parliament/congress Flashcards
what are the features of parliament?
bicameral - HoL and HoC
How many MPs/constituencies in the HoC?
650
what is the layout of parliament?
backbenchers majority of parliament, frontbenchers - those run the government, Speaker of the HoC, opposition - shadow cabinet, rest of the parties that don’t have a majority.
what types of members are there in the HoL?
life peers, hereditary peers, archbishops, crossbenchers
how many lord spirituals are there?
26 from the church of England
how are the HoL appointed?
HoL appointment committee, don’t have to be aligned with a party, member of the public that is nominated can be reviewed for membership by the committee
who else can appoint those to the HoL?
give examples
the PM can appoint members, such as Rishi Sunak appointed David Cameron as a Lord in 2023
Gordon Brown appointed Lord Sugar in 2009
what are the function of HoC?
scrutiny, legislation, debate, representation, legitimation, mandate
what is scrutiny?
holding government accountable for their actions, question PM and ministers on actions they have taken
critical observation and examination
what is debating?
MPs debate issues of major importance of their constituents and of the country.
what is representation?
MPs protecting the needs and interests of people in their constituency
what is legitimation?
the HoC must approve all bills which become laws and has the power to support or question
how effective is representation in the HoC? both sides
Representation - MPs have surgeries talking to their constituents
fails to represent the social makeup of society
52% of MPs over 50
ethnic 8%, but UK 14%
65% male, 35% female
how ineffective are PMBs
PMBs - only 2-3% are taken into consideration
how effective is legislation in the HoC? both sides
legislation - pass bills into law 2018 Data Protection act
MPs cannot freely debate and vote how they want to because of party line and party whips, three line whip telling them how to vote in upcoming votes
how effective is legitimation in the HoC? both sides
legitimation - approves important decisions, voted against military intervention in Syria 2013
war on Iraq 2003, over 750,000 protesters in London on a single day
how effective is scrutiny in the HoC? both sides
Scrutiny - PMQs, questioning the PM
PMQs - seen to be mainstream political theatre, punch and judy rather than holding the PM accountable
select committees - scrutinise gov’t dep’t work and ministers
question ministers - in-depth questions
Boris Johnson questioned by the privilege committee on Partygate 2021, however, 2016 Boris Johnson accused of waffling by foreign affairs committee chair
PMQs are effective in scrutinising the executive?
high profile and widely publicised, clips often featuring in TV news or social media
forces the PM to directly address key issues, most direct method of scrutiny
opportunities for the leader of the opposition to stake a claim to the premiership by delivering a better debating performance
keeps PM on their toes and directly accountable to parl.
PMQs are ineffective in scrutinising the executive
highly misleading and distorted image of parl’s work and how government is scrutinised
punch and judy politics
petty point scoring
very male, very testosterone fuelled
PMQs made 12% of the public feel proud of parliament
no less than 67% felt there was too much party political point scoring as opposed to answering the question
MPs from the ruling party use it an opportunity to ask pasty questions, these are planted questions wich supposed to make the government look good
also an opportunity to ingratiate themselves with the frontbench in hopes of a future promotion
what are the three theories of representation in the UK?
Delegate
Burkean
Mandate
what is the delegate theory?
MP is a mouthpiece for the constituency only, votes for what their constituents want, not their own interests
what is the Burkean theory?
where the MP uses their experience and understanding to decide what it best for the interests of their constituents
what is the mandate theory?
the MP is there to represent party interests not their constituents interests.
what are the functions of the HoL?
legislation - no money bills, but can delay
government scrutiny
investigating public policy
representation - scientists etc
how effective is legislation in the HoL? both sides
bill are debated at depth, containing experts providing inputs into debates, committee reviews of bills
however, not able to stop legislation passing and the Salisbury Convention means that the HoL is unable to oppose policies in the manifesto of the elected government
how effective is scrutiny in the HoL?
each gov’t dep’t has a member of the HoL that will question minister every Monday -MQs
government has to respond within 60 days to any report submitted
no single party controls the HoL
increasing non-partisanship
life peers can disobey the whip
don’t have constituencies so can constantly scrutinise the government
how effective is representation in the HoL?
contains peers who represent those that are less well represented in society - homelessness Baron bird advocates for homeless people
represents expertise from across society, different professional backgrounds
different political views
Lord Spiritual Act 2015 - woman becomes a bishop in the HoL
however,
how ineffective is representation in the HoL?
members are not elected by the public, so don’t have a mandate
92 hereditary peers - inherited title not selected by committee
members appointed by party leaders through the power of patronage
over half the members are over 70yrs
only Christianity is represented, no other religion
briefly name the stages in the legislative process in the UK?
first reading - anyone can scrutinise
second reading - following a debate a vote will take place
committee stage - goes to a specific committee, it will be considered, examined, amendments, proposed with changes back to chambers
report stage - discuss amendments, then vote again
third reading - amendments no longer made, but new amendments considered, vote again to approve, both chambers to approve bill ‘ping pong’
royal assent - monarch will sign the bill into law
what is the Public Bill Committee?
committee where it will debate and consider amendments to the bill, considering each clause of the bill, highly scrutinising changes
what is the public account committee?
oversee government expenditure, questioning ministers, publish reports, effective scrutiny and honest.
what is secondary legislation?
bills can be passed to slightly amend primary legislation without removing the primary legislation act. the HoL can reject as well as the SC.
what is the Strathclyde review?
in 2015, reviewed the relationship between the HoC and HoL
recommended that the HoL should not be able to stop secondary legislation passing, but should ask HoC to rethink
compare the powers between the HoC and HoL?
HoC:
can remove the government - vote of no confidence
legislation powers - final approval
select committees - scrutinise the government
power to approve the budget
mandate
HoL:
propose amendments
amend and scrutinise legislation
who are backbenchers?
MPs in the HoC and HoL, not part of the gov’t or the opposition
how is the opposition significant?
size of gov’t majority, if there is a minority, opposition has more power
offer a clear alternative to the government
A united opposition allows more chance of voting down government legislation
what is the structure of congress?
HoR - 435 members
senate - 100 members
6 non-voting members
each state has 2 senators and a number of HoR the represents the state population
what is the structure of the senate?
100 senators, 2 per state
term length of 6 years
1/3 of senators reelected every 2 years
president of the senate - Kamala Harris
majority leader - Chuck Schumer
minority leader - Mitch McConnell
what is the structure of the HoR
435 members
members elected every 2 years, term length 2 years
constantly campaigning
Speaker - Mike Johnson
Majority leader - Steve Scalise
Minority leader - Hakeem Jeffries