proofs Flashcards
a demonstration that an argument is invalid/ valid
proof
true or false: a proof is an argument
false
what makes a good proof?
obvious and valid
how to prove an invalidity?
informal proof with counterexample
eliminates wide scope conjunction.
&Elim; 1
- cites one line
introduce a conjunction
&Intro;1,2
- cites TWO lines
eliminate 2 stacked negations
~Elim;1
- only applies to main connective
build a disjunction from a disjunct
vIntro;2
- disjuncts can be complex sentences
- can add as much as you want at a time from one disjunct
reiteration
Reit;1
- requires line number
- valid from circular reasoning
how to reason from a disjunction?
vElim;1, 2-3, 4-5
- proof by cases
- requires citation of disjunction and subproofs of both disjuncts
- requires the exact same sentence to appear 3 times: in each subproof AND in the main proof
how to reason to a negation?
reductio!!!
- ~Intro;2-7
- cites entire subproof
- make temporary assumption and show that a contradiction results
- each subproof ends with #
true or false: only a contradiction can entail a contradiction
true
what is the 5 step plan?
- pick a disjunct
- put it in a subproof
- build the disjunction
- intro the #
- intro the ~
always ends with ~Intro!!!
how do you prove a tautology (no premises) in bool?
reductio!
- never assume what you already know
2 more weird cases of validity
- logically false premise
- conclusion same as premise
true or false: if an argument is unsound, then it is invalid
false