Perception Flashcards
-Evolution -Audition -Vision
What is evolutionary anachronism?
• Evolutionary anachronism- attribute of living species best explained as a result of having been favourably selected in the past due to coevolution with other biological species that have since become extinct
Who should we compare ourselves to when looking at human cognition and why?
• When looking at cognition, we shouldn’t compare ourselves to computers or gods, but to animals because we are animals
o We have the same ancestors as animals
o Understanding ourselves means looking at the antecedents of our parts and processes in our ancestors
o Our ancestors evolved to win competitions
o Darwin suggests that we are no different from animals, as any cognitive ability we have is in some shape of form also in lower animals
Have we evolved from modern monkeys?
o We have common ancestors with modern monkeys, we haven’t evolved from modern monkeys
What is the problem of studying animals for human cognition?
Can’t look at animals today as we haven’t evolved from them, and ancestral monkeys we have evolved from are dead
What is a primary adaptation?
• Primary adaptation- original adaptations
What is a vestigial adaptation?
• Vestigial- Was an adaptation for the organism’s ancestor, but evolved to be non-functional because the organism’s environment changed
What is an exaptation?
• Exaptation-Trait that has been co-opted for a use other than the original adaptational use due to a difference in environment
What is a secondary adaptation?
• Secondary adaptation-enhances the exaptation function
Describe the adaptation and vestiges of the human spine
o For example, the spine
Coccyx and tailbone- tail useful in trees to grasp branches
Curved spine- shock absorber for walking
Spine exapted to hold us up
Secondary adaption to improve shock absorbance
What type of adaptation is piloerection for humans?
o For example, piloerection
Good for animals with spines, but vestigial for us
What is the blink reflex (reactions and purpose)
o For example, the blink reflex
A bright light suddenly shone into the eyes, a puff of air upon the sensitive cornea or a sudden loudnoise will produce immediate blinking of the eyes
Purpose- to protect the eyes from foreign bodies and bright light
May be associated tensing of the neck muscles, turning of the head away from the stimulus, frowning and crying
Is our brain made for modern uses?
• Most (99%) of our brain was made to suit the needs of our animal ancestors, not what we’re trying to do with it now- evolution is slow
In what ways is animal psychology and human psychology percieved differently?
o Animal psychology Foraging and food choice Predator avoidance Mate choice and courting Communication o Human psychology Perception Cognition Intelligence Language
Describe the bag of tricks metaphor for our brains and why it is useful
• Bag of tricks metaphor-
o Computer metaphors are used a lot for cognition, but we should not be looking at computer metaphors as computers can do a lot of general things- we can only do specific ones
o We have a specific collection of tools/cognitive faculties
o Bag of tricks has more animal perspective
o Big concepts are not a useful unit for analysis
• Question of what cognition evolved for may be too general
What are the 4 types of explanation for a phenomenon?
- Proximate explanation-closest explanation to the event that is to be explained
- Developmental explanation
- Neuroscientific explanation
- Functional evolutionary explanation
What is the central interest of evolutionary psychology?
o Evolutionary psychology is interested in which, and how many, behaviours and mental processes, evolved as the result of specific issues that our ancestors faced
What are barriers to people accepting functional evolutionary explanations?
o Barriers to the functional evolutionary explanation
People think they are more like gods than animals
Lack of understanding of evolution
Belief that human qualities are not qualities animals have -> tend to identify with higher cognitive abilities that we believe animals don’t have
In modern times, is the mentality that we are far away from animals cognitively increasing or decreasing?
• However, this mentality is decreasing in some instances and increasing in others
o There is greater acceptance of similarity of animals to ourselves- when people are vegan or vegetarian for ethical reasons
o Feminism is not animalistic-due to our history and culture, we want to close the gap between man and woman whilst in terms of the animal kingdom, there is a large difference between the two sexes
How can we find if something is innate rather than learned?
