Non Fatal Offences (CL book 4) Flashcards
ASSULT steps to success
intro - define (common law defence - sentence in s.39 Crim justice act 2009)
1. must be an act
2. made v aiuf
3. immediate
4. MR intends for v to aiuf
5. MR reckless for making v fear aiuf
ASSULT what section and act is it under
s.39 criminal justice act 1988
ASSULT what is the AR
must be an act
causes v to apprehend immediate unlawful force
ASSULT what is the mr
intention or subjective recklessness to cause v to fear violence
ASSULT what is the case that showed words can be an assult
constanta
words can be an act
ASSULT which cases showed silence can be an assult
Ireland / burstow
silence / heavy breathing can amount to an act
ASSULT which case showed words can cancel out an assult
Tuberville v savage
ASSULT which case showed what immediate meant
Smith
immediate means imminent
ASSULT which case showed the MR includes recklessness
Logdon V DPP
fake gun at woman
BATTERY steps to success
intro - s.39 cja 1988 - common law offence
1. AR - act or omission
2. AR - unlawful force
3. AR - direct/ indirect
4. MR - intent for unlawful force
5. MR - reckless for unlawful force
BATTERY section and act
s.39 criminal justice act 1988
BATTERY what is the AR
application of unlawful force on another person
BATTERY what is the MR
intention or subjective recklessness to apply the force
BATTERY which case showed that battery can be an omission
Santa bermudez
didn’t tell police about needle
BATTERY which case showed that battery can be indirect
DPP V K
acid in in hand dryer
BATTERY which case showed that force can be touching clothes
Thomas
touching a persons clothes while they’re wearing them is the same as touching the person
BATTERY what is the case for MR
Fagan
MR after AR if continuing act
ASSULT / BATTERY EVALUATION 3Ps
p - no act of parliament
d - against rule of law as it’s uncertain and how can ppl regulate
h- parliament recognised to set out max sentence, so must be ok w it
ASSULT / BATTERY EVALUATION
delevopment of law
p- common law. developed by judges. up to date
d- defined mr and ar . includes modern day stalking (constanza) (ireland/ burstow). and indirect acts
h- should be parliament defining them, but judges been doing it for years and are fine, maybe better
ASSULT / BATTERY EVALUATION
sentencing
p- max 6 months or fine. protects ppl
d- unlimited fine. link to ds income. (smith - homeless)
h- maybe more appropriate for community sentence as vs had no actual harm done
ASSULT / BATTERY EVALUATION
justice - outdated
p- outdated language confusing
d - assult and battery sound more violent in modern terms when it actually includes slight touch (thomas)
h- legal personnel have good understanding and can explain it to people when necessary