Offer - Cases Flashcards
Clarke v Earl of Dunraven
A concluded bargain can be considered reached even if it is difficult or impossible to isolate an ‘offer’ and ‘acceptance’
Hermens v Acacia Group Ltd
‘Global’ rule: it is not necessary, in determining whether a contract has been formed, to identify either a precise offer or a precise acceptance, nor a precise time at which an offer or acceptance could be identified:
Carlill v Carbolic Smoke Ball Company
- Bilateral contracts
- Unilateral contracts
- Offers to public at large
- Mere puff
- Invitation to treat
- Advertisements as offers
United Dominions Trust (Commercial) Ltd v Eagle Aircraft Services Ltd
Bilateral and unilateral offers`
s26B Electronic Transactions (Qld) Act 2001
Advertisements on the internet are generally not offers, but offers to treat
Smythe v Thomas
Internet auctions are a species of auction, and so are subject to similar rules, plus any terms and conditions of the auction site
Manufacturer’s Material Insurance Ltd v John H Boardman Insurance Brokers Pty Ltd
When determining if an advertisement is mere puff or an offer the test is what a reasonable person would think of it
Harvey v Facey
A supply of information is not an offer
Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain v Boots Cash Chemists (Southern) LD
The display of an article together with its price constitutes an invitation to treat
Fisher v Bell
The display of an article together with its price constitutes an invitation to treat
Grainger & Son v Gough
Information in catalogues and circulars regarding items for sale and their price is only an invitation to treat, and placing an order constitutes an offer
Partridge v Chrittenden
- Information in catalogues and circulars regarding items for sale and their price is only an invitation to treat, and placing an order constitutes an offer
- Legislation may restrict or regulate the extent to which certain kinds of goods may be offered for sale
AGC (Advances) Ltd v McWhirter
- Auctions with a reserve - bids are offers
2. Auctions without a reserve - bids are offers
Warlow v Harrison
Auctions without a reserve - auctioneer contracts with highest bidder
Spencer v Harding
An advertisement for tender is an indication of a person’s readiness to receive offers