Civil Procedure Flashcards
What is personal jurisdiction?
Power of the court over the defendant
What is subject matter jurisdiction?
Power of the court to hear the type of case the plaintiff is bringing
Personal jurisdiction requirements: 2 approaches
Traditional approach: Defendant was domiciled in forum, personally served while present in the forum, consent or waiver (appearing in action w/out objection)
Long arm statute: D has sufficient minimum contacts with forum state so not to offend traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice
What does it mean to have “sufficient minimum contacts?”
-Defendant PURPOSEFULLY AVAILS himself of benefits of the forum state, so it is FORESEEABLE that he may be sued there.
OR
-D’s contact with forum state is so SYSTEMATIC and CONTINUOUS that he is essentially home
How does a court obtain subject matter jurisdiction?
- Diversity of Citizenship
2. Federal Question
Federal question jurisdiction
Exists when the claim arises under federal law, the US constitution, or US treaties.
Plaintiff must be enforcing a a federal right. No jx if primary issues do not involve federal law
Diversity of Citizenship jurisdiction requirements
- complete diversity of citizenship (no P can be from same state as any D)
- amount in controversy exceeds $75k (amount based on damages alleged in good faith)
Aggregation of claims
P may aggregate his claims against one D or multiple Ds if all are jointly and severally liable
How is citizenship determined?
Party’s citizenship is determined by their domicile.
Natural person - domicile is where they live
Corporation - principal place of business AND where incorporated
Executor - citizenship of the decedent
Partnership - state of its partners
Supplemental jurisdiction
In a diversity of citizenship jurisdiction, supp jx can be used if claims do not amount to greater than $75k, but supplemental claims must arise from a COMMON NUCLEUS OF OPERATIVE FACTS.
Supp jx cannot be used if it violates complete diversity requirement
When is venue proper?
In any district where:
- any district in which ALL Ds resides
- if Ds live in same state, but different districts, then any district a D lives in
- where a substantial portion of the claim occurred or the property is located, OR
- if neither of the above apply, then proper in any district which ANY D is subject to the court’s PJ
Transfer of Venue
Venue may be changed to another forum if:
- receiving court has PJ, SMJ and the convenience of the witnesses requires transfer, OR
- the interests of justice require transfer
Removal
DEFENDANT may remove a case to federal court if:
- fed court has SMJ
- all Ds must agree
- D is not a resident of the forum state, AND
- removal is sought within 30 days of learning grounds for removal
Plaintiff CANNOT remove a case to fed court
Forum non conveniens
There is a far more appropriate court that exists elsewhere: need to balance factors
- location of Ws and evidence
- undue hardship for D
- use of judicial resources
- public policy
Service of Process and Notice requirement
Summons and copy Complaint must be served upon D within 90 days after Complaint is filed
Two ways to deliver service of process
- to the individual personally
- to someone of suitable age and discretion at the individual’s dwelling or usual place of abode and that person live there
How to deliver service of process to a corporation
Deliver to an officer, manager or general agent of the corporation
Preliminary Injunction
Purpose is to maintain the status quo pending determination of merits of litigation. Must provide notice to the other party and must show:
- imminent irreparable injury (non monetary)
- no adequate legal remedy
- substantial likelihood of success on the merits
- balance of hardships between P and D if injunction granted
- not adverse to public interest
Temporary Restraining Order
Emergency remedy used to maintain the status quo of subj matter of litigation and prevents irreparable harm to P until the outcome of the preliminary injunction hearing. Must show same factors as in Preliminary injunction
Proper Complaint
Complaint must state
- grounds for jurisdiction
- facts supporting a PLAUSIBLE claim in which P is entitled to relief
- and demand for relief