• To find if something has evolved or is learned, need to examine something important in our ancestral environments, but not so important in the environment of kids and adults today, so that a special response to it is unlikely to be learned
Describe New, Cosmides and Tooby 2007 study, as well as potential confounds
o Animals were very important for almost all humans and their ancestors, until very recently (when we started living in species)
o Animals are especially important to keep track of (prey and predators), so arguably should be attended to more
o If evolutionary demands shaped specific aspects of attention, then attention should be spontaneously directed to animals more
o New, Cosmides and Tooby 2007 study
Change blindness study
If evolutionary history dictates what we turn our attention to, then images with changes involving subjects should be detected in this hierarchy
• People
• Animals
• Plants
• Moveable/manipulable artifacts designed for interaction with human hands/body
o Brain is responsive to tools
• Fixed artifacts construable as topographical landmarks
o Important for navigation but don’t expect these things to move
Results of upright condition-
• People and animals had a significant detection advantage- attention was drawn towards them when they changed
Confounds-
• Backgrounds, locations, visual features, color differences, texture differences, spatial frequency differences of the target are changed between pictures
To address confounds, did inverted conditions
• Found that people and animal advantage was removed
Hence can conclude that confounds not reason that people and animals drew increased attention from subjects
Describe the New and German 2015 study as well as potential problems with it
o New, German 2015 study-
In an evolutionary psychology view, should be less susceptible to things that are real threats now if it was learned rather that evolved
Claimed that spiders can surmount inattentional blindness by using different spider shapes and comparing them to needles
Inattentional blindness model
Found that only the certain spider shapes had a detection advantage over non-spider shapes, except for the flower shape which puts in question the results
There is a problem with these results as we don’t know what visual features the brain responds to the most
This experiment was also done on adults, so the innateness of spider detection is questionable-do we learn to be afraid of spiders due to our cultural education or is it innate
Describe which part of the brain is extremely responsive to faces
• Part of temporal lobe (fusiform gyrus) extremely responsive to faces
Describe the Kanwisher, Chun and McDermott (1997) experiment on facial recognition
• Experiment- Kanwisher, Chun, McDermott (1997)
o Showed faces to people and would look at responsiveness in the brain compared to other objects such as hands or other visually similar objects (to control for visual features)
o Scrambled stimuli as a control condition with the intention of preserving the visual features
So stimuli were arranged as a face vs not face but using the exact same shapes
But maybe manner in which stimulus was broken up disrupted visual feature that the brain area cared about
o Larger responses to faces in all conditions
Describe why inversion is a better design than scrambling to eliminate visual feature bias
• Inversions of something makes it harder to recognise them as an object (although visual features are maintained and no disruption occurs)-less confounds than scrambling features
• Inverting photos perfectly preserves their lower- level stimulus properties but makes identifying the semantic category to which a target belongs more difficult
o The low level stimulus properties (colours, textures, shapes) are still processed very similarly but the system no longer easily recognises what is a person and what is an animal
o With the system not recognising the people and animals as people and animals in the inverted case, it is therefore no longer predicted that the people and animals should have an advantage
• If lower level properties are causing the animate attention advantage, then it should appear even when photos are inverted. In contrast, if the attentional bias is category-driven, then manipulations that interfere with categorization but preserves lower-level perceptual features should eliminate the animate change-detection advantage
Describe how the brain evolved and how it is currently used
• There is no general problem-solving system because we did not have general problems. We had foraging and food choice problems, mating problems and social problems
o Hence the bag of tricks metaphor
• But, at some point, we developed fairly general problems solving
o Most human organs have specific function, but the brain can multipurpose
Primary adaptation of brain-foraging, mate choice…
• Brain started out as a bag of tricks
Secondary adaptation of brain- gaining more neurons allowed us to do a wider range of things
• Brain didn’t originally evolve to have such general abilities
Describe how we should look at the brain if the brain is like a bag of tricks
o If the brain is a bag of tricks, it makes sense to look at specific things it’s adapted to do
Describe how we should look at the brain if the brain is like a general purpose device. What are the disadvantages of this metaphor?
o If the brain is a general purpose device, it makes sense to look at its building blocks to understand its particular character
But easy to fall too hard for this metaphor, and think that we are a general purpose computer with few constraints on thinking, planning or language
Instead we have many limitations, and don’t do things like a conventional computer
How should we determine ancestral adaptation and what a function originally evolved for/how it has evolved?
o Fossil record
o Organisms that have adaptation in one stage of life but not another stage of life
o Organisms that have adaptation versus those that don’t have adaptation
o Exaptations- features with functions for which they were not originally selected
Look at what organisms seem to use it for
What is thought to be the first organism who evolved neurons?
Think that organisms that would have had the first neurons were jelly-fish like systems
• Contraction for movement requires a fast and coordinated neuron system
Why are neurons needed for the peristaltic wave and what is it?
