Politics of the World: Autumn Flashcards
What is the process for a scientific test?
Observation, theory, hypothesis
Experiment, replicate
What is a case study?
Careful in depth study of country
What is the Small N method?
Compare 2 similar countries to see why different outcomes occurred. Choice of Most similar system design or method of difference
Small N study example?
Algeria v Bahrain (neither in Arab Spring)
- Poor multi party autocracy v wealthy monarchy
What is a large N study?
When lots of data sets are used and statistical analysis applied to try and predict state behaviour
What did C Q G say about study of politics?
“Collection of facts not certainties”
Popper on scientific study?
Must be “Recklessly critical”
Define nation?
A group of people sharing a common identity
Weber’s definition of state?
“A human community that successfully claims the monopoly of the legitimate use of physical force within a given territory”
Define regime?
Set of rules/procedures for electing national leaders and policies
Are states and nations the same thing?
No many nations are possible within states (UK, Brazil, Canada)
What are diasporas?
People living outside their origin country
What are stateless nations?
Jews? Roma? Kurdish?
Community groups that share a common identity but haven’t got control of a territory
Examples of international recognition and its role of creating states?
Quasi- states (e.g. Palestine): Recognised by the international community but doesn’t have control of its territory
De facto states: (e.g Moldova- Transnistria): Full state capacity but no legal (de jure) existence
What is a failed state?
State-like entity that cannot coerce/control inhabitants in a given territory (e.g. Somalia, ruling clans, no law/order)
Define institutions?
Organisations that create, enforce and apply the law. Constrain actors behaviour.
Nettl 1968 quote on the state?
“The thing exists and no amount of conceptual restructuring can dissolve it”
What does Block (1996) say about state power?
Eroded by the “dictatorship of international financial markets”
What does Rodrik (1996) say about the size of governments?
Countries more exposed to trade have bigger governments
What did Ruggie say in 1982 about the global economic system?
“Embedded liberalism”
Balance of free trade and welfare programmes
What is the contractarian view of the state?
- State of nature existed before states (Hobbes ‘war of all against all’). “Life was solitary poor and brutish”
- Sovereign is scary, coerces people into following the law (as long as it stops conflict)
- People exchange natural rights for civil rights
What is the predatory view of the state?
States meant to protect but are in fact the greatest source of threat by exploiting the social contract. Demand taxes/laws to protect them from themselves
-If we are all nasty in the state of nature why would the state behave well?
What did Wiltford, 1957, say made civilisation?
Resource scarcity made civilisation possible
What does Tilly (1985) believe makes states?
States are made through conflict
“War makes the state… states make war”
What is the theory of quasi-voluntary compliance?
It is cheaper to give citizens something for their money than to forcibly remove it
Reasons people have suggested the state is becoming weaker?
- Globalisation
- IGOs
- Regional integration
- Changing concept of sovereignty (gov’s protecting people)
What did Peter Evans (1997) say in the Eclipse of the state?
“while eclipse is a possibility, it is not a likely one”
Is a world with no state a possibility?
- Greater profit? Greater problems
- Government needed for relations, regulation, fiscal and monetary policy and a public sector
What did Huntington say about government in 1968?
Degree of government not the form that is important
What is Geddes (1999) definition of a regime?
Set of (in)formal rules and procedures or electing national leaders and policies
Plato’s view on democracy?
A skilled captain is required. Democracy would lead to instability and tyranny
Aristotle’s view on democracy?
A bad idea as the poor would just try to take money away from the rich
What is the Minimalist view of democracy?
Focus on the process, not about the outcome but how it is conducted. A strict criteria
- Free/fair election -Executive constraints
- Many parties -Level playing field
Schumpeter’s view on democracy?
Free elections with competition
“Free competition for a free vote” (1947)
What is Dahl (1959) view on democracy?
Thicker view than Schumpeter/ minimalist so you also need suffrage, expression, association and a free press
What do Minimalists think the purpose of democracy is?
To establish a system of governance where govs can be rid of peacefully. Act to prevent conflict and civil unrest
What is the substantive view of democracy?
About values and the outcome not just the process.
- Goals/ effectiveness
- Outcomes
- Substantive good achieved?
- Freedom from conflict. Education. Equality etc
Problems with the substantive view of democracy?
- Biased, Western Centric
- Undermines successful transitions
- Criteria too strict (e.g. USA too much inequality)
- All or nothing approach
- Normative, impossible standard
Montesquieu 1782 quote on suffrage?
Suffrage by lot is natural to democracy. As that by choice is to aristocracy
Lord Kelvin quote on democracy?
“If you cannot measure it, you cannot improve it”
Schmitter on democracy problem?
Scholars have hesitated to use the word democracy due to its ambiguity
What happened under Orban in Hungary, Fidesz party?
- Branches of government no longer separate
- Committee investigations stopped
- Political allies promoted
- Rule of law not upheld
Two approaches to classifying democracies?
Dichotomy: Is or it not
Continuum: Spectrum ‘degree to which it is democratic’
What is the Democracy-Dictatorship measure of demcracy?
Dichotomy approach from Cheibub (2010). Elections must be contested, elected legislature & chief executive, multi-party, *alternation of power has occurred
- Ex ante uncertainty
- Repeatability
- Ex post irreversibility
What is the Polity IV measure of democracy?
Continuum minimalist measure which scales 0-10 for democracy and autocracy and subtracts one from the other.
Factors: -Competitiveness and openness of exec recruitment
-Regulation and competitiveness of participation
-Executive Constraint, protect losers
Przeworski 1991, key features of elections?
- Uncertainty
- Irreversibility
- Repeatedness
What is the Freedom House measure of democracy?
Continuum, substantive view
- Measures global freedom, not regime type seen as a measure for democracy (Civil rights)
- Free (1-2.5) Partially (3-5.5) Not free (6-7)
- Corruption? Property rights? Free media?
How to evaluate measures of democracy?
- Conceptualisation
- Validity
- Reliability
- Replicability
- Question matter “Bias of the researcher”
What are Dahl’s (1959) conditions for Polyarchy?
- Officals make policy decisions
- Free/fair/frequent elections
- Large suffrage
- Right to stand
- Freedom of expression
- Alternative info
- Join independant organisations
Dahl quote on Polyarchy?
“Contingent consent of politicians acting under conditions of bounded uncertainty”