Performance Evaluation Flashcards
When evaluating a manager vs a division, what do you need to consider ?
Functional structure- per function
Divisional structure - Divisions per product
Evaluate only on controllable items
Formula for EVA ?
Net Operating Profit after Taxes (NOPAT) - Capital * cost of capital
Ie. Operating income after tax - WACC*(TA-CL)
Residual income formula ?
Net income - (Cost of equity capital)
Return on Investment formula?
Net income/ Equity capital
ROI considerations
- ROI for manager = controllable contribution / Controllable assets
- ROI = Accounting rate of return (Acc no’s)
- It considers profit alone, not size of investment
4, Generally use profit after interest, before tax - TP. Always consider ROI Relevant to both division ROI and Group ROI to ensure that goal congruency is maintained.
What is the investment ?
Total assets available
Includes all assets, regardless of their
particular purpose.
What is the investment ?
Total assets employed
includes total assets available minus the
sum of idle assets and assets purchased for future expansion.
What is the investment ?
Total assets employed minus current liabilities
excludes that portion of total assets employed that are financed by short-term
creditors.
What happens when Carrying value is used in ROI and RI/ EVA ?
investment value decreases as asset is used
(depreciation). Thus even if profit and original investment remain constant, ROI and RI/EVA will increase over time
What should you use in calculations of ROI and RI/ EVA ?
Use market values/original cost
ROI advantages
Simple to calculate
Relative measure and easy to compare
ROI disadvantages
- Ignores risk
- easy to manipulate
- can lead to incorrect decisions
- Accounting based measure of profit
RI advantages
- Considers risk
(through WACC) - Usually motivates
correct decisions - Considers income
earned relative to
investment made
RI disadvantages
- Absolute number
- Accounting based
measure of profit
Important points on EVA
- Converts accounting profit into economic profit
- Economic measure of performance closer to CF’s
- Profit after tax, excludes interest* (double counted)
- Add back any costs related to long term funding