Paper 1.9 - Non-fatal offences Flashcards
What are the five non fatal offences?
Assault
Battery
ABH
s20 GBH
s18 GBH
What section of what Act defines assault?
s39 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988.
What is the definition of assault?
D intentionally or recklessly causes V to apprehend immediate & unlawful violence.
What is the actus reus and mens rea of assault?
AR: apprehend immediate and unlawful violence.
MR: intentionally or recklessly.
What category of offence is assault and what is its maximum sentence for a first time offence?
Summary; 6 months.
Give an example of a case that proves words can amount to an assault.
EG
Constanza (1997)
Court of Appeal held that letters could be held as assault.
OR
Ireland (1997)
Silent phone calls can be held as assault (depending on context).
When being assaulted, V must apprehend immediate, unlawful violence. Describe one assault case where D was found not guilty due to lack of actus reus.
Lamb (1967)
Pointing an unloaded gun at someone who knows it is unloaded cannot be assault as there can be no apprehension of violence.
TRUE OR FALSE: Due to the case of Smith (1983), the ‘immediate’ nature of assault could be extended to imminent.
TRUE: Smith was outside V’s window, therefore his attack was not immediate; however the court held that he had committed assault.
Name one case where words attempt to negate an assault.
EG
Tuberville (1669)
D told V: ‘if it were not assize time, I would not take such language from you’ - found not guilty, as assize time lasted too long for assault to be immediate
OR
Light (1857)
D told V: ‘were it not for that bloody policeman outside, I would split your head open’ while grabbing his sword - found guilty, as the policeman could have left, fulfilling the threat.
What are the four evaluation points for assault?
- Assault has no statutory definition. -
- 6 months can be too harsh to d. -
- Judges are amending the law (Ireland and Smith). +
- 2015 Reform Proposal ignored. +
What section of what Act defines battery?
s39 of the Criminal Justice Act 1988.
What is the definition of battery?
D intentionally or recklessly applies unlawful physical force to another.
What is the actus reus and mens rea for battery?
AR: applies unlawful physical foce to another
MR: intentionally or recklessly.
What category of offence is battery and what is the maximum sentence for a first time offence?
Summary; 6 months.
What form of battery is committed every day and ignored due to its frivolous nature? Give one example of such a battery.
Common battery / implied consent.
EG getting on a packed tube.
For battery charges, the mens rea and actus rea must overlap at some point; what case is an example of this?
EG
Fagan (1968)
D parked his car on a PO’s foot (AR) and after being informed he was on his foot, refused to remove it (MR). The battery began when the MR was formed; D was convicted.