Elections and referendums Flashcards
Where does direct democracy originate?
Athenian State
How does direct democracy work?
Putting a propositions directly to voters for resolution - most referendums seek to elicit a yes/no response to a question asked.
Why is the UK a newcomer to direct democracy?
Seen as a blunt instrument and a breeder for dictators
When was direct democracy first used in the UK>
1970s
How do some people view direct democracy?
As a way of involving citizens in key national or constitutional decisions.
How do others see direct democracy?
A way of “fixing” the shortcomings of representative democracy.
How did parties on the left see referendums in the 1990s?
A way of increasing participation and adding legitimacy to a range of planned constitutional changes
Who argues for the strengths of direct democracy?
Progressive Parties
What do people view direct democracy as?
The will of the people - greater democratic legitimacy
Example of legitimate direct democracy
Good Friday Agreement referendum
What was the issue with Brexit?
Vote Leave broke electoral law and neither side covered themselves in glory over truthfulness
What was the turnout of the 1997 Welsh referendum?
50.1%
What was the result of the Welsh referendum?
50.3% for devolution - lacks legitimacy
What is a benefit of direct democracy?
Increase public engagement - lead to discussion of national significance
Example of highly significant discussion
Scottish Independence
Example of a insignificant discussion
Greater London Assembly
What is the benefit of a binary choice?
Simple questions and simple answers
What is an exception to the simple question rule?
Brexit - no one knew what brexit meant
What do referendums do?
Increase political education - brings awareness through research and campaigning
Example of widening education
Scottish Independence - research from both sides lead to scrutiny
How can referendum results be overturned?
With another referendum
What is the impact of this?
Can entrench constitutional change
What kind of response do referendums provide?
Clear response on a political questions - governments can avoid expensive and unpopular measures
Why doesn’t the UK use referendums to resolve moral issues?
Powers still remain with parliamentarans
Who supported the Yes Scotland Campaign?
SNP and Greens
Who supported the Better Together campaign?
Labour, Tories and Lib Dems
What caused a growth in independence for Scotland?
Brexit
Who supported Vote Leave?
Cummings, UKIP, Tory ministers, Boris, Gove
Why was the Brexit referendum called?
Pressure on Cameron after 2015
When was the Welsh devolution referendum?
1997
What is a critique of direct democracy?
Not a practical way to run a modern state - can’t quickly resolve a lot of issues
What do referendums undermine?
Parliamentary sovereignty and elected representatives - risks the tyranny of the majority
What did Mill believe?
Representative democracy was a moderator of public views.
What undermines legitimacy?
Low turnout
What can happen in referendums?
Dominated by one sided debate - public funding or media coverage - tends to adopt a certain position
What is the significance of the wording of the question?
Can influence the outcome - 1998 London GLA
How can some people vote?
Basis of emotions rather than practical considerations
What is the view of Tories on referendums?
Traditionally opposed to direct democracy but under recent leaders like Howard and Cameron, they came to see referendums as a way of managing Euroscepticism in the party and harnessing Euroscepticism in the wider electorate.
What is the Labour view on referendums?
Blair and Brown were in favour of referendums and made widespread use of them as a means of securing legitimacy for constitutional reform.
What is the Lib Dems view on referendums?
Consistently the most enthusiastic party in regards to referendums at every level of decision making.
What is Rational Choice theory?
Assumes voters will make a rational or logical choice based upon what is in their own best interest.
What is the ideal world for rational choice theory?
Fully informed about the range of options - they will then choose the option which is right for them
What doesn’t sit well with rational choice theory?
Voters are politically ignorant - however people do know what’s right and wrong
What does aggregating people’s choices do?
Means the winning view will reflect what is best for society as a whole
What is issue voting?
Voters choose the party or candidate which best reflects their own opinion on an issue they consider more important than all others
What is valence issue voting?
The economy is often the key factor influencing voting behaviour, with voters supporting the party or candidate most trusted to deliver prosperity (no one is going to vote to be poorer)
What is valence issue linked to?
Perceptions of governing competency
What has challenges the idea of competence?
Populism
What has given rise to a range of other factors influencing voting behaviour?
