Plato Flashcards
what is P’s socio-political context
pre-Christian moral framework, no religious-secular binary, different public / private distinction
what is a polis for P
a city state (not necessarily Urban), a particular model of community belonging (citizenship), particular participatory dynamics of public life
what was the prevailing form of governance at the time for P
declining dominance of the Athenian democratic polis
what was P’s stance on Athenian democracy
he was a critic, received threats from demagogues and those skilled in rhetoric / persuasion, also brought up concerns about ability of those participating (what validates their judgement)
who was Plato
founder of the Academy, Plato as a member of the economic elite (family embroiled in political debates / factions)
what was the effect of Socrates’ trial and execution
disillusionment with political engagement, philosophy as a public threat?
what did Socrates do with Cephalus’ view of justice
he poked holes in his principles and becomes a threat to their perception of justice
what question does Socrates raise about people’s behavior
do people only act justly when they are under duress
what does Socrates argue about harm
it is never just to harm anyone
what does Socrates say in his refutation of Thrasymachus’ view of justice
a perfect ruler works not for his own advantage but for the ruled
what does Socrates encourage people to do with wisdom
not to take wisdom at face value, question it and follow its reasoning
how does Socrates move the scale of the discussion
moves it from justice in the individual to justice in the city, because “there is more justice in the larger thing, and it will be easier to learn what it is”
what is Socrates’ intent
not to explain the creation of legitimate political authority, but what its true nature is
what is the division of labor premised on for Plato
we aren’t all born alike, but each of us differs somewhat in nature from the others, one being suited to one task, another to another”.
Natural talent is unequally distributed among different people
what is arete
virtue / excellence, all things have their own arete and it helps people accomplish their given purpose
T/F for Plato, there must be an underlying order to the city and to the hierarchy of people inhabiting it
True, (only certain people are capable of ascertaining this order, through philosophical reflection)
what is Plato’s hierarchy
Guardians, Auxiliaries, Ruled
what are the importance of the education of Guardians according to P
closely controlled education, developed with different content for different people, oriented toward creating a virtuous society
according to P, the best city will be led by
people are who are fully devoted to its wellbeing
what is P’s myth of the metals
that all citizens are born with a certain type of metal in their soul (guardians gold, auxiliaries silver, ruled iron or bronze) which creates a natural order that citizens should not deviate from. Also helps assign people’s roles in society
what is the problem with having a luxury based city according to P
breeds greed and never ending desire for more, which can put the city in a deathspin
according to P, what does education generate
allegiance to common morality, agreement on common goals, acceptance of the class hierarchy
according to P what does education guard against
excessive / misplaced desire, division due to wealth disparities, proper education (mostly) displaces the need for laws and regulations
Plato’s use of nature includes both
innate differences (nature) and differences developed by training and habit (nurture)
what are 4 virtues that Plato looks for in Cities and Individuals
Wisdom, Courage, Moderation, Justice