Privacy, Confidentiality, and Privilege Flashcards
CALIFORNIA LAWS THAT GUIDE THE SPECIFICS OF CLINICAL PRACTICE
What is confidentiality?
Confidentiality is the patient’s right to have communications kept within the bounds of the professional patient-therapist relationship.
What is privilege?
Privilege, or testimonial privilege, is the patient’s right to keep confidential communications from being disclosed in a legal proceeding.
What is the key distinction between confidentiality and privilege?
Confidentiality involves keeping the therapist-patient information in confidence such that no person outside of the therapy relationship has access to the information (e.g., the patient’s spouse, employer, friend). In general, privilege involves keeping the patient-therapist information in confidence specifically during a legal proceeding.
There are two basic principles that apply to lawful and ethical disclosure of confidential information. What are they?
Disclosure should never come as a surprise, and disclosure should only include information that is necessary and sufficient.
What are the seven situations in which confidentiality may be broken?
- With patient consent
- In treatment emergencies
- In safety emergencies
- Quality care reviews
- The legal system
- Crimes involving hospitalized patients
- Mandatory reporting situations.
- For treatment purposes, in situations where the providers work in the same facility
Written consent to disclose confidential information must include what information?
Written consent must include:
- the name of the person authorized to disclose the information
- the individual or agency to whom the disclosure may be made
- the date of consent
- Any limitations on what information may be released or how the information may be used.
What are treatment emergencies?
A situation in which a therapist may breach confidentiality.
Treatment emergencies are situations in which information must be shared with health care providers to protect a patient from immediate physical harm.
For example, a therapist receives a phone call from emergency room personnel stating that the therapist’s patient has attempted a drug overdose. The therapist would be allowed to breach the patient’s confidentiality to reveal any information relevant to the patient’s immediate care, including information about the patient’s illicit drug use, as well as any prescribed psychotropic medication the patient is taking.
What are safety emergencies?
A situation in which a therapist may breach confidentiality.
Safety emergencies involve situations in which the safety of the patient or another person is of concern.
The most common safety emergencies include potential suicide and violence. Grave disability is also considered a safety emergency.
When an employer is paying for mental health care for its employees, what types of information can they have access to?
- Information that is relevant in a lawsuit (when the patient has raised the issue of his or her physical or mental health)
- Information on session attendance
- information that describes the patient’s functional limitations (which may entitle the patient to miss work or limit the patient’s fitness to perform at work)
However, the psychologist may not disclose the basis for the patient’s limitations (e.g., the patient’s diagnosis), or any other confidential patient information or communication.
Who may be the holder of privilege?
- The patient
- The guardian or conservator: When the patient lacks legal capacity, and has a guardian or conservator, the guardian or conservator is the holder of privilege.
- The patients personal representative: If the patient is dead, the personal representative of the patient may be the holder of privilege.
Who can claim or invoke privilege in legal proceedings?
- The holder of privilege
- Any person authorized by the holder of privilege
- The psychotherapist
How does privilege work when more than one patient holds it? For example, in couples therapy…
When more than one patient holds the privilege (e.g., in couples therapy), one patient waiving privilege does not affect the other patient’s right to claim privilege.
Under what circumstance does a patient involuntarily waive privilege?
Privilege is waived, any time a confidential communication is disclosed by the patient to unauthorized third persons.
For example, a patient tells his neighbor he raped a woman, and that he has shared this with his therapist. Should there be a legal proceeding, this specific information would no longer be privileged.
EVIDENCE CODE 1016
No privilege exists in proceedings in which the patient (or any party claiming through or under the patient) raises the issue of the patient’s mental or emotional condition (e.g., worker’s compensation suit alleging stress secondary to employment).
Thus, if a patient is claiming emotional suffering, the patient may not keep therapy records outside of the court, because these records may prove significant in the court’s decision making process.
EVIDENCE CODE 1017
No privilege exists when the therapist is appointed by the court or by the Board of Prison Terms to examine the patient
EVIDENCE CODE 1023
Privilege doesn’t exist in a proceeding initiated at the request of a defendant in a criminal action suit to determine his or her sanity
EVIDENCE CODE 1025
There is no privilege in proceedings brought by the patient to establish his or her competence
When do the exceptions to privilege, established by evidence code 1017, 1023, and 1025, not apply?
This exception to privilege doesn’t apply when the therapist is appointed by the court specifically to provide the criminal defendant’s lawyer with information upon which to base the defense. In other words, if the purpose of the exam is to help the lawyer and defendant put together their legal strategy, the information may remain in confidence between the lawyer and his or her client.
EVIDENCE CODE 1018
No privilege exists if the services of a therapist were sought or obtained to aid anyone to commit a crime or to escape detection or apprehension after commission of a crime. Thus, a patient may not invoke privilege in an effort to hide civil or criminal wrongdoing from the courts.
EVIDENCE CODE 1019
There is no privilege regarding communication that is specifically relevant to an issue between parties, who all claim through a deceased patient
EVIDENCE CODE 1021
There is no privilege with regard to communication concerning a deceased patient’s intent related to a deed, will, or other document executed by the patient, affecting an interest in property
EVIDENCE CODE 1022
There is no privilege with regard to communication concerning the validity of a deceased patient’s deed, will, or other document executed by the patient, that affects an interest in property
EVIDENCE CODE 1020
No privilege exists when either the therapist or the patient alleges a breach of duty (e.g., malpractice suit initiated by the patient, use of a collection agency by the therapist because of nonpayment by the patient).
Thus, if a patient sues a therapist for negligence, the professional may use the therapy records in his or her defense.
EVIDENCE CODE 1024
No privilege exists in a LEGAL proceeding, if the disclosure is necessary to prevent the danger presented by the patient to himself, others, or property