Power / Ideology (AS) Flashcards
Summarize Althusser’s main characteristics of ideology
Ideology
- constitutes concrete individuals as subjects
> interpellation
- is trans-historical
> immutable in form throughout history - is a material practice
> what is done
> ideology is lived - is difficult to spot
> naturalized, universal, timeless
> doubtless validity
> curved logic: ready made answers to questions that haven’t been asked - is everywhere (omnipresent)
> culture is part of ideology
> culture fulfills ideological functions
> culture sustains ideology - ideology has a mission
> ideological projects
> presents imaginary solutions to problems that only exist to be solved - ideology is present in all that is obvious to us
> commonplaces and truisms - ideology presents partial truths
> omissions, gaps, smoothed-over contradictions
> seemingly answers questions, that in reality are evaded
> masquerades as coherence
Explain the ideological project as discussed by Macherey
- surface problems (explicit, obvious)
- imaginary solutions
Ideological project:
- actual problem
- implicit
Explain how figuration plays a role in ideology
ideology is abstract > translation into concrete situations, characters etc. through figuration > opens up room for questions > ideology can not be flawless > ideology lags behind on history
NOTE
ideology has difference inscribed in it
List the three steps of Althusser’s ideology critique
task: deconstruct text to reveal problematic through symptomatic reading
- identifying ideological project
> focus on surface problems and their ideological solutions - symptomatic reading
> looks at questions that haven’t been asked and/or answers to questions that haven’t been posed
> similar methodology as deconstruction, psychoanalysis - identifying “real” problem(s)
> using the findings of symptomatic reading
> establishing limits of ideology in dealing with them
NOTE
ideology critique needs to mistrust surface problems as they are part of the ideological project and only there to be solved
Explain how gaps / absences play a role in recognizing the ideological project (problematic)
- it is through gaps and absences that we are pointed in the direction of the ideological project
- surface problems are addressed > imaginary solutions
- actual problem is hinted at in answers to questions that haven’t been asked
Explain the role of the surface problem for ideology
surface problem exists so it can be solved by ideology (imaginary solution)
Explain the role of Althusser’s ISA’s in ideology
representation and reproduction of myths and beliefs necessary to enable people to work within the existing social formation
ISA’s ensure the status quo is kept in place:
- ideology works through ISAs
- teaching through ideological means
> makes interpellation possible
> ISA’s interpellate us!
- vicious cycle of teaching and interpellation
> we accept interpellation because we have been taught to
- acceptance of status in society / as subject
> construction of people as subjects
> subject as destination of all ideology
NOTE
interpellation and ideology are present on all levels of society
List the main ISA’s in 20th century capitalist formations
Education
Family
Religion (has lost in importance acc. to Althusser; has been replaced by education)
Explain Althusser’s concept of the subject
subject: both individual & subjected
- the subject is dominated, subjected by a force larger than itself: Subject
- illusion of power (subject, not object!)
- self-identification:
> Subject is created by subject
> subjects considers themselves made by Subject
> subjects identify with Subject
Explain why Althusser’s concept of the subject is double speculary
the subject mirrors / recognises him/herself in both the Subject and other subjects
Explain the role of interpellation in Althusser’s concept of the subject
individuals are constituted as subjects through interpellation
subject constructed in language and ideology
> subject-constitution as process of recognition of one’s role
subject is always already interpellated
> expectations before birth
> expectations before conception
NOTE
Althusser needs this concept to confirm his theory that we are all constructs
Can one refuse interpellation?
Very difficult: by refusing interpellation one often becomes subject to another interpellation
> ideological choice (Belsey, 1980)
List some elements of camp
essence of camp:
love of the unnatural: of artifice and exaggeration
- so bad it’s good
- exaggeration > too much
- dissolves boundaries between categories
- logic of excess
- many forms: production, consumption etc.
NOTE
predates other concepts doing the same by about 50 years!
NOTE
what is camp? the moment something is discussed within the context of camp it becomes camp
Explain how camp helps us create an ideology critique
- camp defies fix ideology
- dissolves boundaries, helping us look beyond them
- positioned outside established norms, helping us see those norms
Summarise Althusser’s two definitions of ideology
1) a system (with its own logic and rigour) of representations (images, myths, ideas, concepts) - a practice through which men and women live their relations to the real conditions of existence
2) the way we live our relationship to the real conditions of existence at the level of representations (real conditions vs. our representations of these conditions)
Explain Althusser’s concept of ‘the problematic’
‘the problematic’ consists of assumptions, motivations, underlying ideas etc from which a text is made
> structured as much by what is absent as by what is present
> fixes meaning and movement of problems and thereby of solutions
> to fully understand meaning we have to be aware of both text and assumptions that inform it
> encourages posed questions to be answered and produces deformed answers to questions it attempts to exclude
> revealed in answers to questions that haven’t been formally posed
NOTE
posing a question within a problematic means allowing a ready made solution to recognise itself
Explain how symptomatic reading is a double reading
- reading the manifest text
- producing and reading the latent text through lapses, distortions, silences and absences (symptoms of problem struggling to be posed)