New Rights : Class Inequalities Flashcards
What are the new right theories for class inequality ?
- Saunders : in defence of inequality
- Murray : underclass
What does Saunders: in defence of inequality argue about society ?
Society based on social equality and like be possible if considerable force were used
What example does Saunders: in defense of inequality use for force ?
threat of death or imprisonment
What does using force ensure according to Saunders : in defence of inequality?
To ensure that everyone did their jobs to the best of their abilities because not be motivated by economic rewards
What forms of equality does Saunders : in defence of inequality support ?
Legal equality and equality of opportunity
What equality does Saunder: in defense of inequality reject ?
Equality of outcomes
What is legal equality ?
being judged by the same laws and having the same legal right
What is equality of opportunity?
Everyone has the same chances to compete for unequal rewards
What is equality of outcomes ?
Everyone being rewarded in the same way whether they deserve it or not
What does Saunder say is a desirable form of equality?
Degree of inequality as motivates people to compete and have equal opportunity to take part in competition
What is Saunders critical of ?
- Labour Party as wants to equalize society by taxing rich to pay benefits
- education as wants to give w/c to do well as m/c children but m/c are more intelligent and able than w/c children
What are the evaluation of Saunders ?
- can we trust free market capitalism to allow equality of opportunity or legal equality ?
- are people only motivated by external rewards ?
- Tumin: power and rewards
What is the evaluation can we trust free market capitalism to allow equality of opportunity or legal equality ?
- Saunders is mistaken to assume that capitalist societies based on free market necessarily offers individuals more freedom than socialist or communist societies which seek to make people equal
Are people only motivated by external rewards evaluation by Saunders ?
Is it true that rewards motivate people to do demanding jobs ? Does not account for those motivated by altruism or sense of service
What does Tumin power and rewards : evaluation of Saunders say ?
Those in higher paid jobs reflects their power rather than agreement to society that they need it