Module 3: Cognitive Behavioral Therapy principles Flashcards

1. Module background (1-27), 2. lecture (28-60), 3. Lee & Cash (61-112), 4. Miller (113-132)

1
Q

aim of CBT

A

help patients recognize problematic situations and triggers, and to either avoid these, or learn how to deal with their problematic behavior in those situations.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

CBT is based on the client’s ability to () and appeals to

A

change and their commitment to stop or reduce problematic behavior

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

How is problematic behavior reduced or stopped?

A

1- self percetion
2- improving self-insight
3- adjusting dysfunctionl cognitions
4- behavioral exercises

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

addiction research initially was about cue exposure

A

triggers are offered in the absence of the opportunity to consume the substance

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

The idea behind cue exposure

A

to weaken the Pavlovian association

Weaken CS-US (by creating CS -> no US)

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

but we know that erasing associations is

A

impossible once they are formed

–> so in cue exposure the unwanted behavior is often replaced with a new desired behavior –> new competing association is created –> it competes with the old association

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

an example of negative reinforcement of substance abuse

A

disulfiram in treating alcohol abuse because tgt they produce a negative physical reaction

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

what is an alternative approach?

A

Contingency management: positive reinforcement of desired behavior

  • direct, small rewards following desired beh.

effective for cocaine abuse + reinforcing abstinence, reinforcing coming to appointments for example

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

In CBT, not only learning processes are targeted but

A
  • clients also gain insight into their own behavior (through functional analysis)
  • they learn effective strategies and skills to stop or reduce problemaic behavior
  • integrated treatment looks at co-morbid issues
    –> social contacts
    –> anxiety
    –> depression
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Motivational interviewing

A

a collaborative, goal-oriented conversation style with special attention to change language. It is designed to enhance personal motivation and commitment to a particular goald by eliciting and exploring a person’s reasons for change in an atmosphere of acceptance and compassion

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

why are addicts ambivalent about changing addictive behavior + how can MI counter this

A

because changing behavior is difficult especially when substance use has taken up years and given both negative and positive, rewarding effects

in MI an empathetic conversation style is combined with directivity to investigate the patient’s ambivalence with regard to substance use and to encourage it to change.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

In MI, the patient is asked emphatically about (5)

A
  • the suffering
  • the motive
    for or against change
  • values/norms/objectives
  • the discrepancy between the situation now and the desired situation
  • attempts to improve the patient’s sense of competence
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

how are the aims of CBT achieved?

A
  • by identifying the main obstacles,
  • by exploring past successes, and
  • by letting the patient reflect on possible strategies
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

change talk

A

e.g., “I would like to quit”, or “I have to quit in order to keep my job”

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

sustain talk

A

e.g., “I’ve tried, and I don’t think I can quit smoking”, or “I have to drink, it’s the only thing that helps me relax.”

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

what role do change talk and sustain talk play in MI?

A

Eliciting change talk and reducing sustain talk plays an important role in MI
- done by open questions
- and questions about the benefits of change and disadvantages of continuation

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

the last phase in MI and how is this also a phase in which most therapists make mistakes

A

In the last phase, the therapist creates a plan of change with the patient. The most common mistake (of therapists) is to want to move on to this planning phase too quickly.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
18
Q

what is considered a condition for a treatment plan to succeed

A

high willingness to change

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
19
Q

the MI is perpendicular to the

A

Johnson Model intervention
-> a confrontational intervention

there is more evidence for MI and CBT

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
20
Q

MI alone is useful for

A

milder cases of substance use

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
21
Q

when dealing with more severe cases of substance use, MI should be

A

complementary to CBT

-> that way it increases adherence

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
22
Q

Detoxification

A

patient stops using drugs

in alcohol detox: medication is used to reduce withdrawal symptoms (benzodiazepines) and to prevent seizures or a delirium

in opioid addiction: gradually reduced after being administered and while being monitored. Opiate is first replaced with methadone or buprenorphine/naloxone (Suboxone), after which methadone- or buprenorphine/naloxone use can be reduced in a second phase or can serve as basis for opioid maintenance therapy

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
23
Q

aversive drugs

A

disulfiram (antabus, refusal) prevents alcohol in the body of breaking down -> nausea, headache, dizziness, sweating, palpitations

-> most effective when taken under supervision of a partner or doctor

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
24
Q

Anti-craving medication

A

Naltrexone (revia, nalorex) -> obstruction of mu-opioid receptor (indirectly involved in the regulation of dopamine)

