Part 2: Multilateral integration Flashcards
What is multilateral integration?
Non-discriminating economic integration
WTO
What three purposes does the WTO have?
- A negatiating forum for countries to lower trade barriers
- A set of rules (legally binding ex GATT)
- A forum for solving trade disputes.
Explain the main points of the WTO’s history:
1944-1994
- 1944 Bretton Woods: start point in wanting an International Trading Org. ITO charter was ambitious
- 1948: USA does not ratify - leading to the ITO falling apart (says something of USA as an econoic and political power)
- 1947: Drafts of GATT are made. Though not as ambitious as ITO. 23 members
- 1947-1994: GATT was the forum for international trade negotiations
- 1986-1994: The Urugay rounds creating WTO.
- 1995- today: WTO is the forum for miltilateral negotiations with rules as GATT, GATS and TRIPS (more ambitoius)
What are the components of structure in WTO?
2
Organizational structure:
- Ministeral conferance (every two years. most power)
- General council (12 times a year, run by ambassaders
- Comitees (Every commitee focuses on different thing
- Every enber country has right to have a representative in the room. (issue is money)
Structure of agreements’ (rules)
- GATT, GATS, TRIPS
What typ of decision-making do they have in WTO?
How?
Most common: CONSUNSUS= no country objects
-one country, one vote, tis can favour small countries but they usually have problems having represants in all votes.
2/3 votes when voting on accepting a new country as a member
Who can apply for a membership in the WTO?
Any country of seperate customs terretories wth full autonomy over trade policy
How does one become a member in the WTO?
(1. Become an observer)
2. Send letter to WTO Director General: “We want to join”
3. General Council establishes a working party to examine request
(this requires consensus, so if there is a menber countr that really does not want this country to join, they can have veto power)
4. Applicant describes trade plicy in a memorendum.
5. a) Multilateral negotiations, b) Bilateral negotiations
6. Working party agrees on finished negotiations.
7. General cuncil or ministeral Conferance votes
2/3 votes to pass
What is one recent “trend” in the WTO? How come?
The demands on applicants have increased heaviliy over time. Why: since the WTO relies on consenus to operate, accepting countries w. diffrent opinions osv
The members feel it is right for the new member to give before thay can take.
What are the 5 codes of conduct for WTO?
- Non-discrimination
- Reciprocity
- Enfoceable commitments
- Transparency
- Safety valves
Some of the codes of conduct contradict/ work against each other, how come?
- non-discrimination can lead to free-riding, reciprocity can reduce that
- Safety valves can restrict trade sometimes and this is then to secure markets w. market failures. This can be ineffective in an economic point of view, but it can serve other purposes.
how has the structure of WTO affeted its legitimacy, rules and cooperation?
By having minesteral conferences every other year its demand attention from the member countries and its populations so that it is’nt forgotten. This gives it legitimacy and upholds its rules. It is also positive for the cooperation and a way of upholding peace.
What are some useful critera to help understand a country’s influence in WTO?
Its share in world trade
Trade dependness/ openess
Ratio of exports and imports to gdp and absolute size of its market.
How does the prisoners dilemma relate to why countries trade?
How does WTO impact this game?
You can make an example with two countries (or trade regions) deciding wheter to trade or not.
Both choosing not to trade: bad for both
One choosing not to trade: Good for the country choosing not to trade
Both trading: good for both
We will then get a game with a dominant strategy where both choose not to trade and thereby lose.
With WTO countries can work against this dominant strategy by binding themselves to trade
What is the lock-in mechanism?
It is forseeing that a future version of a country may not want to argue for free trade (ex. Trump) and by commiting to free trade by WTO we can prevent that from happening.
How does lobbying act in the political economy?
Since there are few companies that gain from trade barriers, they have money to spend on lobbying while the large amount of losers (consumers) only lose little but the final amount is larger. But they don’t have incentives to lobby for trade -> problem with collective action.
Solution: In negotiantions, countries offer their own liberalization to motivate other countries to do the same. Easier to trade when you know you have someone to trade with.
What three trends have we had in negotioation rounds since GATT?
- More countries joining over time
- More issues being covered
- Rounds lasting longer periods of time
What happened in Doha round and how is this a risk for WTO?
Doho round was an ambitious round that didn’t reach consensus leading to is being declered dead
This is worrysome since the negotiation is a core purpose of WTO
What are plurilateral agreements?
Groups of WTO members to agree on rules and issues that are not covered by the WTO
(All WTO rules apply to all me,bers!)
Can be solutions to difficult negotiations but it goes agains the non-discrimination policy
What the 5 steps for disspute settlement?
- Consulations: Misunderstanding? easy solution?
- Request for a panel: After 60 days, a panel is created and this must be approved by the original compliants. Panel has diffrent experts in trade. Panel is established by Dispute Settlement Body (DSB)
- Panel at work: objective assessments of facts and make a report to the DSB
4a) adoption of report 4b) appeal: Case is sent to apppellate Body (AB) and they say if report is valid and then we go to 4a. - Implementation: Within a reasonable period of time, otherwise punishment and new dispute settlement case.
What does GATT stand for?
General agreement on Tariffs and Trade
What for rules does GATT contain?
- Nondiscrimination
- Tariffs as the principle only allowed instrument
- Tariffs are binding
- Other policies cannot go against the principle on non discrimination or agreements about market access.
What is an important note when talking about GATT?
It does not say “don’t regulate trade” but more that IF you regulate trade, here are some rules
What does the MFN mean and what does it imply?
What does it apply to (economic measures)?
Most Favored Nation: Part of non-discrimonation policy that says that “a product in one member country cannot be treated any less favourably than a “like” product originating from any other country”
=> Market access: WTO-members must treat all member coutries as well as their most favoured trading partner.
Applies to tariffs, restrictions etc
What are the exceptions for MFN?
Regional integration (as it is based on discrimination) Non-reciprocal preferences for developing countries
What does national treatment contain?
What does is cover/not cover?
It says that “foreign goods cannot -once they have paid tariffs and other border measures- be treated less favourably than like or directly compretetive products produces domestically”
=> countries cannot discrimnate against foreign goods with domestic policies.
Covers almost all domestic policies ex. taxes and regulations. Does not cover subsidies or government procurement (supply)
What are the rules on Tariffs?
Exceptions?
in principle, tariffs are the only plicy instruments allowed by GATT.
Rules: 1) Follow MFN 2)Tariffs should be bound (GATT article 3) This creates a tariff ceiling so tha tcountries can “predict worst case scenario”
Exceptions: Agricultural goods.
What is the diffrence between a bound tariff and applied tariff?
A bound tariff is the tariff that is the maximum allowed level of tariff.
Applied tariff is the actual level of tariff that a coutnry has at border
What is a tariff schedule?
Every country has a tariff schedule and it is a list of goods with their respective tariff levels.
What is Binding overhang?
implications of binding overhang?
Binding overhang is the gap between the applies tariff and the bound tariff
Implications: Negotiationg on tariffs usually refer to bound tariffs and not applied.
countries have flexibility in their applied tariffs.
What does MD, MS and XS stand for?
MD= import demand, MS=import supply, XS=export supply
What are the assumptions when doing a tariff analysis?
Two countries: Home and Foreign
Perfect competition
Constant returns to scale