Officer Liability Flashcards
Title 18 241-
Conspiracy against rights (Criminal)
- Allows the federal government to prosecute anyone who (2 or more) conspire to violate a person’s civil rights
- If two or more person’s conspire to injure, oppress threaten, or intimidate any person in the free exercise or enjoyment of any right or privilege
- If two or more persons go in disguise on the highway or on property of another with intent to prevent or hinder his free exercise or enjoyment
Elements of crime one (Title 18 241)
- A conspiracy
- To injure, oppress , threaten or intimidate
- Any person
Elements of crime two (Title 18 241)
- Two or more persons go in disguise on the highway or property of another
- To prevent or hinder
- Any person
- In the exercise or enjoyment of any constitutional or federal civil right
Title 18 242
Deprivation of rights under the “color of law”(Criminal)
* Empowers the federal government to prosecute federal, state, and local law enforcement officers and other public officials under the “color of law” intentionally violate the civil rights of prisoners, suspects, or other persons
Color of law (the elements of This crime)
- To prove violation
1. An activity under “color of law” in unit, uniform, badge
2. With specific intent
3. To deprive an person
4. Constitutional or federal right - Identifies as LEO
- Performing duties
- File official documents
Title 42 1983
Civil action for Deprivation of rights- civil cause of action against state and local law enforcement officers who, acting under color of law, deprive an individual of any right. It is not a criminal statute but a civil one
- an act
- under color of law of a state, territory or DC
- depriving any person( a citizen or other person within United States jurisdiction
- of rights, privileges, or immunities secured by the constitution or federal laws
Elements of Title 42 1983
- Permits aggrieved part to sue state and local law enforcement to be civilly sued in federal court for civil rights violations
- Civil rights are guaranteed to individuals by the constitution and protected by federal law
- Rights include
- 1st amendment- freedom of speech
- 4th amendment- protection against illegal search and seizure
- 5th amendment- protection against self incrimination
- 8th amendment- protection against cruel and unusual punishment
Immunity for Constitutional violations
Sovereign Immunity, Absolute Immunity, Qualified Immunity
Sovereign Immunity
- “The king can do no wrong”
- Prevented any and all lawsuits against the crown
- US as sovereign is immune from suit unless it consents to be sued
Absolute Immunity
Avoids personal civil liability for officials, legislators,
Qualified Immunity
- Is immunity from civil suit and entitles a law enforcement officer to avoid standing trial or facing the burdens associated with civil litigation
- Officer may be entitled to QI if
- They acted reasonably
- Their conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights
Bivens
Federal law enforcement officers are civilly liable for violations of the 4th amendment
- When a federal law enforcement officer makes an arrest without probable cause or unlawfully conducts a search
- An injured party can file a Bivens suit against the officer
Most common Bivens actions
- Arrests and searches without probable cause
- Knowingly submitting false or misleading Affidavits for search arrest warrants
- Franks V Delaware Supreme Court held that a law enforcement officer violates the 4th amendment if in order to obtain a search warrant, he perjures himself or testifies in reckless disregard of the truth
- An affidavit that contains information the officer knew to be false or would have known to be false the court will likely not grant a motion to dismiss for Qualified immunity
- Failure to intervene when excessive force is used
Civil liability Tort
- Tort is a civil wrong, other than the breach of contract, court will provide a remedy in form of action for damages
- Remedy involves money
Civil Tort
Private wrong against individual
- Plaintiff V defendant
- Burden: Preponderance of evidence
- Liable- money and/ or injunction
- Purpose: compensation