Professional Responsibility Flashcards
Be ethical - always. And Party on!
Mandatory Duty to Withdraw
Mandatory Withdraw
A lawyer must withdraw if continuing would violate a law or ethical rule (includes knowingly pursuing a frivolous claim); The lawyers physical or mental condition materially impairs their ability to represent their client; or the lawyer is discharged.
In California, a withdraw is mandatory if the lawyer knows or should have known that the client is acting without probable cause to harass or maliciously injure another person; or The representation will result in violation of the Rules of Professional Conduct or State Bar Act.
Permissive Duty to Withdraw
Withdraw is permitted if there is good cause, and it can be accomplished without material adverse effect on the interests of the client.
Duty of Diligence
ABA: A lawyer shall act with reasonable diligence and promptness in representing a client.
CA: A lawyer shall not intentionally, repeatedly, recklessly, or with gross negligence fail to act with reasonable diligence in representing a client.
Duty to Avoid Frivolous Claims
A lawyer shall not bring or defend a proceeding unless there is a good faith basis in law for an action, claim, or defense.
Threats in a Civil Case
Under the ABA rules, an attorney may threaten another attorney with criminal or disciplinary action in a civil case if the threat is related to the case itself. In California, such threats are not permissible.
Duty to Report Misconduct
Under the ABA rules, a lawyer must report to the appropriate professional authority any other lawyer’s or judge’s violation of the rules in legal or other context if it relates to a substantial question of the person’s honesty, trustworthiness or fitness.
In California, there is no ethics rule that requires a lawyer to report misconduct by another lawyer but does require self reporting to the state bar for certain violations. Also in California, a lawyer can be disciplined for merely knowing of a firm member’s disciplinary violation but doing nothing to prevent it.
Duty of Competency
An attorney must render competent services to the client. Competency relates to the lawyer using the legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation. (CA) A lawyer must not intentionally, recklessly, with gross negligence, or repeatedly fail to perform legal services with competence.
Duty of Confidentiality
A lawyer cannot reveal anything related to the representation of a client without the client’s consent.
The duty applies regardless of whether the client requests that the information be confidential. The duty can attach before a lawyer/client relationship is formed. If no employment results, the party seeking to disqualify bears the burden of proof that the confidences were imparted and once it attaches it continues indefinitely.
In California, the duty ends when an estate is settled.
Duty of Loyalty
A lawyer has a duty of loyalty to his client that requires the lawyer to put the interest of his client above all other interests and to avoid any conflicts of interest.
Duty to Avoid Conflicts of Interest
A lawyer must avoid all conflicts of interest with his client. A lawyer must avoid actual (current) conflicts of interest and potential (future) conflicts of interest.
Concurrent Conflicts of Interest
A lawyer may not represent a client where there is a conflict of interest. A concurrent conflict of interest can arise in several ways:
Between Current Clients: Representation of one is directly adverse to another
Between Current Client and Another: Significant risk that representation will be materially limited due to responsibilities to another person.
Exception to Concurrent Conflicts of Interest
- Lawyer reasonably believes they can provide competent and diligent representation;
- The representation is not prohibited by law;
- Clients are not asserting a claim against each other;
- Each client gives written informed consent.
California:
Must still provide written disclosure of relationship to client so long as:
1. Lawyer/another lawyer in firm has relationship to party or witness, or
2. Lawyer knows/should of relationship between opposing party’s lawyer and lawyer.
Duty re: Representation of Insurance (California Rule)
Lawyers can represent both insured and insurers whereby the insurer has contractual right to unilaterally select counsel for the insured resulting in no conflict of interest by statute.
Duty re: Representation of Corporate/Organizational Clients
A lawyer employed by an organization or corporation represents the organization or corporation and must act in the best interest of the organization or corporation.
Representation of Organization Individuals
A lawyer may also represent the organization and its officers, directors, employees, shareholders, or other constituents if the requirements for the exception to represent those with concurrent clients are met.
Organization: Reporting Conduct to a Higher Authority
If the lawyer knows that an officer, employee, or other person associated with the org. is engaged in an action that lawyer (CA: knows/should) is a violation of a legal obligation or law reasonably imputable to the org. and is likely to result in substantial injury to the org., the lawyer shall report up, and refer the matter to a higher authority in org. unless the lawyer reasonably believes it is not the best interest of org.
Failure to Act by Higher Authority in Organization
If the highest authority fails to take action and lawyer reasonably believes violation will result in substantial injury, lawyer may:
ABA: Report out and reveal information even if confidential
CA: Lawyer may not report out if it will violate confidentiality. Lawyer should urge reconsideration, resign from representation, or withdraw. (Exception: violation will result in great bodily harm/death)
No Aggregate Settlements/Guilty Pleas
A lawyer who represents two or more clients shall not participate in making aggregate settlement of the claims unless each client gives written informed consent.
Lawyer Who Was A Former Government Employee
A lawyer who has formerly served as a government employee shall not represent a client in connection with a matter in which the lawyer participated personally and substantially as a gov employee without written informed consent.
Imputed Firm Disqualifications
A conflict for one attorney in a firm is imputed to all other attorneys in the firm, resulting in their disqualification, unless:
1. Conflict based on personal interest of disqualified lawyer and does not present significant risk of materially limited representation by others.
2. Conflict based on former client at a prior firm, lawyer is timely screened.
3. Former client is provided written notice and certifications of compliance.
4. CA only: prohibited lawyer did not substantially participate in same or related matter.
Client can waive imputed disqualifications with informed written consent.
Conflicts between client and a third party
A conflict of interest exists if there is a significant risk that the representation of a client will be materially limited by the lawyer’s loyalty/responsibility to a third party.
Compensation from third parties
A lawyer shall not accept compensation from third parties to represent the client unless:
1. Client gives informed (CA: written) consent
2. No interference with lawyer’s independent judgment
3. Information relating to representation remains confidential
Conflicts between client and the lawyer’s personal interest
A conflict of interest exists if there is a significant risk that the representation of a client will be materially limited by the lawyer’s personal interest.
The lawyer’s personal relationships and beliefs can cause a conflict of interest. This can be waived with full disclosure and written informed consent
Opposing Lawyer is Lawyer’s Relative
Lawyers closely related by blood or marriage must obtain informed consent before representing clients of the same or related matters.
CA extends to when one lawyer is the client of the other lawyer, two lawyers cohabitate, or two lawyers have an intimate relationship.
Sexual Relations with Clients
ABA: A lawyer shall not have sexual relations with a client unless a consensual sexual relationship existed before commencing representation.
CA: Applies ABA except this does not apply to spouse or registered domestic partner.
Business Transactions with Clients
A lawyer shall not enter into a business transaction with a client or knowingly acquire an interest adverse to the client, unless…
1. Terms are fair to client,
2. Terms are fully disclosed in writing (CA: lawyer’s role disclosed)
3. Client is advised in writing to seek independent counsel
4. Client gives informed written consent to essential terms.
Solicitation of Gifts from Clients
Creates a conflict between client and lawyer’s personal interests. Lawyer shall not solicit gift or prepare instrument that grants lawyer gift unless the lawyer is related to the client. CA: Lawyer may accept a gift if the client has been advised by independent counsel who prepares certificate of independent review or if gift is fair with no undue influence.
Proprietary Interest from Client
A lawyer shall not acquire a proprietary interest in the cause of action or subject matter of the litigation unless it is to:
1. Acquire a lien to secure lawyer fees, or
2. Contract with client for reasonable contingency fee in a civil case.