Partisan and class dealignment
What do voters compare in terms of policies?
Voters comparing contrasting party manifestos, choosing the one which suits them best
What is comparing policies an example of?
Rational Choice theory
What do voters asses in terms of issues?
Voters focussing on the policies parties have and again making a rational choice on which party or candidate is “strongest”
Example of key issues?
Immigration and crime
What does looking at record in office do?
Turning elections into a kind of “referendum” on their performance, this example of valence issues driving
What is the impact of looking at leadership?
Politics taking a more presidential feel since the 60s - much more focus is given to personal qualities and even appearance with voters seeking strong, competent and charismatic leaders.
What is also important in looking at?
Image of party unity being key in decision making - if a leader cannot lead their party, they are seen as weak, but if a party is at war with itself, it is seen as incapable of governing the country.
What often happens in constituencies?
Tactical Voting: a feature in recent elections in the UK, especially in 1997, though this is consequence of the limited options available to voters under FPTP.
Where do the conservatives dominate?
Rural and suburban votes
Where do Labour dominate?
Urban and metropolitan area - lost group of the small towns
Who dominates in scotland?
SNP - usurped Labour since 2005
What is the nature of Lib dem support?
Distributed across the UK
Where is support for UKIP and greens focussed?
Particular communities
What was a key influencer on voting behaviour?
Class - not so much now
What blurred the line between the working and middle classes?
Embourgeoisement in the 1980s
WHta started to matter more than class?
Economic and social issues
Who found it hardest to adapt to the new landscape?
Labour
What happened to the aggregate share of the vote for the Tories and Labour after 1970?
Declined
What did class dealignment allow?
New parties emerge that cut across class lines
Which campaigns relied on the ability to broaden the social base of their party?
Thatcher and Blair
Who are “Left behind voters”?
Not directly benefitting from globalisation and have borne the brunt of austerity since the global financial crisis - older, white, less well-off, less educated and non-metropolitan.
How do Left behind voters tend to vote?
Not labour - sees it as dominated by a metropolitan, highly educated liberal elite
Why do they vote for Tories?
Immigration
What was key to the success of Heath and Thatcher?
Housewife vote
Who enjoyed the female vote in 1997?
Blair
How has the female vote been split in recent years?
Pretty equally
What issues do women favour Labour for?
Health and education
What Brown and Blair programme appealed to women?
Surestart
What is the trend in terms of age?
Older you are, more right leaning - younger is more left - reflects very different social and cultural values
Who is more likely to vote?
Older voters
What is the greater influence of older voters called?
Grey Lobby
What areas do parties focus on because of the grey lobby?
Immigration, health, pensions and crime
Where do younger voters tend to congregate?
Met areas
What does the participation of older voters mean for labour?
Make it harder for Labour - continue to gain big margins in met areas by can’t cut through with the oldies
How do BAME voters tend to vote?
Labour
Why do BAME voters vote progressively?
Cultural legacy of conservatism in the 20th century which often sounded anti-immigrant and hostile to multi-culturalism - the ideas of Enoch Powell and Norman Tebbit.
Why has there been an increase in black voters voting conservative?
Higher paying jobs - look at economic policies
What has hindered both parties?
Issues of Islamophobia and Anti-semitism
What is the trend with education?
Those less educated are less likely to vote for progressive parties, more educated you are the less likely you are to vote for the Tories.
What is a central pillar of liberal democracy?
Free media
What role does the media play?
Providing knowledge, holding all three branches of the government to account
Who restricts the BBC?
Ofcom
What faces fewer regulations?
Print media - conservative bias
What is the concern with online media?
Toxic nature of online debate
What are the worst offenders of bias?
Tabloids - mockery and ridicule rather than informed debate.
What have many newspapers focussed too much on?
Personality vs Policy
What exacerbated the focus on personality and image?
Move towards televised leaders’ debate in 2010
When was the media valuable?
Issues like MPs expenses, investigative journalism played a key role in exposing wrongdoing and holding public office holders to account
Which media-owners have huge amounts of influence?
Lord Rothermere, Barclay Brothers and Murdoch