practical strategies and material for informal assessment of ELLs w/ potential LI Flashcards
FOUNDATIONAL PRINCIPLES
- Nonstandardized assessment increases ecological validity
- Relates more to the child’s actual environment, and language needed there, than standardized testing does
he Assessment Wheel (p. 277)demonstrates an ideal approach to comprehensive assessment
-This does take some time, but is worth it because typically-developing ELL students are much less likely to be mislabeled and placed into speech-language and/or other special education services
Evaluate the Student’s Communication Skills in a Variety of Setting
-Use multiple observations in naturalistic settings
-Observe the student’s ability to communicate successfully at home, in the classroom, on the playground, in the cafeteria, and other settings
Many variables make it challenging to assess young ELLs
-A phenomenal resource: Tabors, P.O. (2008). One child, two languages: A guide for early childhood educators of children learning English as a second language (2nd ed.). Baltimore: Paul H. Brookes Publishing Company.
-Barrueco, S., Lopez, M., Ong, C., & Lozano, P. (2012). Assessing Spanish-English bilingual preschoolers. Baltimore: Brookes Publishing.
Popular current measures (can use parts):
Hawaii Early Learning Profile
Preschool Language Scale-5 (Spanish)
Ages and Stages Questionnaire (parent and teacher interview, for 1-66 months old, 2-3 minutes to score; Brookes Publishing)
Communication and Symbolic Behavior Scales Developmental Profile (9 mos-6 yrs)
McArthur-Bates Communicative
Development Inventories (Spanish
and English) (only this on test 3)
USE A PRE-EVALUATION PROCESS
- Gather the case history. Be sure to include language history.
- Use questionnaires and interviews with individuals who are familiar with the student (e.g., teachers, parents, interpreters)
- Ascertain the student’s language proficiency in L1 and English
A wonderful new parent questionnaire has been developed in Canada:
Alberta Language and Development Questionnaire (AlDeQ) (Paradis, Emmerzael, & Sorenson Duncan, 2010)
http://www.chesl.ualberta.ca
PORTFOLIO ASSESSMENT
A portfolio contains materials by and information about a student
Portfolios help teams judge a student’s ability to learn over time when provided with instruction
Use the Informal Measure of Oral Language Skills
- This is what I usually use to obtain a language sample from the student
- It can be administered in English or in any other language
Narrative Assessment
The child can create a story, or the clinician can tell a story and ask the child to tell it back (150 words for 5-8 year olds)
zaretsky, ASHA`
- for narrative assessment, you can use 4 pictures in sequence
- story recall ability is a deficit for L1 students
When the student tells a story
- Does she organize it in such a way that the listener understands the general story sequence?
- Does she give comments or explanations that are relevant or irrelevant to the story?
- If the student is re-telling a story originally told by the speech-language pathologist, does she REMEBER both major and specific DETAILS?
- Does the student use appropriate syntax and vocabulary, even in L1?
remember…
Different cultures have different rules for telling stories
Gorman, Fiestas, Pena, & Clark (2011). Creative and stylistic devices employed by children during a storybook task: A cross-cultural study. Language, Speech, and Hearing Services in Schools
-Goal of study: to assess CULTURAL VARIATIONS in STORYTELLING when children were presented with wordless picture books
60 first and second grade Caucasian, Hispanic, and African American children
Important to examine this topic because NARRATIVE SKILLS are very predictive of SCHOOL SUCCESS
Gorman et al 2011 found that
- African american ch included more fantasy in stories
- hispanic ch named characters more often
- white ch talked more about relationships between characters
Soodla & Kikas (2010; Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research)
Examined the macrostructure of Estonian children’s narratives to determine if there were differences in narrative macrostructure between typically-developing (TD) and language impaired (LI) children
The TD children were much better than the LI children at starting stories; the TD children also had significantly more quantity of information in their stories than the LI children
Rezzonico, S. et al. (2016). Narratives in two languages: Storytelling of Bilingual Cantonese-English Preschoolers. Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research, 59, 521-532
Looked at 4-5 year old bilingual English-Cantonese children in Canada
Rezzonico et al., 2016 looked at
- macro structure of narratives
- macrostructure: story is thematically coherent
- events are properly sequenced
- microstrucutre: appropriate language complexity
- looking at # of utterances, # of total words, # of different words, sentence length
Rezzonico et al., 2016 looked at pt 2
- there is a transfer of narrative skills (macro & micro structure) between catonese and english
- evaluating narrative skills in both languages is a valuable diagnostic task
so we know that
-assessment of ch narrative skills is very promising –> differentiating lang difference from impairment in ELLs
Evaluate RAN (Rapid Automatic Naming) Skills
Assessment of RAN skills provides information about the student’s SPEED and ORGANIZATION OF THOUGHT
Research has demonstrated that individuals with dyslexia have difficulty with this task
RAN tests are best for children who are ages 5 yrs. and over
RAN assessment works with ELLs too!
research shows that
If ELL students have difficulty with RAN, there is a distinct possibility of dyslexia/reading disabilities
More research ELL population
Assess Associated Motor Behaviors
- Research suggests that students who have learning disabilities may manifest:
- Poor coordination or awkwardness
- Difficulty copying from the chalk/whiteboard
- POOR HANDWRITING
- CLUMSINESS, poor balance
- Difficulty manipulating small objects
- Trouble learning to tie shoes, button shirts, other SELF-HELP activities
Assess Reading Fluency
-Reading FLUENCY (or lack thereof) is an important potential indicator of a learning disability
-Fluency: how fast a ch reads, # of words per minute
-DIBELS (Dynamic Indicators of Basic Early Literacy Skills) (Good & Kaminski, 2002)
-Assesses READING FLUENCY in a number of areas
http://dibels.uoregon.edu
Assess Language Processing Capacity/Information Processing Skills
- Research has suggested that students with true LI have difficulty retaining the SEQUENTIAL ORDER OF INFORMATION
- LI students have specific difficulties on tasks that require verbatim, immediate ordered recall