Nature of God Flashcards
What does Descartes say about gods omnipotence - unlimited
God can do anything even the logically impossible.
Descartes example of gods omnipotence
Make a square circle or a married bachelor
C.S Lewis and aquinas view on logically impossible things - unlimited
These are misuse of language and a nonsense statement, so God not being able to do this is not a limitation
Mavrodes’ solution to the paradox of the stone.
God has unlimited power so there being a stone he can’t lift is impossible.
Swinburne’s view on Gods omnipotence - limited
God is limited to the logically possible as statements like making a circle square are contradictory
Geach view on omnipotence - unlimited
Derived from greek word for almighty ‘pantokrator’ meaning power over everything rather than to do everything.
William of Ockham view on omnipotence - limited
God has ordained power, meaning power within the world since he created the world so cannot uncreate the world or change the past.
McQuarrie view on omnipotence - limited
God limits himself to incarnate as Jesus
What are the two sides of views on omnipotence
Limited and unlimited
Platinga view on omnipotence - limited
God chooses to limit his powers so that the world can function with free will
How does omnipotence relate to religious language
Aquinas argument of proportions, shows humans cant understand gods level of omnipotence with our definition
What is Whitehead and Hartshornes view on omnipotence - unlimited
A limited god is much less impressive than an unlimited one
What are the three critiques of Descartes view of omnipotence
- If god can do anything then he can do things against his loving nature
- Logically impossible things aren things as they are logically impossible
- Problem of evil
What is the idea of god creating something from nothing called
ExNihilo
What does Boethius have god as
Eternal
What does bioethics call gods eternity
A simultaneous present
For Boethius what does god being eternal mean
God is outside of human time constraints, he observes from an eternal present seeing past present future at the same time.
What does Aquinas use to support Boethius
one person is stood on a hill looking down at the road and all the people on it, they are like god as they can see the past where the traveller has walked, present where they are walking, and the future where the traveller is going to walk all at the same time.
What does Boethius argue gods knowledge is like
Gods knowledge is of a simultaneous presence, it isnt a foreknowledge
What problem did Boethius realise gods knowledge created
If god can see our future actions, then how can humans act otherwise, gods foreknowledge isnt the cause of our actions, free will is
What is Boethius idea of conditional and simple necessity and example
A man walking on a sunny day, simple necessity is the sun shining because that is what the sun must do. The man walking is conditional necessity as this has been chosen by free will. God only sees the future that is a result of free will or conditional necessity, he sees the man walking because the man chose to walk
Simple necessity
necessity of nature acting according to law