PROFESSIONAL ETHICS Flashcards
Rule 8.4
Defines lawyer misconduct in general. Any violation of the GRPC is also a violation of Rule 8.4, which prohibits misconduct.
If someone is making a disciplinary complaint, Rule 8.4 will always be included.
Pro Hac Vice
Temporarily authorized practice of law in a state in which a lawyer is not admitted to practice, for the purposes of providing legal services arising out of services already ongoing in the lawyer’s authorized state.
Lawyer is then subject to discipline in that state despite not being admitted.
Meant to be used occasionally and sparingly.
Lawyers are permitted to do transactions or ADR in another state temporarily and without pro hac vice statute if that is their speciality elsewhere.
False/Misleading Statements
Lawyers cannot may any “false, fraudulent, deceptive, or misleading” statements that are likely to —
- Create unjustified expectations;
- Not include the name of at least one lawyer;
- Advertise contingent fees or “no fees unless you win” without a conspicuous disclaimer that court costs are not included.
Decisions Allocated to the Client vs. the Lawyer
Client in Civil Cases — Makes the decision of whether or not to accept a settlement.
Client in Criminal Cases — Makes the decisions re: whether or not they enter a plea, waive a jury, or testify.
The lawyer is left with all technical and legal tactical decisions but must confer with the client, especially when a decision effects client expenses or third parties.
Fee Arrangements, in General
All fees must be REASONABLE and COMMUNICATED in advance. They are not required to be in writing unless it is a contingent fee.
Reasonableness factors include —
- The time/labor required;
- The novelty/complexity of the legal issue;
- What other lawyers are charging in the area;
- The preclusion of other employment;
- Experience/reputation of the lawyer;
- Whether it is a fixed or contingent fee.
Contingent Fees
Fees that require the client to only pay if there is a favorable outcome.
Not permitted for domestic relations or criminal cases.
Otherwise, they are generally valid if they are reasonable and in writing which includes the method of calculation of fees and how court costs will be integrated/taken out.
Upon conclusion of representation, the lawyer must provide a written statement including the outcome of the matter, the amount of the fee and the method of its determination.
Advertisements vs. Solicitations
Advertisements — Communicate the availability of services; are permitted as long as there is no personal targeting and are not false/misleading (“we’re the best!”).
Solicitations — Direct, personal, or live telephone communication with a prospective client for the purposes of obtaining employment for a specific matter. Not permitted.
A lawyer may not solicit, or accept employment from someone that they know was solicited directly/personally/live.
Can solicit with other lawyers, but not clients.
Written Communication with Prospective Clients (Written Solicitation)
Written communication with prospective clients must be conspicuously marked as an advertisement.
Lawyers may not make written communications to a prospective client if —
- The client has made it known that they do not want to be contacted;
- The communications includes fraud/coercion/harassment, etc.
- The communication concerns an action for personal injury or wrongful death within 30 days of the incident.
- The lawyers should know that the person is not capable of exercising reasonable judgment in obtaining a lawyer.
Duty of Competence
A lawyer shall not undertake representation that they know is beyond their level of competence without the assistance of another competent lawyer.
Competence requires legal knowledge, skill, thoroughness, and preparedness.
Emergencies may excuse temporary incompetence or unpreparedness.
Lawyers have the ability to become competent in a subject if they can do so without delay.
Duty of Diligence
Lawyer cannot willfully abandon or disregard a legal matter entrusted to them without just cause.
Diligence = Zealous advocacy.
Must maintain their workload, etc.
Duty of Communication
Lawyer must keep client informed. This includes —
- Promptly responding to reasonable requests for information;
- Explaining matters to the client to the extent reasonably necessary for them to make informed decisions;
- Communicating all settlement offers promptly.
Keyword — “Reasonable” communication.
Duty of Confidentiality
Ethical duty of confidentiality protects ALL information relating to the representation, regardless of the source.
This is opposed to the evidentiary attorney-client privilege, which only protects information obtained directly from the client, in a judicial setting in which the attorney is being asked to testify.
The duty of confidentiality is an affirmative obligation to keep the client’s information confidential unless authorized in writing.
Confidential information may be disclosed without written consent to prevent substantial financial or physical harm, to establish a defense against the attorney, or if inquired by the court.
Duty extends after the attorney client relationship has ended.
Disclosing Confidential Information
Confidential information may be disclosed with written and informed consent, or without written consent to (1) prevent substantial financial or physical harm, (2) to establish a defense against the attorney, or (3) if inquired by the court.
Conflicts of Interest, in General
Lawyers are prohibited from undertaking representation where their personal interests or duties to another client, former client, or third party would MATERIALLY and ADVERSELY affect their representation.
Lawyer has a duty to devote their undivided loyalty to their client. Personal interests, interests of third parties, or interests of other clients have the potential to dilute that loyalty, creating a conflict of interest.
Consenting to a Conflict of Interest
A lawyer may represent a client despite a material and adverse conflict if all the affected clients give their
(1) informed consent in writing, after
(2) consultation with the lawyer,
(3) receiving written information regarding the risks of the conflict, and
(4) being given the opportunity to consult with independent counsel.
As long as the conflict is consentable.
Nonconsentable Conflicts of Interests
Clients CANNOT consent to a conflict if —
- Representation would violate the law or GRPC (criminal co-∆);
- Representation involves a claim by one client against another client represented by the same lawyer in the same or substantially similar proceeding;
- The lawyer cannot provide adequate representation (usually for personal reason).