MPRE Flashcards
Who has the ultimate authority to regulate the legal profession?
The courts
Duty to disclose
Must disclose if lawyer knows another lawyer has violated the rules that raises a substantial question to that lawyer’s honesty, trustworthiness, or fitness as a lawyer
Exceptions to duty to disclose
Confidential communications and approved lawyer’s assistance program (ie. substance abuse program)
Rule for admission to legal profession
Must be psychologically and morally fit to practice law
What does being morally fit mean?
Good moral character. No acts of moral turpitude (lying, violence, theft, recklessness, sexual misconduct, false statements to the bar, etc)
Impermissible standards - what govt not allowed to require for admission
- citizenship - no need to be a US citizen or citizen of a particular state
- Political beliefs (Exception: refusing to swear allegiance to the state or US constitution and participating in organization involved in illegal objectives
Duty to supervise
Each lawyer having direct supervisory authority over another lawyer must take measures to ensure that subordinate lawyer is complying with the RPC
When is a supervisor responsible for ethical violations of Subordinates
Supervising authority responsible if:
- he fails to make remedial action,
- knows of conduct when it can be stopped or mitigated, and fails to take remedial action,
- ratifies conduct
Duty to make independent judgments
Every lawyer responsible for his own actions unless following directions from a supervisor that he believes is REASONABLE
Unauthorized practice of law by NON LAWYERS
Activity involves legal knowledge and skill AND person gives advice on binding legal rights
OR
involved activity traditionally performed by lawyers (drafting documents or appearing in court)
Lawyer’s duties v. clerks duties
Lawyer: court appearances, taking depositions, negotiating settlements
Clerk (if supervised by a lawyer): interview witnesses, fill in blank forms, write memos
Exception for when a lawyer can practice in a jurisdiction they are not admitted in
- Pro Hac Vice status - asks court in that state to practice in a particular case (usually one time)
- Taking deposition in other state as long as related to practice in jurisdiction where lawyer is admitted
Fee splitting with a NON LAWYER
Generally prohibited, EXCEPT:
- employees
- estate of deceased lawyer: proceeds of deceased partner can be transferred to their estate
- non profit organization
Can lawyers enter into business with a NON LAWYER?
Lawyer may own and operate a business with non-lawyers so long as any part of the business is not involved in practicing law
Formation of lawyer-client relationship
Relationship formed when client intends to seek legal advice from lawyer and lawyer either accepts or fails to clearly decline the representation
Duty to accept a client’s case
Lawyer has no duty to accept any case, UNLESS court appointed
When can a lawyer get out of a court appointed case?
Good cause:
- conflict
- puts an UNREASONABLE financial burden on lawyer
- lawyer’s personal feelings toward client would impact effective representation
Scope of representation -
Clients authority v. lawyer’s authority
Lawyer - allowed to make decisions regarding MEANS of litigation (strategy, discovery method, etc)
Client - makes decisions regarding ENDS of litigation
- In civil case, whether to settle
- in crim case, whether to take plea bargain, waiver of jury trial or testifying
Agreement to limit scope of representation
May limit scope of representation if limitation is reasonable and client gives informed consent
Duty to communicate
- Reasonably consult with client about means
- reasonably update client of status of case
- promptly comply with reasonable requests for info
- explain matters to client in order for them to make an informed decision
When MUST a lawyer withdraw from representation?
- lawyer’s disability (mentally or physically)
- if continued representation will foster commission of crime or violate RPC
- client’s primary purpose is to harass or delay
- discharge: client fires attorney
- NOTE: if matter already in litigation, MUST ask for court’s permission to withdraw
When MAY a lawyer withdraw from representation?
With consent or for good reason
General rule for fees
- communicated to client
- before or within a reasonable time after commencing representation
- preferably in writing
- NOTE: unless client is a regular client, then implied consent if same rate as before
Minimum fees
Prohibited. If lawyers in a community all agree that they will not charge less than a certain amount for representation
Factors determining reasonableness of a fee
- Time and Labor
- Novelty and difficulty of questions involved
- If client is aware that lawyer must turn away other cases
- what other attorneys charge for similar work in community
- amount at state and results obtained for the client
- time limitations imposed by client
- Nature and length of relationship with client
- experience, reputation and ability of lawyer
- whether fee is fixed or contingent
Requirements for contingent fees
Must be
- in writing
- signed by client, AND
- state method by which the fee is to be determined
When are contingent fees not allowed?
Criminal cases and domestic relations cases
NOTE: watch for collections cases involving domestic issues, contingent fee allowed here
Fees upon termination of lawyer (with or without cause)
Without cause - lawyer must be compensated for work already done
With cause - lawyer will not be compensated for work completed
When is fee splitting with lawyers not in the same firm allowed?
- division is proportional to services provided, OR each lawyer assumes JOINT LIABILITY,
- client agrees in writing (including share each lawyer will receive)
- total fee is reasonable
What must a lawyer do if withdrawing from representation?
- Give reasonable notice
- Return client property (complete file)
Duty of competence
Must provide competent representation to a client, meaning:
- legal knowledge,
- skill,
- thoroughness and
- preparation reasonably necessary for the representation
3 ways to avoid incompetence problem
Incompetent? Drink some “ALE”
- Associate with lawyer competent in area
- Learn it - become competent in subject
- Emergency situations
Duty of Diligence
Lawyer must act with reasonable diligence and promptness in repping a client.
-Does not mean use offensive tactics
Theories of malpractice
- intentional tort
- breach of fiduciary duties
- breach of contract
- negligence (most common)