Origins of Hinduism Flashcards
What is the timespan of the IVC, and what period followed it?
2500-1500 BCE, followed by the Vedic period 1500-500 BCE
BUT J Fowler: 3300-3000 BCE
Geographical dimensions of the IVC
- Covered 1.25 km^2, most widespread of the old world civilisations
- Flourished along Indus river between Eastern Pakistan and Northwest India
- Major sites are Harappa in the Punjab and Mohenjo Dharo in Sind
- 1200 minor sites
Uncovering the IVC
- First excavations in 1921 by Sir John Marshall/R.D. Bannerjee
- Excavations impeded by ill health and WW2 but later continued by Sir Mortimer Wheeler
Evidence of infrastructure in the IVC
- Grid pattern streets in North-South East-West orientation
- Drainage system and waste disposal shoot per house
- Single room buildings at each intersection (watchmen?)
- Uniform brick size suggests mass production and measurement scale?
- Artificially raised Citadel (fortified core of city)
- Large, purposeful buildings which might have been grain stores?
- Water tank at Mohenjo dharo along with bathing areas
- Street lighting
Populations of key sites
- 40 000 approx.
Trade relations in the IVC
- Trade links with Mesopotamia between 2300-2000 BCE
- Copper and Lead sourced from India
- Minerals imported from Iran/Afghanistan
- Cotton export
- Would have required administration
Seals and figurines in the IVC
- Ceramic seals found which depict images of animals, humans and anthropomorphic figures
- Cows and Bulls depicted - a possible link to later Hinduism (Sacred cows and Shiva’s bull Nandi)?
IVC seal linked to Shiva?
- Yogic position
- Three faces and elaborate headdress
- Surrounded by variety of animals
- -> Shiva as Pasupati, Lord of the Beasts?
- Ithyphallic
- Cone shaped phallic symbols
- –> Reminiscent of later anionic linga and yoni?
Female figurines in the IVC?
- Pregnant and carrying small children
- Necklaces
- Elaborate hairstyles
- Clearly produced in mass as most are crudely formed
- -> Shakti the mother goddess? Or just proto Saraswati, Parvati or Lakshmi?
The Great Bath at Mohenjo Dharo
- Large waterproof pit: 39”/23”/8”
- Long building with several cells
- -> Potentially a temple for ritual purification
- -> Also linked (J. Fowler) to horned deity with mask found nearby
Conflicting views on Proto-Shiva seals in the IVC
- May or may not be in yogic position
- May or may not have three heads
- Asko Parpola notes the similarity between these and figures found on Elamite seals from 3000-2750 BCE
Conflicting views on female figures in IVC
- In agrarian society fertility is a major pre-occupation
- Though symbolic, the link between this symbol and Shakti is tenuous
Conflicting views on the nature of the Great Bath at Mohenjo Dharo
- Not found in conjunction with a temple as later ritual bathing areas were
- Could be that archeologists are attaching assumptions to this piece of evidence that are ill informed by later discoveries
The Priest King
- clover leaf associated with kingship
- Suggests theocracy
The language of the IVC
- Not yet translated, hugh barrier to research
- Only known from seals
- Either proto-Dravidian, or no links at all
- only 400 symbols - logographic? (Each symbol is a whole word)
What are the limitations to not knowing the language of the IVC?
- Dependent on physical objects for evidence
- These are open to a variety of interpretations
Racial composition of the IVC
- Mediterraneans
- Alpines
- Mongoloids
- Proto-Australoids –> Thought to be the basic element of Harrapan culture and the Indian people at large
Discovery of fire pits at Harrapa in the IVC
- Charred pits
- Contained ash, animal bones
- Some clearly constructed and purposeful
- Clearly seperate from the domestic hearth
- –> Possible use in Yajna ceremonies?
J. Fowler’s views on Temple worship in the IVC (2 points)
- “no conclusive evidence”
- “Perhaps temples were not needed, and worship may have taken place in open spaces”
Some examples of symbolism in the seals of the IVC
- Horns for power
- Foilage from womb
- cattle, crocodiles, rhinoceros, snakes, buffalo
Evidence of tree spirit in IVC
- Seal with people kneeling to a tree or placing offerings under them
Afterlife practice in the IVC
- Practices seem to have varied: Some were buried, some cremated and some buried after their bodies were exposed to the elements
- At Lothal, opposite sex pairs buried together suggests Sati?
- Buried with possessions, suggests some kind of afterlife belief
Overview of IVC beliefs?
- Religion central - THEOCRACY
- Fertility cult? - Female statue figures
- Multiple deities worshipped - Seals
- Ritual bathing? - The Great Bath
- Centrality of fire rituals? - Fire pits
BUT - Cannot be sure due to
(i) Subjective interpretation of physical evidence
(ii) Lack of language translation
Aryan Invasion Theory
- Aryan invaders overtook between 1700-1500 BCE
- Light skinned, illiterate, Indo-European people
- Arrived in North West India via Iran
- Superior warfare technology
- May have domesticated the horse to ride?
Strengths of the Aryan Invasion Theory
- Zoroastrianism: ‘Avesta’ scriptures of this religion in Iran is similar to the Vedas
- Evidence from Vedas, which describe the conquering of the ‘Dasa’ by the authors - ‘Dasa’ = IVC people?
- Explains the sudden decline
- Explains modern tensions e.g. Brahmins vs chaotic ‘Bhakti’ tradition
- Siva (IVC proto) worshipped by Dravidian speaking Southerners in keeping with Bhakti tradition
- > Bhakti= IVC?
