Professional Responsibility Cards Flashcards
Duty of Confidentiality
A lawyer must not reveal information relating to the representation of a client, unless the client consents. Also, the lawyer must take reasonable measures to prevent unauthorized access to client info. Under CA, a lawyer must disclose confidential information if to prevent a criminal act that would lead to death or substantial bodily harm after making an attempt to dissuade the client from moving forward.
Items of a Crime
If an attorney comes into possession of the fruits of a crime, that informaiton cannot be protected by the duty of confidentiality. It must be turned over to the authorities. However, an attorney is allowed to hold an item of evidence for a reasonable period of time in order to inspect it to build the case.
Duty of Competence
Under ABA, an attorney owes a duty to their client to use their skill, knowledge, thoroughness, and preparation solely for their client’s benefit. Under CA, a lawyer must not intentionally, recklessly, or with gross negligence fail in performing their duties competently.
Mandatory Withdrawal
An attorney is required to withdraw when (1)they are terminated; (2) when their representation of the client violates the law or ethics; (3) when a mental or physical condition prevents the attorney from undertaking effective representation; and (4) where the client’s course of conduct requires the attorney to participate or assist in crime or fraud.
Permissive Withdrawal
Under both ABA and CA, an attorney can withdraw if the client insists on a course of action the lawyer disagrees with or considers repugnant, if the client has misused the client’s services in the past, or if the client has not performed their duties like paying fees. Under ABA, an attorney is permitted to withdraw if they can do so without prejudicing their client.
Duty to Communicate
Under ABA, a lawyer has a duty to communicate with their client and keep them reasonably informed on key issues and steps during representation. Under CA, a lawyer must keep the client updated on significant developments which include written settlement offers and plea deals.
Duty of Loyalty
Under both ABA and CA, an attorney must act in the best interest of the client. If a lawyer believes they are unable to properly represent the client due to some material limitation, they must withdraw unless they reasonably believe they can represent competently. A lawyer must also not represent multiple clients to the same or substantially similar suits unless informed written consent is acquired. More narrowly under CA, the consent and disclosure must be in writing.
Duty to disclose Prior Relationships
Following the Duty of Loyalty, if an attorney had a close personal relationship with someone from opposing counsel, the attorney must disclose that potential conflict to the client. Just like with the Duty of Loyalty, the attorney must withdraw if they do not believe they can adequately represent their client due to the limitation. Under the ABA, the attorney must receive informed consent. Under CA, the attorney must provide consent and disclosure in writing.
Duty of Candor
An attorney owes a duty of candor to the tribunal and their opponent. A lawyer must not knowingly make a false statement to the court or fail to correct a false statement previously made.
Duty to Inform the Court
A lawyer must not assist in perjured testimony or false evidence. A lawyer must disclose to the court when they discover that perjured testimony/evidence is attempting to be admitted.
Duty to Supervise
Under both ABA and CA, a lawyer has a duty to adequately supervise the staff that they manage or exercise control over.
Duty of Diligence
Under both ABA and CA, a lawyer has a duty of due diligence. A lawyer must timely manage and handle cases and documents to provide diligent service to the client. More narrowly in CA, a lawyer is obligated to not knowingly, recklessly, or intentionally fail to act with diligence.
Duty of Fairness
Under both ABA and CA, a lawyer owes a duty of fairness to opposing counsel. When a lawyer receives information they know or reasonably should know was sent by mistake, they must take certain steps to mitigate harm to opposing counsel. Under ABA, the lawyer must notify opposing counsel as soon as possible about the information. Under CA, the lawyer must notify opposing counsel and only read as much as necessary to determine the information was inadvertently sent.
Referral Agreement
Under ABA and CA, a lawyer may refer a client to another lawyer with he informed consent of the client and as long as the referral agreement is non-exclusive.
Referral Fee
Under ABA, referral fees are prohibited. Under CA, they are permitted as long as the client gives informed consent and the total fees are not increased due to the referral agreement.
Referral Fee with Non-Attorney
Under ABA and CA, a lawyer may not arrange referral agreements with non-lawyers for a fee unless it is a qualified reciprocal referral service.
Gifts
Under ABA, lawyers are not permitted to solicit substantial gifts. Under CA, gifts for past referrals are permitted as long as there is an understanding that the gift is not a consideration for future referrals and the gift is “fair”
Solicitation
Under ABA, solicitation, whether personally or through an agent, is prohibited. Solicitation is direct communication with a person in order to gain representation for a financial gain. Under CA, direct solicitations in hospitals and medical facilities are presumed unethical.
Partnership with non-lawyer
Under both ABA and CA, a partnership with a non-lawyer is strictly prohibited to avoid any improper influence on a lawyer.
Fee-sharing with non-lawyers
Under both ABA and CA, sharing fees with non-lawyers is prohibited, unless it is for employees within a firm as part of a compensation plan.
Sexual Relations with a Client
Under ABA, sexual relations with a client is prohibited, unless they pre-date the lawyer-client relationship. Under CA, a lawyer is prohibited from coercing or otherwise unduly influencing a client into sexual relations.
Contingency Fee Agreement
Are agreements whereby a lawyer recovers a percentage fee of the recovered amount. Must be in writing and clearly indicate how the fee was calculated. However, contingency fees are not allowed in domestic relations or criminal cases for policy reasons.
Threats with administrative action
Under CA, threatening with administrative action or any other civil action or prosecution to gain advantage in a current litigation is prohibited. ABA has no such rule.