elections Flashcards
what is the debate over electoral reform in the UK?
Makes Votes Matter was formed and campaigned for a proportional not majoritarian electoral system in general elections. many political parties supported the replacement - 2019, Lib Dems, SNP, Brexit Party, impact the nature of government, voting behaviour
what electoral systems are used in the UK? (ALL)
FPTP, PR, AMS, STV, SV, AV
what is FPTP?
majoritarian system, candidate with the largest number of votes win the seats
what are the advantages of FPTP?
produces clear results, resulting in a majority government not a coalition.
produces local links with their MPs, therefore can be held directly accountable for their actions
straightforward system, quick in producing election results
what are the disadvantages of FPTP?
it is not proportional, the number of seats to the % of vote. UKIP won 3.8 million votes but got 1 seat.
many wasted votes because of safe seats
elective dictatorship
can discourage participation - votes are wasted
candidate not directly chosen by voters
discriminates smaller parties
What is proportional list?
instead of electing one person per constituency with larger constituency areas
start of each round, total votes are divided by number of seats already won - D’Hondt formula
what are the advantages of PR?
proportional - Brexit party won 39% gained 40% of seats
less chance of wasted votes
guarantee the favoured candidate is chosen
helped third parties to be voted
what are the disadvantages of PR?
system is less straightforward with there being multiple rounds
should promote participation but European elections have low turnouts 2019 - 36.9%
no party secures a majority - form a coalition
weak link to the local constituents
what is AMS? additional member system
hybrid system, mix of FPTP and PR. currently used in Welsh and Scottish parliaments. 2 ballots one for candidates other for party.
what are the advantages of AMS?
largely proportional 25% of seats with 24% of the vote - Scottish conservative party
less chance of wasted votes
local links
third parties have greater representation - split ticketing
what are the disadvantages of AMS?
complicated system - requires 2 ballot papers
produces a minority government or coalition
no clear proof that turnout increases
what is STV? single transferable vote
In Northern Ireland elections
multi-member constituencies where voters rank their choice in preference order
what are the advantages of STV?
proportional system
preferential voting can reduce wasted votes
local links
greater incentive to vote for independent or minor parties
what are the disadvantages of STV?
can causing donkey voting - where they randomly chose an order
not a straightforward system
produces a coalition or multiparty government
what is AV?
election of chairs to parliamentary select committee
voter puts number on candidate for their favourite and does that for their second. then if they have won 50% rounds stop. if nobody gets over 50% the last candidate is eliminated
what are the advantages of AV?
Not much wasted votes, if there is a second vote then the votes are redistributed
The mostly likely to produce a single party government
Retains local links with constituents
Favours candidates with a broad appeal
Easy to understand
Removes the temptation of tactical voting
what are the disadvantages of AV?
absence of wasted votes should encourage participation
but there is not evidence as no European countries use AV
what are the arguments for FPTP to be replaced for general elections?
STV and PR reflect vote share better, FPTP distorts results.
party with the most votes does not always gain the most seats.
does not always produce a strong government 2017.
discriminates third parties
votes are wasted
encourages tactical voting, YouGov survey results.
what are the arguments against FPTP to be replaced for general elections?
traditionally produced strong and stable governments
easy to understand when voting.
alternative systems still have flaws.
two dominant parties, forces those parties to have a relatively broad appeal and basis of support.
quick and straightforward to count votes
what are the main factors in voting behaviour in the UK?
personality of party leader
relevance to the manifesto
influence of the campaign and media
voter profile
own political views
performance of current government
what are the recent trends in voting behaviour in the UK?
class dealignment - class becoming more difficult to determine and less important
partisan dealignment - become less classed based, fewer think that a party is for people like them, more of a political consumer, shopping around
swing voters - open to voting between different parties when they feel like it.
rise of identity politics - falls on women, minority ethnic groups, immigrants and LGBTQ+
what are people most likely to vote for depending on their age, gender etc. in the UK?
age - those older vote for conservative, younger vote labour
gender - women more likely to vote labour, men conservatives
ethnicity - minority - labour less hostile to immigrants compared to conservatives
what are the key elections in the UK?
19823, thatcher’s 2nd term
1997, Blair
2019 - Johnson
what is the role of the media in the UK elections?
TV has to remain neutral
bulk of media influence fell to newspapers 1979
The Sun encouraged to vote for Maggie
Gave Thatcher a strong media presence over Michael Foot
The Sun switched allegiances in 1997 to back Blair instead of Major
the Sun wot won it
emergence of social media helped Johnson and Corbyn in 2019
advertising on social media, YouTube, Facebook
younger voters were more likely to engage with social media, open to influence from posts and political adverts.
2010 first TV debate
2019 both Conservatives and Labour worked together to exclude SNP and Lib Dems
name referendums in the UK?
1997 Devolution referendum for Scotland and Wales
1998 London Mayor and Greater London authority assembly
2004 Northeast England devolution referendum 78% N
2011 AV referendum
2011 Wales to extend powers to the Welsh Assembly
2014 Scottish independence
2016 Brexit
2023 Scotland asked Westminster for a referendum refused
what are the advantages of referendums ?
engage voters in decision-making, increase participation turnout
offer direct link between policy making and national will
settle controversial arguments in a more final matter than a parliamentary vote
what are the disadvantages of referendums?
don’t allow voters finer decisions beyond yes/no
undermine and weaken representative democracy
may not be easily understood by majority of voters - lack of political education or misinformation - Brexit
political debate can be bitter and devisive
‘not a one and done’ many wanted a second brexit referendum
turnout can be low - AV 42%
what are the main elections in the US?
presidential election, congressional elections, primaries/caucuses, direct democracy
what is gerrymandering?
deliberate manipulation of electoral districts for party advantage at elections.
what is the electoral system?US
electoral college, majoritarian, it is state based and does not reflect the overall popular vote across the country.
in some states the congressional elections use different electoral system, name the state and what they do?
Georgia - top-two election for its senate seat, candidate try to get 50% or a run off race happens
California - top two candidates are selected in a state primary, then go head to head in the senate election
Maine - uses a ranked choice system