philosopher v philosopher

Question 1

austin v hart

Answer 1

Hart rejects Austin’s command theory, arguing that law is based on a system of rules rather than coercive orders.

Question 2

fuller v hart

Answer 2

Fuller critiques Hart for ignoring law’s internal morality, while Hart argues that law and morality should be kept analytically separate.

Question 3

hart v dworkin

Answer 3

Dworkin believes Hart’s rule-based model is insufficient because it ignores the role of legal principles and moral reasoning in adjudication.