PPS week Flashcards
What happened during the Montgomery case?
Child of diabetic mother was born with serious disability due to shoulder dystocia that the doctor had not told her was a risk of vaginal delivery so the mother still had a vaginal delivery. Judge ruled the doctor should have explained the risks
What questions must a doctor ask themselves about informed consent?
Does the patient know about the material risks of the
treatment I am proposing?
Does the patient know about reasonable alternatives to this treatment?
Have I taken reasonable care to ensure that the patient actually knows this?
What does article 8 involve?
The right to respect for privacy and family life, even in end of life care. (qualified)
What did the Tracey case involve?
DNACPR given without discussion with the patient nd the trust was sued
What are the things that have changed due to the Tracey case?
Patients (or their families) will be included sensitively and compassionately in DNACPR decisions.
Where consultation is expected to cause psychological anguish or distress (but not actual harm) doctors may avoid a DNACPR decision even where resuscitation will be futile
What factors come into play when considering rationing healthcare?
Clinical, value based and socio-psychological.
What is the libertarian approach?
Each is responsible for their own health, well being and fulfilment of life plan
What is Article 2?
The right to life (limited)
What is Article 3?
The right to be free from inhuman and degrading treatment (absolute)
What is Article 12?
The right to marry and found a family
What did the Kerry Wooltorton case involve?
She committed suicide, wrote a note saying she didn’t want any life-saving treatment, but she wanted to be kept pain free. Judge ruled that she should be allowed to die
What is the Bolam test?
A test that arose from English tort law, which is used to assess medical negligence. Bolam holds that the law imposes a duty of care between a doctor and his patient, but the standard of that care is a matter of medical judgement. It states that if a doctor has acted according to proper and accepted practice, he is not guilty of medical negligence.
What is the Bolitho test?
The defence could not be considered reasonable if the body of doctors or supporting witnesses were not capable of withstanding logical analysis.
When are DOLS needed?
The Mental Capacity Act allows restraint and restrictions to be used – but only if they are in a person’s best interests. Extra safeguards are needed if the restrictions and restraint used will deprive a person of their liberty. These are called the Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards.
Where can DOLS be used?
The Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards can only be used if the person will be deprived of their liberty in a care home or hospital. In other settings the Court of Protection can authorise a deprivation of liberty.
What are the types of error regarding patient safety?
Sloth Fixation and loss of perspective Communication breakdown Poor team working Playing the odds Bravado Ignorance Mis-triage Lack of skill System error
What is an example of a sloth error?
Not bothering to check results/information for accuracy. Incomplete evaluation. Inadequate documentation.
What attribute is used to prevent a sloth error and an example of how to put that into practice?
Conscientiousness. Attention to detail. Completeness. Not assuming that information presented to you is correct. Full documentation.
What is an example of fixation and loss of perspective?
Early unshakeable focus on a diagnosis. Inability to see the bigger picture. Overlooking warning signs.
What attribute is used to prevent fixation and loss of perspective and examples of how to put that into practice?
Open mindedness. Situational awareness. Recognition of the clinical patterns but considering facts that don’t fit. Re- evaluation if deviation from the expected.
What is an example of communication breakdown?
Unclear instructions or plans. Not listening to or considering others opinions.
What attribute is used to prevent communication breakdown and examples of how to put that into practice?
Effective communication. Being approachable and open. Listening. Clear explanation with appropriate terminology and reinforcement.
What is an example of poor team working?
Team members working independently. Poor direction. Some individuals out of depth, others underutilised.
What attribute is used to prevent poor team working and examples of how to put that into practice?
Good team working. Clear team structure and roles with sharing of views, concerns and management plans. Clear logical leadership.
What is an example of playing the odds?
Choosing the common and dismissing the rare event.
What attribute is used to prevent playing the odds and examples of how to put that into practice?
Probability assessment. Evaluation based on scenario features as well and likelihood
What is an example of bravado?
Working beyond your competence or without adequate supervision. A show of confidence to hide underlying deficiencies (not taking on that which you should)
What attribute is used to prevent bravado and examples of how to put that into practice?
Humility. Accurate self evaluation. Open communication of mistakes
What is an example an ignorance?
Lack of knowledge. Unconscious incompetence. Not knowing what you don’t know.
What attribute is used to prevent ignorance and examples of how to put that into practice?
Self-awareness. Aware of your own abilities and limitations. Consideration of factors which may affect your judgement (e.g., stress, fatigue)
What is an example of mis-triage?
Over/underestimating the seriousness of a situation.
What attribute is used to prevent mis-triage and examples of how to put that into practice?
Prioritisation. Appreciation of the relative importance or urgency of each situation.