Neo-Marxism Flashcards

1
Q

What is Neo-Marxism?

A

A macro-level perspective which attempts to reinterpret, revise, or update Marx’s theoretical ideas so that they better explain recent developments in capitalist society

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What does Neo-Marxism theorize?

A

the economic, political, and ideological aspects of contemporary capitalist society

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

The three developments that involved Neo-Marxism

A

Economic Determinism = stressed economic issues in the analysis of capitalist society
Hegelian Marxism = shifted stress to ideological issues in the analysis of capitalist society
Critical Theory = shifted stress to ideological issues in the analysis of capitalist society

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Why was Neo-Marxism so inaccessible?

A
  • Written in German/Italian
  • Inaccessible to public
  • Only started to become English in the 50s-60s
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

Why did Neo-Marxism grow in the 60s?

A

Partially due to problems with SF
–> Focus on social order in SF meant it had a lot of difficulty addressing social conflict
–> Various social movements were struggling for social change, led away from SF and towards Neo-Marxism

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

What does later Neo-Marxism focus on?

A

it includes analysis of economic issues, political issues, and ideological issues

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

1990s Debate of Neo-Marxism

A
  • Debate among scholars over continuing relevance of Neo-Marxism
  • Emerged 1990s after the breakup of the Soviet Union (1989) and country started reverting from socialism to capitalism
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

The two sides of the 1990 Neo-Marxism Debate

A

Right-wing academics: Argued Neo-Marxian theory must be abandoned: End of Soviet Union/ collapse of socialism/ move back to capitalism showed that Marx was wrong

Left-wing academics: argued Neo-Marxian theory is still relevant and crucial for understanding various aspects of capitalist society

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

How is Neo-Marxism helpful today?

A

Useful in understanding class inequality, ownership concentration, globalization, and the mass media (etc.)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Economic Determinism Definition

A

assumption that the economic system directly shapes all other aspects of society (such as the political system, ideological system, etc.)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Economic Determinism’s Impact on Neo-Marxism

A

The early Neo-Marxists who believed in economic determinism saw the breakdown of capitalism as being inevitable

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

T/F: Marx Focused on Dialectical Materialism

A

FALSE

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What is Hegelian Marxism?

A

A reaction against the economic determinism of the early Neo-Marxists
- Based on ideas of Hegel and Marx (combined)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

2 Key concepts of Hegel’s philosophy

A

The Dialectic = conflicts and contradictions generate change
Idealism = importance of mental products

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Hegelian Marxism Analysis of Capitalist society

A
  • drew on hegel’s idealism and dialectic
  • recognizes material conditions in capitalism
  • does not focus on economics
  • focuses on examining conflicts and contradictions connected to ideology
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Antonio Gramsci Biographic Sketch

A
  • Italian neo-Marxist (1920s and 1930s)
  • Intellectual and political activist (leader of Italian Communist Party)
  • Opposed to fascist regime = authoritarian and extreme right-wing system of gov (Benito Mussolini)
    —> Threatened by Gramsci due to left-wing views and extreme left-wing party: had Gramsci arrested, put on trial on trumped-up charges, convicted and put in prison on a long-term sentence
  • While in prison: wrote a series of notebooks (32) filled with theoretical ideas
  • Died in prison, but his notebooks were smuggled out and later published (Selections from the Prison Notebooks)
  • Wrote many ideas in code otherwise they would be confiscated and from memory
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

Gramschi main theoretical ideas

A
  • Particularly interested in trying to explain why proletariat revolution that Marx expected did not occur
  • Coercion and consent
  • Hegemony
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

Coercion and Consent (Gramsci)

A
  • Coercion part of reason why rev did not occur: threat of physical force helped to keep working class in line
  • Consent other part of why: working class might consent to its domination
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

Hegemony (Gramsci)

A
  • Intellectual, moral, and political leadership
  • Leadership is consensual
  • Dominant group (bourgeoisie) exercising this consensual leadership over a series of subordinate groups (proletariat)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

How does hegemony work?

