Paper 1 ELS Flashcards
what courts do criminal law use
Supreme court
Court of appeal
Queen’s Bench Divisional court
Crown court
Magistrates’ court
How must criminal cases be proved
beyond all reasonable doubt
What does ‘Stare decisis’ mean?
‘let what has been deciding stand’ the essence of the precedent
what does ‘ratio decidendi’ mean?
‘the reason for deciding’ binding part of the judgement
what does ‘obiter dicta’ mean?
‘sayings by the way’ extra things leading to s final decision
what are the 3 types of precedent?
binding, persuasive, avoiding
what is binding precedent?
must be followed if it is made by a court higher than you
appeal courts generally bind themselves
what is persuasive precedent?
principles could be considered but don’t have to be
anyone can follow anyone
can be from courts in other countries
what is avoiding precedent?
a higher court overrules a decision made by a lower court
court decides that an earlier case is wrong / not fitting
when did the supreme court precedent (practice statement) change?
1966
what was the practice statement 1966?
- supreme court changed their rules of precedent changing from ‘never’ to ‘when it appears right to do so’
court of appeal precedent rules
1 - court can chose between 2 of their previous cases if they are similar
2 - must follow supreme court’s decision if any have been made
3 - where the decision was made per incuriam - by mistake or carelessly, it can be changed
judicial precedent advantages
1 - certainty
2 - consistency and fairness
3 - precision
4 - flexibility
5 - time saving
judicial precedent disvantages
1 - rigidity
2 - complexity
3 - illogical distinctions
4 - slowness of growth
what is a statute?
Acts of parliament passed into law
written document which will become legislation (law)
what is statutory interpretation?
when a judge defines words on page within an act of parliament
what is the literal rule (SI)
judges reading a statute as a plain, ordinary, literal meaning
traditional approach
what is the golden rule? (SI)
used when the literal rule creates absurd results
what is the mischief rule? (SI)
judges filling in the gaps and looking at context to decide whether a law should be changed
rules to consider with mischief rule
1 - what was the common law before?
2 - what was the mischief that the law didn’t provide for?
3 - what was the remedy parliament enacted?
4 - judges should then interpret the act to ensure mischief is solved
examples of internal aid
- long/short title
- preamble (little paragraph introduction to the statute) helps understand parliaments initial intentions
- marginal notes - explaining different sections but don’t always give intentions
What is internal aid?
things to help judges understand what parliament meant when they wrote statues
things from inside the statute written down
What is external aid?
help that can be found outside of a statute
examples of external aid
- previous acts of parliament on the same topic
- historical setting
- earlier case law
- dictionaries of the time
things to consider when giving a caution
Victim’s view.
Any attempt by the offender to offer compensation.
Seriousness of offence.
Have they ever been cautioned before.
some reasons people may not be granted bail
- they would fail to surrender
- would commit another offence
- must be kept in custody for their own or another’s safety
rules applied to bail
- live at particular address
- don’t contact certain people
- hand in passport
- report to police station weekly
what is remand?
if a person is cared with a serious crime, instead of bail, they are put in prison until first hearing
what is CPS and why was it needed?
Crown Prosecution Service - takes over criminal prosecution on behalf of the police
why?
- officers may be too attached to case
- too much variation between police forces
- police officers are not well versed in law