Non Fatal Offences Flashcards
Assault occasioning in actual bodily harm
S.47 Offences Against the Person Act 1861
Infliction of grievous bodily harm and malicious wounding
S.20 Offences Against the Person Act
Grievous bodily harm with intent
S.18 Offences Against the Person Act
Facts about assault
Common law offence
Charged under S.39 Criminal Justice Act 1988
Summary offence
Punishment for assault
6 month imprisonment or up to £5000 fine
Assault AR
An act that causes the victim to apprehend the immediate infliction of violence
Collins v Wilcock
Assault
Only needs to cause fear, no force needs to actually be applied
Logdon v DPP
Assault
The victim had apprehended immediate physical violence and the defendant had been at least reckless as to whether this would occur
Smith v Chief Superintendent of Working Police Station
Assault
Door locked and behind a window but still fear her safety, this is sufficient immediate for an assault
R v Constanza
Assault
Not excluding the immediate future
R v Ireland
Assault
Silent phone calls considered to be and assault
Words can amount to an assault
Tuberville v Savage
Assault
Words can negate assault
Assault MR
Must intend to cause the victim to fear the immediate infliction of unlawful force or see the risk that fear would be created
Assault MR
Must intend to cause the victim to fear the immediate infliction of unlawful force or see the risk that fear would be created
R v Cunningham, R v G and another
Subjective recklessness linked to assault MR
Definition of assault
An intentional or reckless causing of an apprehension of immediate unlawful personal violence
Battery definition
Infliction of unlawful harm
Batter facts
Common law offence
Summary offence
Charged under S.39 Criminal Justice Act 1988
Punishment for battery
6 months imprisonment or a fine
Battery AR
The application of unlawful force against the victim or another
Collins v Wilcock
Battery
Merest unwanted touch
Haystead v Chief Constable of Derbyshire
Battery
When the mother lost control of the child, this was entirely and immediately the result of the defendants action in punching her
Fagan v Metropolitan Police Commissioner
Battery
Both the indirect and direct application of force could constitute the AR of battery
R v Thomas
Battery
The term physical force implies that a high level of force needs to be applied but this isn’t the case. The victims must be aware of the defendants actions in order to be afraid
Wood v DPP
Battery
Technical assault by the officer and Wood was entitled to struggle and was not guilty of any offence
DPP v Santana - Bermudez
Battery
Battery can be an omissions too
Defendants failure to tell police officer of the needle could amount to the AR
Haystead v Chief Constable of Derbyshire
Battery
The defendant must cause the AR of battery. If the victim incurs the actual infliction of unlawful personal violence but the defendant did not cause this, the defendant cannot be liable
Battery MR
An intention to apply unlawful physical force to someone or subjective recklessness as to whether that force was applied
R v Venna
MR of battery
S.47 AR part 1
Assault or battery
Requires proof of the AR of assault or battery
S.47 AR part 2
Chain of causation must be established and the assault or battery must occassion in actual bodily harm for criminal liability
R v Roberts
S47
Reaction to circumstances was reasonably forseeable so the chain of causation was not broken
S.47 AR part 3
Actual bodily harm
No description only cases for actual bodily harm
R v Donovan
S47
ABH includes any physical or psychiatric harm that is not “merely transitory and trifling”
Miller
S47
Any hurt or injury that interferes with the health or comfort of the victim
T v DPP
S47
Loss of consciousness even momentarily was held to be actual bodily harm
DPP v Smith
S47
Cutting the victims hair can amount to actual bodily harm
Chanfook
S47
Includes psychiatric injury but must be an identifiable clinical condition. Needs to be more than transitory and trifling
S.47 MR
The same as assault or battery
Roberts
S47
Found guilty of ABH even though he had not intended any injury or realised there was a risk in injury however he had applied unlawful force and this satisfies the MR for common assault
Savage
S47
Had the intention to apply unlawful force
Malicious wounding or infliction grievous bodily harm
S.20
Punishment for S.20
triable either way for 5 years
facts about S.20
Unlawful and malicious wounding and unlawful and malicious inflicting grievous bodily harm. Applicable when there is a wound but not GBH or when there is GBH but not a wound
S.20 AR
Grievous bodily harm, serious harm following Saunders
DPP v Smith
S20
Really serious harm
R v Brown and Stratton
S20
Several lesser injuries should be considered together, none of the injuries in isolation would have been sufficient for this charge
Clarence
S20
Word inflict was given a restrictive meaning
R v Dica
S20
Infecting someone with HIV was inflicting GBH
R v Halliday
S20
Convicted because the injuries his wife sustained were a direct result of the defendants act
Bollom
S20
Severity of injuries should be assessed in accordance with the victims age and health
Burstow
S20
Serious psychiatric injury can be GBH
Wounding
Requires a breaking of the skin. Bleeding must normally occur as seen in Moriarty v Brookes
JCC v Eisenhower
Wounding
Not a sufficient wound under S.20 as the skin was not broken
Wood
Wounding
Collar bone was broken but the skin wasn’t so not a wound
S.20 MR
Intention or subjective recklessness as to some harm, must be done maliciously.
Cunningham
S.20
An intention to do harm that was done or recklessness as to whether that harm should occur or not (the defendant must foresee it)
R v Mowatt
S.20
Does not need to intend to cause GBH or wounding but must either intend to cause some harm or be reckless as to whether some harm will
DPP v A
S20
It is only required to have foreseen some harm might occur not that it would occur
R v Adaye
S20
Did not know conclusively that he had HIV, the Crown Court held that knowledge of a higher level of risk of HIV was sufficient to hold that the defendant had acted recklessly
Intend to maliciously wound or cause grievous bodily harm with intent
S18 Offences Against the Persons Act 1861
Punishment for S18
Maximum sentence of life
S18 AR
Wounding or causing GBH, it is necessary to prove the defendant’s actions were the substantial cause of the wound or GBH and causation is required
S18 MR
Intent to cause serious harm or maliciously wound
R v Belfon
S18
must have specific intent to do some GBH or resist or prevent the lawful apprehension or detention of any person
Taylor
S18
Intention to wound is not enough for the MR
Nedrick and Woollin
S18
Intention can be direct or oblique
Examples of S47
Loss or breaking or teeth Temporary loss of sensory functions Extensive or multiple bruising Displaced broken nose Minor fractures Psychiatric injury which is more than fear, distress or panic
Examples of S20
Resulting in permanent disability or permanent loss of a sensory function
More then minor permanent visible disfigurement
Broken or displaced limbs or bones
Substantial loss of blood
Lengthy treatment needed or incapacity
Any serious cut or laceration is a wounding under S18 or S20
Examples of S18
Repeated or planned attack
Deliberate selection of a weapon or any adaptation of an article to cause injury
Making prior threats
Using an offensive weapon against or kicking the victims head