a breach of the lease, which automatically terminates the sublease.
- Sublessee cannot enforce any covenants made by the LL in the lease, EXCEPT in a RESIDENTIAL LEASE, might be able to enforce implied warranty of habitability.
Covenants Against Assignment or Lease
- Strictly construed AGAINST LL (i.e., if it doesn’t SPECIFICALLY prohibit it is permitted).
- Valid covenant against assignment will be waived where (i) knows if it and does not object; or (ii) consents and doesn’t expressly reserve rights as to future assignments.
- Transfer in violation of lease doesn’t terminate the lease, however LL is then able to sue for damages.