Plato Flashcards
What is mans essential virtue?
Justice
What does justice bring?
Harmony and happiness, good in its own right and beneficial to society
What is the purpose of the noble lie?
To invalidate feelings of dissatisfaction in class
What does the bible lie state?
That our natures are determined by metals from the ground. Rulers are Gold, auxiliaries are silver and craftsmen are bronze. It maintains the division of power for the benefit of all.
How is an individual just?
If reason, emotion and desire within an individuals mind is balanced
What are cardinal virtues of the state?
Wisdom, courage, temperance, harmony and justice
What does Plato claim poses the greatest harm to the state?
‘Interference by the 3 classes with each other’s jobs does the greatest harm to our state’
What makes a guardian?
- best of the best ( including women)
- happiness not required
- no family
- no property- all is held in common
- lovers of wisdom
- mature
- shouldn’t fear death
- passed a series of rigorous tests
What is the role of a guardian?
- to maintain peace
- to love wisdom
- to keep the classes in order
- to protect the state
- to breed in mating festivals to produce the best
What are criticisms of Plato’s guardians?
- not required to be happy- Aristotle- need to be happy to flourish
- live in peace - Hobbes - naturally selfish- reason of guardians is to override human instinct
- lovers of wisdom- any teaching that is censored/ ignorant necessitates lack of wisdom
Why does Plato raise the genders equally?
- if men and women are to be used for the same purpose they need the same training and education
- women shouldn’t be confined to domestic duties- the ‘tearing of their puppies incapacitates them’
- ‘ only difference is that the female bears and the man begets’, which is irrelevant in a society where women aren’t constrained to raising children
- Plato accepts that ‘ a great many women are better than a great many men’- and gives then the opportunity to be the exceptions
- ‘ natural capacities are similarly distributed in each sex’
How does Plato contradict his statements on gender equality?
- ‘ all in all women will be the weaker partners’
- ‘ women and children are to be held in common by men’
How does Plato defend women in his family policy?
- he believes that child bearing incapacitates women from their full achievement
- all female guardians are in common to all male guardians in reproductive practice
Why does Plato call for an end to the family?
He wants equal opportunities for women and children and ultimately the best guardians possible.
He believes that unanimity is the greatest good for peace- society is the large family
What is the breeding prime?
Men- 20-40
Women-25-55