Neo-Marxism Flashcards
What is Neo-Marxism?
A macro-level perspective which attempts to reinterpret, revise, or update Marx’s theoretical ideas so that they better explain recent developments in capitalist society
What does Neo-Marxism theorize?
the economic, political, and ideological aspects of contemporary capitalist society
The three developments that involved Neo-Marxism
Economic Determinism = stressed economic issues in the analysis of capitalist society
Hegelian Marxism = shifted stress to ideological issues in the analysis of capitalist society
Critical Theory = shifted stress to ideological issues in the analysis of capitalist society
Why was Neo-Marxism so inaccessible?
- Written in German/Italian
- Inaccessible to public
- Only started to become English in the 50s-60s
Why did Neo-Marxism grow in the 60s?
Partially due to problems with SF
–> Focus on social order in SF meant it had a lot of difficulty addressing social conflict
–> Various social movements were struggling for social change, led away from SF and towards Neo-Marxism
What does later Neo-Marxism focus on?
it includes analysis of economic issues, political issues, and ideological issues
1990s Debate of Neo-Marxism
- Debate among scholars over continuing relevance of Neo-Marxism
- Emerged 1990s after the breakup of the Soviet Union (1989) and country started reverting from socialism to capitalism
The two sides of the 1990 Neo-Marxism Debate
Right-wing academics: Argued Neo-Marxian theory must be abandoned: End of Soviet Union/ collapse of socialism/ move back to capitalism showed that Marx was wrong
Left-wing academics: argued Neo-Marxian theory is still relevant and crucial for understanding various aspects of capitalist society
How is Neo-Marxism helpful today?
Useful in understanding class inequality, ownership concentration, globalization, and the mass media (etc.)
Economic Determinism Definition
assumption that the economic system directly shapes all other aspects of society (such as the political system, ideological system, etc.)
Economic Determinism’s Impact on Neo-Marxism
The early Neo-Marxists who believed in economic determinism saw the breakdown of capitalism as being inevitable
T/F: Marx Focused on Dialectical Materialism
FALSE
What is Hegelian Marxism?
A reaction against the economic determinism of the early Neo-Marxists
- Based on ideas of Hegel and Marx (combined)
2 Key concepts of Hegel’s philosophy
The Dialectic = conflicts and contradictions generate change
Idealism = importance of mental products
Hegelian Marxism Analysis of Capitalist society
- drew on hegel’s idealism and dialectic
- recognizes material conditions in capitalism
- does not focus on economics
- focuses on examining conflicts and contradictions connected to ideology
Antonio Gramsci Biographic Sketch
- Italian neo-Marxist (1920s and 1930s)
- Intellectual and political activist (leader of Italian Communist Party)
- Opposed to fascist regime = authoritarian and extreme right-wing system of gov (Benito Mussolini)
—> Threatened by Gramsci due to left-wing views and extreme left-wing party: had Gramsci arrested, put on trial on trumped-up charges, convicted and put in prison on a long-term sentence - While in prison: wrote a series of notebooks (32) filled with theoretical ideas
- Died in prison, but his notebooks were smuggled out and later published (Selections from the Prison Notebooks)
- Wrote many ideas in code otherwise they would be confiscated and from memory
Gramschi main theoretical ideas
- Particularly interested in trying to explain why proletariat revolution that Marx expected did not occur
- Coercion and consent
- Hegemony
Coercion and Consent (Gramsci)
- Coercion part of reason why rev did not occur: threat of physical force helped to keep working class in line
- Consent other part of why: working class might consent to its domination
Hegemony (Gramsci)
- Intellectual, moral, and political leadership
- Leadership is consensual
- Dominant group (bourgeoisie) exercising this consensual leadership over a series of subordinate groups (proletariat)
How does hegemony work?
- Works through ideology: various ideas and povs
- Through these ideas/ povs that the dominant group tries to make linkages to the interests of subordinate groups
- Satisfied with a mere few benefits (“good enough”)
- They then give their consent to their own domination
Two types of wars in resistance to hegemony
War of Position
War of Manoeuvre
War of Position
long-term process involving developing and spreading counter-hegemony = alternative ideology and culture that is developed a spread by various organizations associated with subordinate groups
- Eg. trade unions
- War between different ideological positions
- When successful, won due to getting most people in subordinate groups to accept that systems are not in their ideology: then moves to next type of war
War of Manoeuvre
short-term tactic involving sudden frontal attack on capitalist state (gov and admin)
- Subordinate groups would start a rev against the dominant group; would begin by trying to seize state power
- Marx did not anticipate how strong/ effective capitalist ideology would be in getting people to accept it
- Gramsci: rev can only begin after the war of position has been won
Impact of Gramsci’s ideas
- Huge impact on neo-Marxian theory esp after english translation of Selections from the Prison Notebooks (1971) from its og Italian
- Examining various types of ideology and conflict
- His ideas have enough flexibility that they can be applied in various ways: largely due to coding he used (“dominant group” and “series of subordinate groups”) broadened applications