• This need for a fast and coordinated neuron system can also be seen in other organisms such as humans
o Need a fast system for the peristaltic wave
The muscular action of the digestive tract moves food continuously in an action known as a peristaltic wave
Describe the life cycle of the tunicate and what it demonstrates about neurons
E.g. Tunicate
• Will swim around for most of their life
• Beginning of lifetime-
o Has only got 100 neurons
• Then have another stage of life where they set up on a nice rock and go through metamorphosis
o During metamorphosis, they eat their own brain
o Neurons become deconstructed
• The now immobile form of the tunicate becomes filter feeder and waits for plankton
• When it has neurons, a lot of them are stimulating muscles so tunicate can swim around, but when it has eaten them, it can no longer move
Describe the difference between plant and animal signalling systems
Plants don’t have neurons but can still move-they still have a signalling system but it’s extremely slow
Animals with neurons-neuron signalling system is very fast
Compare chemical diffusion to neuronal action potentials and justify why neuronal action potentials evolved in comparison
• Neurons allow for rapid transmission around the body, allows repeated rhythmic signalling
o Faster than hormonal communication/chemical diffusion, which is what plants and some organisms exclusively have. Chemical diffusion has
Slow propagation
Little specificity
Variability in how much signal reaches destination
Sluggish on and off
o Neuronal action potentials allow for
Fast speed up to 50m/s
Point-to-point specificity
Precise amount of signal reaches destination
Can stop quickly
• Rapid inhibition means that signalling can stop quickly: no straggler signals
Why did neurons evolve?
• Neurons allow for rapid transmission around the body, allows repeated rhythmic signalling
• Neurons provide synchronisation needed for movements-coordinated movements
o Can be done with weak connections that excite each other: central command not needed
Combination of neurons following own rules and hubs sending rules to neurons
• Intricate patterns required
o Partly innate, partly learned
Describe what allows organisms to walk in terms of evolution and learning
E.g. walking has to be coordinated-only able to walk easily due to large ancestral lineage working on locomotion
• Million years of evolution allow for walking in organisms but still requires a slight learning process and hence some period of interacting with the world
o Needs interaction with the world for brain to adapt to length of muscles and other features needed for walking as adaptation can’t predict exact measurements of organism. Also need learning to work out muscle coordination based on feedback
Walking is much the same as it was a million years ago: perceptual demands are not too different but what we have to do cognitively is very different
o Animals need to perform intricate complex patterns of synchronisation and oscillations so that they don’t fall over
What nerve system generates patterns of oscillating units with complex relationships- some in synchrony, others not
Spinal cord
What is the advantage and disadvantage of humans evolving to being born at a particular immature stage?
o Humans evolved to be born at a particularly immature stage
Disadvantage is that not much is pre-programmed
• Many animals have to function independently almost immediately, but young humans can’t do much: rely on learning to achieve perception, cognition and intelligence by developing a network
Advantage- our neurons experience plasticity at longer amount of time and hence we can learn a lot of information that is arbitrary
Why is programming robots to walk extremely hard?
• Programming robots to walk using computer-type information processing is really hard
o Computer programs traditionally are expected to work perfectly even the first time they run, which is not true of humans
Why is hearing important?
• Allows us to locate stimulus events in the environment and represent the world internally
• Inform us about our environmental surroundings
• Auditory perception is omnidirectional and constant
o Cf vision: we can hear behind us, and with eyes closed
• Vital to human communication
What is the definition of sound?
• Sound is a repetitive change in air pressure over time -series of compressions and rarefactions
What kind of wave is sound?
• Sound is a longitudinal wave (oscillates along its axis)
o Expands from a source in 3D (spherical wave)
How is sound represented?
o Often represented as a sine wave, but this is an oversimplication
How does sound travel?
• Sound travels through space as waves (acoustic vibrations) with long sound waves
o Surrounded by particles in the atmosphere
What are the wavelengths of audible sound waves?
• Audible sound waves have wavelengths from 0.0172m to 17.2 m
Can sound bend around corners?
Yes
Is sound reflected or produced by its source
• Sound is usually produced by its source rather than reflected
Describe the inverse square law
• Sound waves expand over distance and lose intensity
o Inverse square law- sound intensity decreases with the square of distance
Describe what sound is absorbed by and what is this affected by
• Sound energy is absorbed by the air, more for higher frequencies and hence higher frequencies are more easily muffled
o Attenuation of pressure over distance varies as a function of frequency
Describe the 3 perceptual attributes of sound and what they are affected by
- Frequency-perception of frequency is pitch
- Amplitude- perception of amplitude is loudness
- Complexity- perception of complexity is timbre
Describe the human hearing range
o Human hearing range is approximately 20-20000Hz
Describe the little brown bat hearing range
little brown bat can hear 10.3kHz-11.5 kHz
Do we hear all the frequencies in the world?
We don’t hear all frequencies- organisms only select a small narrow band
Are pitch and frequency identical?
No, but they are related
What is the Mel scale? Describe the relationship between the Mel and Hertz
The Mel scale: a scale of pitch (perceived frequency) rather than Hz. Equal Mel steps are perceived as equal intervals.