- -> Siva = linked to IVC also?
- —–> Aspects of IVC religion assimilated into Aryan religion? Hinduism as a COMPOSITE religion?
Weaknesses of Aryan Invasion Theory
- No archeological evidence for invasion/migration in this period
- -> Pottery from Ganges-Yamuna that may have been occupied by Aryans, but could also have been from local proto-historic religions
- Cannot assume that modern Hinduism not found in the Vedas came from the IVC
- —-> // Proto-Siva –> Siva VS Vedic Rudra –> Siva
Academics supporting Aryan Invasion Theory
- Sir Mortimer Wheeler
- V. P. Kanitkar
- Owen Cole
Continuous Development Theory (IVC)
- Aryan civilisation evolved directly from the IVC
- No outside involvement
- Proto-Hindu elements of IVC religion were precursors to modern Hinduism
- Continuous development from neolithic–> Vedic period
- IVC language was in fact Indo-European and evolved into Sanskrit
Strengths of Continuous Development Theory (IVC)
- Supported by archeological evidence: continuity of material culture
- Doesn’t contradict Vedas as links found to cities inhabited by Indo-European speaking people in the Bactrian region
Weaknesses of Continuous Development Theory (IVC)
- Does not account for linguistic and religious links with Europe ie similarities between Vedas and Iranian religion which became Zoroastrianism
- Some Vedic contradiction: describes ‘Dasa’ (Indus) cities as circular, which they weren’t
- Asko Parpola argues for
1) Dravidian speaking IVC culture
2) Absence of horses/chariots in IVC - -> Features definitive of Aryan culture, which make it unlikely that these features evolved from the IVC
Academics supporting Continuous Development Theory (IVC)
- L. Poliakov
- J. G. Shaffer
- D. Frawley
What does ‘Aryan’ mean?
Arya = noble
Sanskrit root ‘ar’ means ‘agricultralist’ but Fowler claims that ‘noble’ or ‘cultivated’ was the connotation intended
Evolution of the term ‘Aryan’ according to Klostermaier
- First a group of languages
- Then became a racial term for people using those languages
Common assumption about the origins of the Aryans, now debated?
- Invasion theory: Aryans arrived 1500 BCE (Folwer and Lipner prefer 2000 BCE) and established rule over dark skinned Indian natives
BUT - Little archeological evidence
- Cannot assume that non-Vedic elements of Hinduism came from IVC
Different views of original homeland of Aryans
- Arctic Circle, Scandinavia, Ukraine, Persia, Turkey, Middle East, Central Asia
- Fowler favours Iran due to links between Vedas and Zoroastrian Avestas
Social structure of Aryans
- Illiterate, so scripture orally passed down
- tribal, patriarchal social structure led by male ‘Rajas’
Aryan settlement
- Village culture; Pastoral > Urban
- Horses and chariots for Mobility and Militarism (Hopkins)
- Semi-nomadic
- Settlement along Sarasvati River
Hopkins quote on Aryan horse-drawn chariots
“Mobility and Militarism” - Hopkins
Difference between the IVC and Aryans - A regression?
- City vs Pastoral
- Trade with Egypt and Mesopotamia vs none at all
- Literate vs Illiterate
- BUT Military power was with Aryans
- Domesticated Horse and Cow
Economy of the Aryans
- Brought Iron Age to India
- Domesticated horse and cow
- Metal workers, potters, reed workers, tanners, weavers, carpenters
- Cattle rearing main occupation
- Lack of trade with Egypt and Mesopotamia (Hopkins)
The structure of the Vedas
The Vedas are comprised of four layers: (From oldest-most recent) 1) Rig Veda 2) Sama Veda 3) Yajur Veda 4) Atharva Veda
Within each layer, there are four sub-sections:
1) Samhitas (hymns)
2) Brahmanas (rituals)
3) Aryanakas (theologies)
4) Upanishads (philosophies)
Origins of the Vedas
- Vedas stretch back 3000 years
- Only put into writing 1000 years after origins. Printed in the 19th century by Max T. Miller
How do Western and Hindu attitudes to sacred texts vary?
- Hindu texts weren’t written down until perhaps 1000 years after they were composed
- Hindu ‘sacred texts’ have more fluid boundaries: The writings of holy men today are considered sacred by their worshippers
Why were the Vedas not written down for so long?
- They are sruti and were ‘heard’ by the rishis, then past down aurally from guru to disciple
- Writing was seen as ritually polluting: Aitareya Aranyaka (5:3:5): should not recite veda after one has “eaten flesh, seen blood…or written”
Why are the Vedas paradoxical according to Holm and Bowker?
- Vedic knowledge as ‘authoratitive revelation’ could be said to be a characteristic implied by the term ‘Hindu’
BUT - “…most Hindus would not have known their Hinduism through these revealed texts, but rather through the ritual traditions and the mythologies of smriti literature”
Are the Vedas exclusivist?
- They are the absolute authority for Hindus, though most know ‘their’ Hinduism from smriti
- Brahmins are the only class “qualified” to learn the texts and they are “esoteric” (Holm + Bowker)
- Bharati claims
(i) less than 5% of all Hindus ever knew these texts even by name
(ii) less than 1% knew their content
The Rig/Rg Veda
- collection (samhita) of ten books (mandalas)
- 1028 hymns
- Composed from as early as 1200 BCE by Bardic families
Sama Veda
- book of songs/chants (saman) with instructions on their recitation (gana)
- Based on Rg Veda