-> reduces rewarding effect of alcohol

this is relatively ineffective for chronic alcoholics

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
25
Naltrexone is also effective for
treating pathological gambling :0
26
Acamprosate (campral)
inhibitory effect on glutamatergic system -> reduces craving for alcohol after abstinence
27
Preservation treatment
prescribing medication that has the same chemical properties as the drug to which that person is addicted -> withdrawal symptoms and craving are prevented (e.g., methadone and buprenorphine/naloxone (Suboxone).)
28
# 1. CBT for substance abuse and gambling disorder: general introduction Aim of CBT
changing the pattern of problematic substance use (reducing or quitting) * includes protocolled treatment + a workbook * CBT and motivational interviewing MI: a way of doing treatment --> A basis for all therapy
29
# 1. CBT for substance abuse and gambling disorder: general introduction CBT forms (4)
* CBT 1: individual - 5 meetings * CBT 2: individual - 13 meetings * CBT 3: group - 6 meetings * CBT 4: group - 12 meetings
30
# 1. CBT for substance abuse and gambling disorder: general introduction Structure of sessions
1) Discussing homework - Registration (of substance/alcohol use) assignment (every week) (e.g., when you have a craving, when using, when usually use but now don't) - Homework related to the theme of the previous meeting 2) introducing new theme 3) giving new homework - Registration assignment - Homework related to new theme
31
# 1. CBT for substance abuse and gambling disorder: general introduction CBT is applicable to (4)
· Problematic use of alcohol and drugs · Smoking · Gambling · Sex addiction Any other addiction
32
# 2) CBT interventions aimed at improving which skills? (3)
· Self-control · Coping skills · Social skills --> behavioral based interventions (emphasis on behavioral, not cognitive therapy)
33
# 2) CBT interventions Registering substance use and craving
Any CBT treatment needs this important step of registration because we want them to fill things in as they happen -> helpful in future assignments in therapy * The act of writing down and showing to councellor can be shameful for some so they stop using Usually in first sessions there is confusion between thought, feeling and bodily sensation * You don't correct them but you explain your pov If they didn't use, what did they do instead * What reactions did people around you have to that
34
# 2) CBT interventions 1) Preparing for change steps + aim
1) First of all: increase motivation for change by means of motivational interviewing · a technique that is used to elicit motivation in the client to change a specific negative behavior 2) Make a cost/benefit balance · Disadvantages of use · Benefits of decreasing/stopping use · Short-term · Long-term purpose: to provoke 'change language' · I want to change, I want to stop, etc.
35
# 2) CBT interventions 1) Preparing for change: predictors of treatment outcome and relapse
outcome: * amount of change language spoken * Change in the ratio of change language / maintenance language relapse: * When abstinence is imposed * When clients identify the pros of using and cons of change
36
# 2) CBT interventions 2) Goal setting + characteristics of goals
Writing a goal down makes it explicit and when they want to use, there is a cognitive dissonance -> this is why goal setting is important characteristics of goals * Important and feasible for the client * Negotiation between client and counselor * Abstinence or controlled use * Advice: 4 - 6 weeks of abstinence --> because after 4-6 weeks effects of substance are gone, to see if comorbid disorders are still there -->Many symptoms of withdrawals look like symptoms of comorbid disorders --> we have to rule them out * Goals are formulated SMART (specific, measurable, attainable, realistic, timely
37
# 2) CBT interventions B) Goal setting guidelines for alcohol + drugs
Alcohol: * no alcohol at all / no more than 1 glass * minimally 2 substance-free days per week Drugs: * abstinence
38
behavioral contract
a contract made between the counsellor and client. Agreement on: * how much they want to reduce and for how long do they want to maintain it for * goal needs to be small in the beginning to induce a feeling of accomplishment and motivation
39
C) self-control measures
* stimulus control: avoid places, situations or people that pose a risk for SU * stimulus-response prevention: in high risk situations, try and alternative behavior * response consequences: agreeing w/ the client that if the goal if achieved/not achieved the coming week, they will receive a reward/punishment --> same principle as in contingency management
40
What is important for clients to have when they fall into using drugs?
an alternative behavior to turn to that can make them still feel good at the end of the day. Something that gives them hope that not all is lost
41
D) functional analysis
Revealing triggers of behavior * FA: the common thread of the treatment * One FA per substance * Determining function of use * Identify risk situations (Sd) * Choosing interventions on the basis of FA * Invite support person --> Closed ones usually know very well about patterns of use and triggers --> E.g., the warm feets patient = alternatively every time that he had warm feet as response to craving and wanted to take off shoe --> alternative behavior: go for a walk
42
Classical functional analysis
