OBJECTIVITY OF MORAL JUDGEMENTS Flashcards
In what sense are moral judgments objective?
- It is usually agreed that the validity of the moral judgments of any individual is independent of his own feelings
- Opinions and must be ascertained by some more objective standard.
But what determines the standard?
Is it simply the moral consciousness of the society in which he lives
moral judgments are objective so far as individuals are concerned but that they are not objective when the attempt is made to compare the moral judgments of one age and clime with those of another.
Henry Sidgwick thought that he could discover three axioms of the good:
- justice
2 prudence
3 benevolence
impartiality between one’s self and other persons, treating similar cases similarly;
JUSTICE
impartial concern for all parts of one’s
life, not preferring a present lesser good to a greater future good
PRUDENCE
preference for the greater good of another to one’s own lesser good
BENEVOLENCE
In what sense Henry Sidgwick axioms of good quantifiable?
• The more good it is, the more it is desirable
What is the objective basis of morality or
is determined by Moral consciousness of the ethics?
- The line of ethical development that proceeds from age to age
- The comparatively permanent native
inheritance of mankind -
• the instincts
• the relatively enduring type of social (we have every reason to hope prove it will be)
• the citizenship
Moral judgements are deducible only from _______________
quantitative good
The relative strength of instincts differs in individuals, and results in various types of
PERSONALITY
Love, friendship, and beauty can be stated as
PRIORI
What makes virtues instrumental?
They can promote and increase love, friendship, and beauty
morality is a core to act well that every moral theory should accept, at least as a starting point.
MINIMUM CONCEPTION
Why is it impossible to deduce a priori moral judgments universally from moral intuitions?
These notions are formal, and the content to be attached to them in moral judgments are synthetic
How is the content of the good decided?
Careful reflection and application of the test