A
  • Works through ideology: various ideas and povs
  • Through these ideas/ povs that the dominant group tries to make linkages to the interests of subordinate groups
  • Satisfied with a mere few benefits (“good enough”)
  • They then give their consent to their own domination
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

Two types of wars in resistance to hegemony

A

War of Position
War of Manoeuvre

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

War of Position

A

long-term process involving developing and spreading counter-hegemony = alternative ideology and culture that is developed a spread by various organizations associated with subordinate groups
- Eg. trade unions
- War between different ideological positions
- When successful, won due to getting most people in subordinate groups to accept that systems are not in their ideology: then moves to next type of war

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

War of Manoeuvre

A

short-term tactic involving sudden frontal attack on capitalist state (gov and admin)
- Subordinate groups would start a rev against the dominant group; would begin by trying to seize state power
- Marx did not anticipate how strong/ effective capitalist ideology would be in getting people to accept it
- Gramsci: rev can only begin after the war of position has been won

24
Q

Impact of Gramsci’s ideas

A
  • Huge impact on neo-Marxian theory esp after english translation of Selections from the Prison Notebooks (1971) from its og Italian
  • Examining various types of ideology and conflict
  • His ideas have enough flexibility that they can be applied in various ways: largely due to coding he used (“dominant group” and “series of subordinate groups”) broadened applications
25
Application of the War of Position to Contemp. society
- Points to various ways in which a counter-hegemony (alt ideology and culture) is created and circulated in society - Contemporary neo-Marxists say various left-wing social movements have tried to get their messages out through alternative media
26
Application of the War of Manoeuvre to Contemp. society
- Contemporary neo-Marxist have broadened concept - War of Manoeuvre involves rapid assaults on various aspects of capitalist society, not necessarily capitalist state - Used to desc protests by various left-wing social movements at meetings of the World Trade Organization and the G20
27
Stages of Neo-Marxian Economic Analysis
- Return to economic analysis - changes in capitalism - Monopoly capitalism and changes in work
28
Return to economic analysis (1960)
- Neo-Marxism started to become more popular among sociologists/ other scholars in 1960s - An economic strain in neo-Marxian analysis emerged: instead of engaging in cultural analysis and analysis of ideology, other neo-Marxian scholars began to return to economic analysis (but WITHOUT economic determinism)
29
Changes in Capitalism
1966: Paul Baron & Paul Sweezy Monopoly Capital: An Essay on the American Economic and Social Order
30
Paul Baron & Paul Sweezy Monopoly Capital: An Essay on the American Economic and Social Order
- Argued Marx’s ideas needed to be updated to account for the historical shift from competitive capitalism to monopoly capitalism - Competitive capitalism (CC) - Monopoly capitalism (MC
31
Competitive Capitalism (Baron & Sweezy)
a variety of small companies exist in a given sector of the economy and none of them have control over that sector
32
Monology Capitalism (Baron & Sweezy)
one/ a few large compan(y)(ies) control a given sector of the economy
33
Comparison between CC & MC (Baron & Sweezy)
Organization CC: small companies MC: giant corporations Competition CC: based on prices, trying to offer the lowest $$$ to attract more customers MC: based on sales, trying to get a bigger share of a particular market through more appealing ads or packaging Ownership CC: Held by entrepreneurs MC: stockholders
34
(Harry Braverman) Labor and Monopoly Capital: the Degradation of Work in the Twentieth Century (1974)
- Interested in trying to update Marx’s work in another way in terms of his analysis of factory workers - The different kinds of workers in 20th C. capitalist factory - While looking at factory workers, wanted to extend his analysis to office and service workers as well
35
Monopoly Capitalism and Control over factory workers (Braverman)
Noted that under MC, capitalists (through their managers) exert control over factory workers Argues there are 3 types of control at play: - Specialization - Scientific Management/Taylorism - Mechanization
36
Specialization (Control over factory workers)
breaking down tasks into minute activities, each is assigned to diff worker - Result: worker needs few skills (if any) to perform such a specific task - Enhances control of managers because it is much easier to control a worker doing a specific task than someone using a wide range of skills to perform multiple tasks
37
Scientific Management/Taylorism (Control over factory workers)
(Frederick W. Taylor): involves minimizing the time spent on a specific task - T: developed sci techniques to determine how quickly and efficiently a specific task could be performed - Time and motion studies: time motions when performing a task, and would apply minimum amount to everyone
38
Mechanization (Control over factory workers)
