NATURE OF KNOWLEDGE Flashcards
SOLIPSISM
- I am the only thing that actually exists
- Everything is a product of your mind
- What then is the source of my ideas of objects, and why should I think my ideas accurately represent them?
Descartes 2 classifications of thought
ideas: some caused from outside, some innate
ideas in action: judgments and emotions
degrees of being
- intrinsic/actual
- representative/sujective
reality
2 sources of the nature of error
- intellect:
-It neither affirms nor denies propositions.
-Its role is to present me with ideas regarding which I can make judgments. - Will: to accept or reject a
proposition.
-Freedom of the will from what our intellect presents
descartes truth rule
the cartesian circle
- he assumes the truth of the argument, a circle
CPI, what does it prove?
- causal principle of ideas; proves that god exists and is not a deciever
- deception is an imperfection
- if he can prove there is non deceiving god the truth rule is valid
*we vividly and clearly perceive it
empiricism
- all knowledge is derived from sense experience
rationalism
- knowledge is derived from reason and logic
humes theory of ideas
impressions vs ideas
- impressions; feelings, perceptions, senses, emotions–experience, Make the first appearance in the soul
- ideas; thinking
simple idea and impression theory
hume
impression; EX pain
idea; EX thinking about pain
* are ones that don’tallow any distinction or separation ·among their parts·
complex theory
impression; listening to an orchestra
idea; thinking about orchestra
* can be distinguished into
parts
ideas and impressions correspondence
- Can have an idea about things that aren’t physical or exist; unicorn, there is no impression
- Simple ideas are derived from simple impressions, not vice versa
-impressions resemble ideas
idea of the self
-our concept of the self is of something constant and persistent, but there is no experience that is constant
-so, there is no impression that produces the idea of the self
* therefore there is no real idea of the self that is constant
Epiphenomenalism
- physicalism
*does not have any causal power in the brain or body
and hume’s response
the origin of ideas- 2 sources of foundation of knowledge
locke
- sensation: through senses convey to the mind smth that produces the perceptions of the object
- reflection:the notice that the mind takes of what it is doing,
and how= ideas
What are innate ideas?
-ideas already known in the brain, not through experience
Locke’s argument why there are no innate ideas
1.the universally accpeted principles-universal consent can be explain in other ways than it being innate
2.children and idiots don’t act the way they should if they has innate ideas
argument for innatesness, and locke’s repsonse
-men will come to these truths in the need of reason
-it doesn’t account for mathemeatical maxims, you have to understand them seperately from reason. it doesnt make sense that we have to go through that process to access something given to us by nature
-it goes against the it is, and it is not
what is lockes analogy for thinking and the brain
- ideas are to the soul as motion to the body - motion is not essential to the body, thinking is not essential to the min
- it is not self evident
hume’s reasons of confusion of our self identity
we confuse 2 mental activities- thinking in a sequence and one uniterrupted object.
the resemblance of these 2 generate confusion
-we use the soul to connect the different parts