• Mel plot is a scale of pitch, not frequency
• Below 1000Hz, the Mel and Hertz scales coincide (linear relation)
• Above 1500Hz, bigger frequency steps are needed to maintain equal perceived interval -relationship becomes non-linear
What produces loudness and what is it measured by?
o Loud sounds are produced by larger oscillations
o Intensity of compression is loudness
o Loudness is measured in decibels
What do decibels measure? How do you work out decibels?
o Decibels measure changes in sound pressure
Number of decibels= 20* log(P/Pref)
• How many times louder is a sound than the minimum sound that could be heart
• +6dB is a doubling of sound pressure level
• -6dB is halving of sound pressure level
How can sound pressure be measured?
Sound pressure is measured on a relative scale: relative to detection threshold (Pref: the minimum sound a healthy human ear could hear)
What is the minimum sound threshold?
• In a quiet environment, 20 micropascals is minimum sound threshold
What does loudness required to detect a tone vary with?
o Loudness is frequency dependent- sound pressure level (loudness) required to detect a tone varies with frequency
o Equal loudness requires different intensities over frequency
Contour is flattest at moderate sound levels
What is the most sensitive frequency range and why?
Sensitivity is best from 500-4000Hz as need small sound pressure to detect these frequencies (coincides with speech frequency range)
How many hertz are vowels and fundamental frequencies?
• Smaller than 1000Hz: vowels and fundamental frequencies
How many hertz are consonants?
• Higher than 1000Hz: consonants
At what loudness are all frequencies uniformly sensitive?
80 dB
What is complexity?
o Complexity- a fundamental frequency (lowest frequency) gives a complex sound its pitch, but higher harmonics in various proportions give it timbre (or colour)
What defines pitch?
Lowest harmonic defines pitch as it’s the lowest common divisor of the harmonics- even if lowest harmonic is filtered out, the brain derives it and you still perceive it (periodicity pitch)
Why do different instruments have a different timber
o Different instruments have a different timber because their higher harmonics differ (i.e. number, amplitude phase of harmonics varies between instruments and human voices)
What is timber and what is it determined by?
o Temporal components also determine timbre
o Timber- complex patterns added to the lowest, or fundamental, frequency of a sound, referred to as spectrum envelope
What is the use of a spectral envelope?
o Spectrum envelopes enable us to distinguish multiple instruments
What do multiples of fundamental frequency give?
o Multiples of fundamental frequency give music
What do multiples of unrelated frequencies give?
o Multiples of unrelated frequencies give noise
What is the outer ear composed of?
Composed of skin and ear canal
What is the purpose of the outer ear?
Gathers and directs sound into ear canal: amplification of mid-frequencies through canal resonance: vertical direction coding
Coarse amplification
What is the purpose of the middle ear?
Amplifies signal for inner ear (impedance matching)
Much less than 1% of sound energy passes from air into water
Middle ear amplifies sound in 2 ways better to drive the fluid-filled inner ear
• It drives a small plate on the inner ear with sound energy collected from a large area
• The malleus is 2x longer than the stapes, boosting the signal using mechanical leverage
What is the middle ear composed of?
Composed of malleus, incus and stapes
Filled with air
Describe the role of the inner ear
Location of auditory receptors: frequency analysis: transduction of physical signal to neural impulses
Describe the composition of the inner ear
Cochlea is fluid-filled and contains primary receptors
Composed of cochlea
Describe the basilar membrane and its role in encoding frequency
o Basilar membrane has differing thickness and width, which is why only some parts of it will start vibrating depending on the frequency
If oscillation at the base, it is a high frequency
If oscillation at the tip, it is a low frequency
o Depending on which nerve fibres which are attached to basilar membrane are activated, brain knows the frequency
Describe what range the cochlea works best
But not a perfect code- works best between 500-3500Hz
• Within a range of 500-3500Hz, pitch is determined by the location of the standing oscillation on the basilar membrane
Describe the pathway of the ear
• Ear pathway
o Sound goes through ear canal and hits the tympanic membrane (ear drum) and makes it oscillate
o Anvil, hammer and stirrup are moved by ear drums vibrating and stirrup (which is attached to the cochlea) and sets up standing wave and oscillation in cochlea
o Cochlea is full of fluid- bones are levers that crank energy up enough to get fluid filled cochleal membrane vibrating, and where it vibrates is the frequency that will be heard
What sits on the basilar membrane and what does it attach the basilar membrane to?
• Hair cells sit in rows on the basilar membrane
o Inner hair cells- 1 row
o Outer hair cells- 3 rows
• Fine hairs known as cilia protrude from the hair cells and attach to a roof called the tectorial membrane
What dorms the auditory nerve?
Axons from inner hair cells bundle together to form the auditory nerve
• Only sparsely do the outer hair cells go up to auditory nerve