the skills are built into the machine so workers require less - Worker simply has to tend to the machine - Easier to control a machine than a person - The more you constrict the worker of skills and use the machine, the more ctrl you have over the workers
39
Control over office and service workers (Braverman)
Offered a useful analysis of how these 3 types of control have been used to control other workers too Argued that office workers and service workers are being subjected to the same forms of control that have been used on factory workers
40
Office workers being controlled (Braverman)
- Faced specialization in the activities of clerical workers, which have been divided up so that they are responsible for specific tasks that do not require extensive skills - Face scientific management and mechanization, through the use of computers to measure and monitor the productivity of office workers
41
Service workers being controlled (Braverman)
Includes people who work in fast food, retail - Specialization in fast food workers: one person for frying patty, one for dressing burger, etc. - Scientific management because all of these broken up tasks are precisely timed - Mechanization through: 1. Assembly line production: pass product down a line of workers 2. Cash registers that have deskilled workers - All a way for managers to control workers
42
Immanueal Wallerstein Hictorical Analysis of Neo-Marxism
Marx’s work was always historically grounded: analysis of capitalism, dialectical/ historical materialism deeply rooted in history --> Ignored analysis of shifts from one mode of production to another --> Looked at conflicts and contradictions in material production over time - 1970s-2010s analyzed modern world system with 4 publications - 2013: planned for 5th volume but died in 2019
43
Wallerstein theoretical ideas
- unit of analysis - the world system - the capitalist world-system
44
Unit of analysis (Wallerstein)
Refers to what is being studied - For most Neo-Marxists, the unit of analysis is either classes or the state: but for Wallerstein, those were too narrow/ specific for his purpose, instead used ‘The World System’
45
The world system (Wallerstein)
a social system that has a single division of labour, that encompasses multiple dominated cultures Could take 1 of 2 forms - world empire: a world-system that has a common political system (roman empire) - world economy: a world-system that does NOT have a common political system
46
The Capitalist World-System (Wallerstein)
A specific world system marked by the historical emergence of the capitalist world economy 3 historical stages in emergence of capitalist world-system: - Formation - Consolidation - Expansion
47
Formation (Wallerstein)
(1450-1640) - There was a crisis of feudalism in the Euro economy, paved way for beginnings of capitalism - During capitalist development, certain countries were dominant: Britain and the Netherlands
48
Consolidation (Wallerstein)
(1640-1815) - There was a serious recession in the Euro capitalist economy, led to entrenchment, then only 1 dominant country remained (Britain)
49
Expansion (Wallerstein)
(1815-1917) 3 key developments: (i) beginnings of industrial capitalism (growth of factories and assembly lines) (ii) geographic extension of the Euro economy to encompass the globe: raw materials and cheap labour needed for industrial production (iii) appearance of other dominant countries: USA
50
Divisions of Capitalism world systems (Wallerstein)
divided into different and unequal strata - Upper stratum (Core states) - Lower stratum (Peripheral areas) - Middle stratum (Semi-peripheral areas)
51
Upper Stratum (Capitalist world system)
Core states = countries that are at the centre of world econ production - The exploiting countries - Specific countries can differ over time, but currently: USA and Britain
52
Lower Stratum (Capitalist world system)
Peripheral areas = countries that are marginal but necessary to world econ production due to being source of raw materials and cheap labour - The exploited countries - Specific countries can differ over time, but currently: most African countries and many south American countries
53
Middle Stratum (Capitalist world system)
Semi-peripheral areas = countries that are structurally necessary to world econ production but outside its core poli and econ conditions - Simultaneous exploiting and exploited - Specific countries can differ over time, but currently: Mexico, India, China
54
Crisis' in Capitalist world systems
- Escalation production costs, environmental pollution, etc. - Expanding gap between core states and peripheral areas due to inequality that exists between them: Gap is deepening instability within the system - Parallels Marx’s dialectical analysis: can only have social change due to contradictions/ conflicts in society - After destruction of capitalist world-system, sees emergence of a new and different world-system: a socialist world government
55
Two criticisms of Wallerstein
- The conceptual scheme: difficult to neatly categorize countries in relation to his conceptual scheme of core states and peripheral areas - Analysis of classes: with his focus on the relationships between core states and peripheral areas, argue that Wallerstein has lost sight of what is really important (relationship between classes in different societies)