Performance and Breach Flashcards
Contract Performances - Types of performances (6)
1) Full satisfactory
2) Substantial
3) Excusable non-performance (CIISSU)
4) Insecurity and assurance
5) Non performance but: accord/novation/cancellation/waiver/release
6) Breach
Contract Performances - Full satisfactory - Gral
- When all conditions of performance are satisfied
- All parties are discharged from their contractual obligations
- Allows for 3 possible types of conditions to trigger/limit/extinguish duty to perform: a) precedent, b) concurrent, c) subsequent
Contract Performances - Full satisfactory - Types of conditions (3)
1) Precedent 2) Concurrent 3) Subsequent
Contract Performances - Full satisfactory - Condition Precedent - Gral
- Has to occur in order for duty to perform matures - “triggers”
- Can be waived by party or excused by court.
- i.e.: performance when unilateral contract OR obtain approval from party/3rd party (objective/substantive standard test for court to determine approval/rejection)
Contract Performances - Full satisfactory - Condition Precedent - When condition is approval - Standards
1) Objective: reasonable person would approve when involves mechanical utility or operational fitness (i.e. architect certification)
2) Subjective: When approval involves personal taste
Contract Performances - Full satisfactory - Condition Precedent - Timming
- Time of the essence
- small delays not actionable
- If specific time set in contract is usually enforceable
Contract Performances - Full satisfactory - Condition Concurrent - Gral
- Requires both parties to perform promises simultaneously or about the same time
- Can be constructive (created by court) for fairness equity, and even make 1 dependent of the other (hence not enforceable independently)
- i.e.: property sale where deed tendered at time of payment
Contract Performances - Full satisfactory - Condition Subsequent - Gral
- Predefined uncertain future event that DISCHARGES duty to perform by one/both parties
- i.e. lease termination if house used to sell alcohol
Contract Performances - Full satisfactory - Condition Frustration and/or Excuse
- Party cannot intentionally/wrongfully prevent/obstacle occurrence of condition to avoid contractual obligation
- Waiver can be express or implied
- Waiver not revocable once it generated reliance
Contract Performances - Substantial performance - Gral
- UCC: “perfect tender” rule: need perfect performance to avoid forfeiture
- CL: less strict
- OK when minor defect in good faith still generates substantial benefit
- Dx from defect deduced from contract price
Excusable non- performance - Gral
- duty discharged totally/aprtially/temporarily if performance becomes impossible, unduly burdensome BC of event unforeseable at time of contact. - applies in CIISSU situations (cooperation lacking, illegality after formation, incapacity of personal service contractor, source of supply impossible, subject matter distroyed, UCC failure of a presupposed condition)
Excusable non- performance - ClISSU - Cooperation lacking or hindrance
Lack of coop form one party discharges the other party and allows for possible dx recovery
Excusable non- performance - ClISSU - Illegality after formation
Legislation enacted post contract formation
- Discharges both parties
Excusable non- performance - ClISSU - Incapacity of personal service contractor
Death/Incapacity
- only that part is capable to fulfil contract
- parties discharged
Excusable non- performance - ClISSU - Source of Supply Impossible
- When w/o any fault from promisor / contract is discharged
- When source was specific, if not seller must purchase somewhere else to satisfy