Offer Flashcards
Offer Definition
An expression of willingness to contract on certain terms with the intention (actual or apparent) that it should become binding as soon as it is accepted
Contract Definition
A promise or set of promises enforceable by law
Specific Offer Definition
Made to an individual or to a specific group of people
General Offer Definition
Made to the world at large
Unilateral Offer Definition
A promise which demands an act in return
Bilateral Offer Definition
A promise which demands a promise in return
Collateral Offer Definition
A promise to enter into a minor contract in return for a promise to form a major contract
Offer - Advert Cases
Partridge v Crittendon Grainger & Son v Gough Carlill v Carbolic Smokeball Co.Ltd Lefkowitz v GMS Esso Petroleum v Customs and Excise
Partridge v Crittendon - ITT
- It is an offence to “offer” to sell
- Placed advert offering bramble finches for sale
- S.6 of protection of birds act made it an offence to offer such birds for sale
- Literal rule applied - was an invitation to treat
Grainger & Son v Gough - ITT
-It was not an offer to sell the wine but an invitation to treat
Carlill v Carbolic Smokeball Co.Ltd - General Unilateral Offer (advert)
- Reward = £100 for catching influenza after using ball 3 times daily for 2 weeks
- £1000 deposited in the bank to “show our sincerity in the matter”
- It was an offer to the whole world
- Did not have to notify acceptance but merely perform demands
- Business and commercial matter therefore presumed binding
Lefkowitz v GMS - Collateral Offer (advert)
- Promise to give fur coat in exchange for £1
- Terms = to be one of the first three in the queue on a certain date and time
- Store could not discriminate on gender and had to sell to Mr Lefkowitz
- Business and commercial matter therefore presumed binding
Esso Petroleum v Customs and Excise - Collateral Offer (advert)
“Firstly he is accepting the offer of a coin if he buys 4 gallons of petrol. Secondly he himself is offering to buy 4 gallons of petrol, this offer is accepted by the filling of his tank”
- Must be in reliance of the advert to accept
- Business and commercial matter therefore presumed binding
A letter can be…
A statement, invitation to treat or an offer
Offer - Letters cases
Harvey v Facey
Gibson v Manchester City Council
Storer v MCC
Harvey v Facey - Statement
- Telegraph asking for the lowest cash price
- It was a statement, not an offer
Gibson v Manchester City Council - Invitation to Treat
- May be prepared to sell
- Was an Invitation to treat
- Lacked intention to be bound
- There were no promises to accept
Storer v MCC - Offer
- Letter saying - “If you sign the agreement and send it to me, I will send you the agreement signed on behalf of the council
- Letter was a Collateral Offer - specific unilateral and specific bilateral
- There was intention to be bound
Denning - “A man cannot get out of a contract by saying “i did not intend to contract” if by his words he has done so…
Offer - Shop Cases
Fisher v Bell
PSGB v Boots
Fisher v Bell
-Was an offence to offer for sale
PSGB v Boots - Invitation to Treat
- Goods on shop shelves are invitations to treat not offers
- Products sold must be supervised by the pharmacist (Pharmacy & Poisons Act 1933)
- Shopkeepers must have the right to refuse to sell
Lord Goddard - “Ordinary principles of common sense must be applied here”
Offer - Auction Cases
Payne v Cave
Warlow v Harrison
Harris v Nickerson
Payne v Cave (auction)
- Auctioneer invites offer
- Customer makes offer
- Offer is accepted by the fall of the hammer and a contract is made
- Withdrawal of an offer must be made before acceptance
Warlow v Harrison
-The horse was an invitation to treat and was a collateral offer
General - Offer to the world
Unilateral - Promise in exchange for the act of being the highest bidder
Specific - Offer made by the highest bidder
Bilateral - For the auctioneer to form a contract with the highest bidder