Pressure Groups Flashcards
How did Robert Baggott describe pressure groups?
Organisation which seeks to influence the details of public policies and which is not a faction of a recognised political party
How did Wynn Grant describe pressure groups?
Public policy representing a set of authoritative decisions taken by the executive and the judiciary, and by local government and the EU
What is the main discriminator between pressure groups and parties?
Parties purpose to exercise power - they stand in elections
Pressure groups purpose to influence those who have power - they do not stand in elections.
When did a local pressure group stand in Kidderminster?
2001 - campaigning on behalf of the hospital - Richard Taylor won the election
Example of a pressure group who adopts a broad approach to public policy?
Greenpeace campaign on a range of environmental issues
What role did RSPCA play in policy?
Integral during the “hunting with dogs act” - argued the sport was cruel on the animals
How have the RSPCA played a role in enforcing policy?
Hunting with dogs act - been policing the ban to ensure it is enforced
Why was Snowdrop formed?
1996 - Dunblane massacre in a school - formed by bereaved parents - wanted to bring a ban on handguns
What was the impact of Snowdrop?
1997: partial ban. 1998: full ban.
What do pressure groups do?
Lobby the executive and the legislature but now with devolution, they have to lobby all levels of government
Where do pressure groups turn to more?
Judiciary through judicial review
Example of a pressure group who uses the courts?
Liberty and Countryside Alliance
What is the governing function of pressure groups?
Advising the government, civil servants and parties in the formulation of legislation and public policy.
Can government function without pressure groups?
No
What do pressure groups provide>
Specialist knowledge and advice - many civil servants have little knowledge of the areas of government in which they work
Example of a pressure group with expertise?
Road Haulage Association: Explains the consequences of government decisions and what needs to be implemented to combat the issues.
What is the representative function of pressure groups?
Representing causes and specific sections of society.
What is the education function of pressure groups?
Informing the public (and politicians) about important issues.
Experts in the fields, people journalists go to in order to get their information.
What is the participatory function of pressure groups?
Providing an opportunity for democratic participation.
What has happened to pressure group membership in the UK?
Increased
What do sectional groups represent?
Sectional groups represent their members and campaign in their interests.
What is membership of sectional groups like?
Self-limited to members of that particular profession or trade.
Example of sectional groups?
National Farmer Union - farmers.
National Education Union - teachers
What do sectional groups do?
Protect and promote the interests of their members - advance their sector - functioning to get the best possible outcome
What is the expectation of a union?
That they will support you
What are causal groups?
Also know as interest, cause, promotional group.
Exist to promote, represent a particular cause - economic, political etc.
What is membership for causal groups like?
Open to everyone who is interested in their cause - can be a member of multiple groups
How are causal groups seen?
Selfless - they’re not self serving, they’re working for a cause and helping others in society or others in the abstract (environment, landscape etc.)
Example of a Causal group?
Fathers4Justice: Pressure group active until the early 2000s. Separated fathers campaigning for access rights. Direct Action to achieve their aim of making a point.
What is a sectional causal group?
Aim to protect the interests of a particular section of society.
Examples of sectional causal groups?
The Child Poverty Action Group which seeks to combat child poverty.
The Joseph Rowntree foundation fighting on the issue of child poverty. If your household income is below 60% of median earnings after household costs, you are considered poor.
Mencap, campaigning for people with mental illnesses.
What is an attitude causal group?
Seek to change the attitudes about a particular issue.
Examples of attitude causal groups?
Greenpeace which seeks to change attitudes on the environment.
Stonewall: LGBTQ+ rights.
What is a political causal group?
Seek to change the political process or seek constitutional reform
Example of a political causal group?
Charter 88
What is the issue of classification of pressure groups?
Groups often defy simple classification since they cut across the two categories e.g. trade unions.
What are common misassumptions abut sectional groups?
More influential and better resourced than causal groups- this is not always the case.
What is a misassumption about causal and sectional groups?
Misassumption that causal groups are “good” whereas sectional groups are “bad”.
Example of pressure group being wrong?
Brent spar: Shell (oil company) announced that one of the oil platforms had reached the end of its working life. Proposal to tow it out and sink it 4 miles down. Greenpeace (and others) went insane. Sent people to tie themselves onto the oil rig, stormed Shell headquarters. In the end, Shell backed down, agreeing to decommission on land, even if it would cause more environmental issues than sinking it. Greenpeace came out and admitted that they were wrong.
What is an insider group?
Groups that the government regards as legitimate and are consequently given access to the decision making process. They have regular access to ministers and civil servants and might be consulted at the consultation stage of policy.
What is the expectation of insider groups?
They play by the rule in return for regular and privileged access
What key question should be asked about insiders?
Elitism or pluralism?
What are core insiders?
Closest and most regular access to government, no matter who is in power. They may include institutions within the state apparatus and external groups.
Example of a core insider
The NFU - cosey relationship with the Tory party - however worked hard with Labour with the foot and mouth disease outbreak
What are specialist insiders?
Groups which are regularly consulted for their expert knowledge.
Example of specialist insiders?
The AA
RAC - tell ministers the effect of decisions and legislation.
What are peripheral insiders?
Groups which are consulted infrequently or which carry little influence.
Example of a peripheral insider?
Greenpeace
Why is achieving insider status not difficult?
Government will routinely consult hundred of groups on a regular basis
Why does the government consult pressure groups so frequently?
Their input is essential to the effective formulation of public policy.
What is good public policy always?
Consultative. Those who make laws that should serve the people should be prepared to listen to groups who have knowledge on matters.
Why are governments blinkered?
Public policy is seen through a lense of ideology