Professional Responsibility Flashcards
Concurrent Client Conflicts (ABA)
Cannot proceed if one client’s interest is directly adverse to another’s, UNLESS
(1) Lawyer reasonably believes can give competent and diligent representation;
(2) Representation not prohibited by law;
(3) Clients not asserting claims against each other in same litigation;
(4) All clients give informed written consent
Third Party - Current Client Conflicts
Cannot proceed if there is a significant risk that representation materially limited by lawyer’s responsibility to any third party, UNLESS
(1) Lawyer reasonably believes can give competent and diligent representation;
(2) Representation not prohibited by law; AND
(3) Informed written consent
Concurrent Client Conflicts (CA Rules)
Cannot proceed if an actual or potential conflict exists, UNLESS
(1) Informed written consent
Can one lawyer make ‘aggregate settlements’ on behalf of two or more clients in the same litigation?
Not without informed written consent
Can a lawyer enter into a business transaction with a client
Not unless
(1) Fair and reasonable terms;
(2) Fully disclosed in writing;
(3) Lawyer advises client in writing to seek independent counsel; and
(4) Client gives informed written consent to the essential terms.
Former government employee conflicts
Cannot work on the same or substantially related matter without the agency’s informed written consent.
Can a lawyer solicit a substantial gift from a client?
ABA: No
CA: Yes if fair and no undue influence
Can a lawyer draft an instrument with a gift from a client?
ABA: No
CA: Yes if fair and no undue influence
Can a lawyer acquire a proprietary interest in the cause of action or subject matter of litigation?
Not unless to
(1) secure a lien to secure lawyer’s fees or
(2) contract with a client for a reasonable contingency fee in a civil case.
Can a lawyer give advances to client?
ABA: Only for court costs and expenses in (1) contingency cases and (2) for indigent clients
CA: No exception for indigent clients, but may lend money after employment if client promises in writing to repay the loan.
When can lawyer accept compensation from third party?
(1) Client gives informed consent
(2) no interference with the lawyer’s independent professional judgment;
(3) Information related to representation remains confidential
Organizational Client: Duty to Report
If lawyer knows of action likely to result in substantial injury to the organization:
ABA: Refer to higher authority, urge reconsideration, then may reveal information externally
CA: Refer to higher authority, urge reconsideration, cannot reveal information absent threat to life or threat of physical injury
Can a lawyer and client agree to limit malpractice liability?
ABA: Yes, if advise client in writing to seek independent legal counselCA: Never
Duty of Loyalty, Defined
A lawyer owes a client a duty of loyalty, that is, a duty to put the interest of the client above all other interests (preserve independent professional judgment) and to avoid all conflicts of interest
Scope of Representation
Lawyer: Means (what questions to ask witnesses, how to frame arguments)Client: Ends (settle, plea, waive jury trial, testify)
Imputed Disqualification
When one lawyer in firm is disqualified, all are, unless:
(1) lawyer’s conflict is personal and does not present significant risk of materially limiting representation by other attorneys, OR
(2) the conflict is a former client conflict from the lawyer’s work at a prior firm, and the lawyer is screen and the former client notified, OR
(3) informed written consent.
Duty to Communicate
Must communicate regularly with client, inform client of decisions that affect informed consent and status of case
Duty of Confidentiality
ABA: All information related to representationCA: Client’s “secrets”
When is disclosure of conf info appropriate (ABA)?
(1) Express or implied consent
(2) Reasonably necessary to prevent or mitigate:Death or substantial bodily harm (mandatory),substantial financial injury reasonably certain to result from crime or fraud that used lawyer’s services.
(3) Secure legal advice re compliance with rules
(4) Establish a legal claim or defense btwn lawyer and client
(5) Comply with other law or court order
When is disclosure of conf info appropriate (CA)?
(1) Express consent
2) After attempts to dissuade, reasonably necessary to prevent death or substantial bodily harm (discretionary
When is a communication confidential?
(1) Intended to be confidential
(2) No third parties present or reckless speech
(3) Does not apply to physical evidence
(4) Holder can stop eavesdropper from revealing info.
Exceptions to A-C Privilege
(1) Crime or fraud
(2) Dispute between lawyer and client
(3) Two or more parties consult on a matter of common interest, and later have a dispute
(4) : CA Only: Reasonably necessary to divulge info to prevent a crime likely to result in death or substantial bodily harm.
Contingency Fee Agreement: Requirements
(1) In writing
(2) Signed by (CA: Atty and) Client
(3) State methods to determine fee
(4) State methods to pay court costs
(5) (CA: State that fee is negotiable)
NO Contingency fee for domestic relations if promote divorce (ABA and CA) or criminal case (just ABA)
Division of fees btwn lawyers: Requirements
(1) Client consent in writing
(2) Division proportionate to services
(3) Total fee reasonable (CA: Not unconscionable)