Ownership of Realty Flashcards
Estate in Land
A realty interest that is presently or may become possessory
Present Possessory Estates
Can include freehold estates and non-freehold estates.
Freehold Estate
Gives the owner of the estate title to or a right to hold the property.
Leasehold Estate
A type of non-freehold estate where the estate is limited in duration. E.g. “to A for a term of 10 years.”
Non-Freehold Estate
Gives mere possession.
Types of Freehold Estates
Includes:
- Fee simple absolute
- Defeasible estates
- Life Estate
Words of Purchase
Describe the persons who take an interest under a grant or device. E.g. “to A”
Words of Limitation
Describe the nature of the estate taken by the purchasers. E.g. “and her heirs” describe that the estate taken is a FSA.
Preference of Courts: Forfeiture v. Alienability
Keep in mind that courts disfavor forfeiture and favor free alienability.
Labels for Recipients of Realty Transfers (Devisees, Heirs, and Grantees)
- (Devisees) take by will
- (Heirs) take by law of intestacy
- (Grantees)- take by inter vivos (between the living) transfer
Fee Simple Absolute
The largest possible estate in land; a FSA holder has all possible rights that a person may have in the realty including:
- the unimpeded right to sell or convey all or part of the property; and
- the unimpeded right to devise the property
When a FSA Owner Dies Intestate
The property will pass to the owner’s heirs by intestacy.
Language that Conveys a FSA
Traditionally included “to A and her heirs.” However, under modern law, a FSA is presumed when the words “to A” are used (therefore, there is a presumption of FSA in the absence of words of limitation).
Presumption of FSA
If language is ambiguous, courts presume that the grantor intended one to have the greatest possible estate conveyed.
Termination of FSA
The only way for a FSA to terminate is for the owner to die without a will or heirs, and the property escheats to the state.
Defeasible Estates
An estate that may terminate before its maximum duration has run. Includes:
- Fee Simple Determinable
- Fee Simple Subject to a Condition Subsequent
- Fee Simple Subject to Executory Interest
- Fee Tail
Fee Simple Determinable (FSD)
Terminates automatically on the happening of a named future event. When the event occurs, the estate returns to the grantor
Words of Limitation for a FSD
Includes durational language:
- for so long as
- during
- while
- until
-Keep in mind that a determinable estate is created in one clause with a limitation built into that one clause.
Fee Simple Subject to a Condition Subsequent (FSCS)
An estate that can be retaken by the grantor on the happening of a named future event/condition. But the condition only gives the grantor the right to take the estate (unlike FSD it does not automatically terminate).
Words of Limitation for a FSCS
Includes conditional language:
- provided, however
- however if
- but if
- on condition that
- in the event that
-Remember that an estate subject to a condition subsequent is created in two separate clauses; and with a condition stated in the second clause.
Reservation of Power of Termination for FSCS
Remember that the power of termination must be expressly reserved to the grantor (e.g. grantor has power to terminate) or else a court will hold that there is a failed attempt to create a FSCS.
FSD v. FSCS: When the Language is Ambiguous
If the language is ambiguous, courts interpret the grant as an attempt to create FSSCS (because courts abhor forfeiture), though, this often fails and the grant becomes a FSA for lack of a specific power of termination.
Fee Simple Subject to Executory Interest (FSEI)
An estate that is terminated on the occurrence of some event, property then passes to someone other than the grantor.
Words of Limitation for FSEI
A FSEI is created by either durational or conditional language.
Fee Tail
At early CL, a freehold estate that descends to the grantee’s lineal descendants (children) only.
Fee Tail General
FT where the children of the grantee take ownership in the estate when the grantee dies. E.g. “to A and the heirs of his body.”
Fee Tail Male/ Fee Tail Female
When a FT limits descent to the male or female heirs of the grantee. E.g. “to A and the heirs {male/female] of his body.”
Fee Tail Special
A FT where descent is limited to the grantee’s descendants by a specific spouse. E.g. “to the heirs of his body by his wife B.”
Fee Tails in the Modern Law
FTs are disfavored in modern law. Today, if the words “to A and the heirs of his body” are used:
- most states will give grantee FSA
- a few states will give grantee a LE, with a remainder per stirpes in the grantee’s lineal descendants who are alive for the life tenant’s death.
Future Interests in a FT
FTS are followed by reversion in the grantor or a remainder in a third party. The future interest becomes possessory if and when the grantee’s lineal line ends.
Life Estate (LE)
Lasts for the duration of the grantee’s life. E.g. “to A for life.” Keep in mind that LEs can be made defeasible (determinable, subject to condition subsequent, subject to executory limitation).
Life Estate Pur Autre Vie
An estate where the duration is measured by the life of someone other than the grantee. E.g. “to A for the life of B.”
What happens when Grantee Dies for LE Pur Autre Vie?
If grantee predeceases the measuring life, the grantee’s heirs are entitled to the use of the land until the measuring life dies. If the measuring life ends before the grantee, the grantee’s interest terminates.
What Happens When There Are Multiple Measuring Lives for a Life Estate Pur Autre Vie?
The majority of courts hold that there life estate will terminate upon the death of the later measuring life.
Duties that Come with a LE
Include:
- Duty to Repair
- Mortgages
- Taxes
- Special Assessments
- Avoid Waste
LEs: Duty to Repair
A life tenant has a duty to maintain the property in a reasonable state of repair (ordinary wear and tear are permissible). This duty is also imposed on a tenant for a term of years.
LEs: Limitations on Duty to Repair
The duty to repair is limited to the extent of income derived, or if life tenant personally occupies the premises, to the extent of the reasonable rental value of the land (however, this limitation does not apply to a tenant for a term of years).
LEs: Mortgages
The life tenant has a duty to pay the interest on a mortgage to the extent of profits derived from the property. A tenant for years or a periodic tenant has no CL duty to make mortgage payments (but look out for duties required by commercial leases).
LEs: Taxes
The life tenant must pay all ordinary taxes, to the extent of profits derived from the property. A tenant for years or a periodic tenant has no CL duty unless:
- the lease is “perpetual” or for a long term with an option in the tenant and his successors to renew “forever”
- the tenant holds without any obligation to pay rent; or
- the tenant has erected improvements on the leased premises for his own benefit.