Professional Responsibility Flashcards
PR: Essay Approach
A lawyer owes a duty of ______ to _______.
Clients Love Fierce Counsel
Confidentiality, Loyalty, Finance, Competence
Court Feel Differently
Candor, Fairness, Dignity (Decorum)
PR: Duty of Competence
ALWAYS THROW IN
ABA: must render competent services, using legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness and preparation reasonably necessary for the representation
CA: recognizes mental, emotional, and physical ability and provides that lawyer must not intentionally, recklessly, repeatedly, or with gross negligence fail to perform legal services with reasonably competence.
May cure by:
1) learning without undue expense or delay to client; or
2) consult with a lawyer who is competent
PR: Duty of Diligence
Must be diligent and promptly pursue your case to completion.
PR: Duty of Confidentiality
A lawyer owes his client a duty not to reveal anything related to the representation of a client or use information that is not generally known to the clients disadvantage. Also, must prevent inadvertent disclose of confidential information.
PR: Exceptions to Duty of Confidentiality
Consent or Implied Authority
Prevent Death or Substantial Bodily Harm
Comply With Court Order
ABA
Prevent or Rectify Substantial Financial Loss
Defend Self or Establish Claim Against Client
Conflicts Check (may be implied authority)
Obtain Legal Ethics Advice
PR: Exception to Duty of Confidentiality-Death or Bodily Harm
Under the ABA a lawyer may reveal what is necessary to prevent an act that is reasonably certain to cause death or substantial bodily harm.
CA: Only applies to criminal acts.
PR: Exception to Duty of Confidentiality-Financial Crimes
A lawyer may disclose confidential information to prevent the client from committing crimes or fraud that will cause substantial financial harm if the client has used or is using your services to commit the crime and disclosure would prevent or mitigate substantial financial harm.
CA: NOT PERMITTED
PR: Attorney-Client Privilege
An attorney may not testify as to any communications with a client that pertain to legal services. Under ABA, continues until after client dies. Under, CA the privilege ends when client’s estate is settled and personal representative is discharged.
Exceptions
- Services used to enable to commit future crime or fraud
- Legal Services at issue
- Formerly Joint Clients
- Wills (competency or intention of client)
CA- if necessary to prevent a criminal act that lawyer reasonably believes is likely to result in a person’s substantial bodily injury or death.
PR: Duty of Loyalty - General
A lawyer owes a duty to his clients to avoid conflicts of interest. A conflict of interest arises when representation is directly adverse to the client or if there is significant risk that representation will be materially limited by lawyer’s own interest or a duty owed to a another client (past or current) or third person.
PR: Duty of Loyalty - Direct Adversity
May be directly adverse even if unrelated matters, but mere economic adversity does not amount to a direct adversity.
PR: Duty of Loyalty - Significant Risk of Material Limitation Examples
- Representation of Multiple Parties on Same Side
- Former Client Conflict
- Fiduciary Owed to Third Party.
- Lawyer’s Own Financial or Personal Interest
- Close Family Relations with Opposing Counsel
PR: Duty of Loyalty - California Required Written Disclosure
California requires a written disclosure to client when:
1) the lawyer has a prior legal, business, financial, professional, or personal relationship with a party or witness in the client’s matter
2) the lawyer is an immediate family member, lives with, is in an intimate relationship with, or is a client of another party’s attorney
even if relationship does not crate risk of material limitation.
PR: Duty of Loyalty - Informed Consent
Under the ABA, a lawyer may continue the representation, even if a conflict of interest exists, if
1) the lawyer reasonably believes that they can competently and diligently represent each client,
2) the representation does not involve one client asserting a claim against another client in the same proceeding,
3) the lawyer obtains informed consent, confirmed in writing, and
4) the representation is not prohibited by law.
Under California law, the informed consent of each party must be in writing.
PR: Duty of Loyalty-Proprietary Interest in Cause of Action
A lawyer must not acquire a proprietary interest in the cause of action of subject matter of litigation that lawyer is conducting for the client.
- unless contingency
- or lien on property for legal services as allowed by law.
No equivalent CA Rule (use business transaction rule)
PR: Duty of Loyalty - Business Transactions
First Discuss Over Coffee
A lawyer must not enter into a business transaction with a current clients:
Fair- terms must be fair to client
Disclosure- terms and lawyer’s role must be disclose to the client in writing
Outside Counsel- client should be advised that they should get independent counsel
Consent- client must give informed consent in a writing signed by the client.
PR: Duty of Loyalty- Settling Malpractice liability
Lawyer must not settle a claim or potential claim with unrepresented client or former client without:
1) advising client in writing that independent counsel is desirable AND
2) giving client a reasonable chance to consult with independent counsel
PR: Duty of Loyalty- Prospective Malpractice liability
A lawyer may limit prospective malpractice liability if client has independent representation.
CA: lawyer can cannot limit prospective malpractice liability
PR: Duty of Loyalty- Financial Assistance
Lawyer may not , except for indigent clients and advancing litigation expenses, or pro bono attorney may pay for basic living expenses.
CA: permitted for any purpose with written agreement.
PR: Duty of Loyalty- Substantial Gifts
Lawyer must not solicit a substantial gift from a client or prepare an instrument on behalf of the client giving a substantial gift to the lawyer (or the lawyer’s relative).
Does not apply if client is related to the recipient of the gift.
PR: Duty of Loyalty- Acquiring Literary or Media Rights
Lawyer must not acquire literary or media rights to a story based on current representation of client, but may acquire rights after the legal matter is entirely completed.
PR: Duty of Loyalty- Aggregate Settlement Agreement
If representing multiple client and settling, lawyer must:
1) disclose to each client existence and nature of all claims
2) each client must give informed consent in a signed writing
PR: Duty of Loyalty - Lawyer as Trial Witness?
Must not act as an advocate in a trial in which lawyer is likely to be a necessary witness unless
uncontested issue
testimony is regarding nature and value of legal services OR
ABA: withdrawal would cause substantial hardship
CA: client provides informed consent to dual role.