specific context (Sd) -> dyfunctional behavior (R) -> 1) cogn. repr. of pos. consequences (Sr-representation) 2) factual neg. consequences
43
Jellinek functional analysis of substance abuse
* external situation --> with who? --> where? --> when? * internal situation --> thoughts --> physical sensation? --> emotions? * behavior --> what substance? --> how much? --> how long? * consequences --> long term --> short term
44
E) Relapse and emergency measures
communicating about the possibility of relapse and emergency measures that can be done * Complicated topic for clients! Clients do not want to talk about relapse * Comparison: safety instructions when you fly --> What they can do when things go wrong when they are doing fine, not when they are relapsing Flight safety instructions given when you are safe not when in turbulence
45
beware of the Abstinence violation effect when talking about relapse and emergency measures
a negative emotional and cognitive response to relapsing after a period of abstinence -> person may feel guilt, shame, self-doubt which can in turn increase further risk of relapse + hinder recovery process --> clients think that the first moment of relapse means that everything is lost countering: reduce guilt, shame etc, see lapses as part of the process (a lapse is a learning moment), and plan emergency measures to prevent a full relapse.
46
creating an emergency plan steps
1. Ask the patient to formulate a detailed emergency plan to prevent that a lapse becomes a relapse… E.g., emptying the bottle down the drain -> "are you able to?, have you been able to do this before?" 2. Ask about… a) Behavior (e.g., doing a useful but laborious chore following a lapse) b) Helpful thoughts c) Help> who? d) Medication
47
difference between self-control and emergency measures is
self-control: prevent use emergency measures: interrupt use during a (re)lapse
48
F) Dealing with craving (5)
* Seek distraction - do something to take your mind of the urge * Seek social support * Mind surfing - Positive consequences of not using - Negative consequences of using * Alternative thoughts: - patients often think that craving can only be reduced by using. These thoughts are dysfunctional. An alternative, helpful thought is “it’s a disagreeable feeling, but I can tolerate it” or “the craving will subside eventually”. * Urge surfing: powerful intervention · Psycho-education + exercise helps clients to recognize, experience and accept craving as a normal response to conditioned stimuli, that will subside by itself. · Rather than giving into the urge, you ride it out, like a surfer riding a wave. After a short time, the urge will pass on it’s own. - Craving is a momentary phenomenon and when you can overcome that its effects subside away · This technique can be used to deal with craving, in SUD and behavioral addictions (but also emotional reactions such as ‘blowing up’ when angry)
49
Steps of urge surfing
1. Acknowledge you have it 2. notice your thoughts and feelings w/ out trying to change or suppress them 3. remind yourself - its ok to have them, they're natural - its a feeling, not a must - some discomfort is okay, don't have to change it - it is temporary
50
dysfunctional thoughts regaridng craving examples + how to change them / formulate a helpful thought
* I need something to feel better --> what will you do when there is no access to the drug? critical note on changing thoughts: * play no major causal role / SU is a habit behavior * clients mention it as a post-hoc rationalization in order to reduce cognitive dissonance * challenging thoughts does not have an added value
51
G) Declining / refusing offered substances
* Important: this is not an exposure exercise * It’s based on the same principle as Stimulus Response prevention (e.g., if a person offers me alcohol, I will ask for a fruit juice) * This also increases self-efficacy (a person's belief in their ability to succeed in a particular situation) * Practice with the client in role play --> Short & overwhelm them -> have to give an immediate trained response * Using attributes that are reminiscent of use * Watch out for avoidance (by both client and therapist)!
52
How can clients refuse or decline offered substances? and what do they need to say in the moment
How: * react quickly * be clear, don't hesitate * make eye contact What you say: * first "no" * suggest alternative * when pressured, ask the other one to stop * change topic of conversation, avoid discussion * don't apologize or give vague answers
53
# 3) other EBT treatments The minnesota model
* 12-steps group therapy based on alcoholics anonymous AA * abstinence orientated, comprehensive multiprofessional approach to the treatment of addictions --> expouses recovery but not cure, for those who adhere to it --> it is intensive offering group therapy with fellows, lecturers, and counselling
54
Acceptance and Commitment therapy
Combination of acceptance, mindfulness and value-based therapeutic processes * guides people to accept urges and symptoms associated with SU, fosters psychological flexibility, and uses value-based interventions to reduce those urges and the symptoms
54
Similarities and differences between the three
* focus on addiction behavior * give insight on the process of addiction through PE * Reshape (part of) the clients lifestyle * different names for comparable interventions
55
Similarities and differences: CBT
* focus on behavior and triggers * focus on learning new coping strategies * has long been first choice of treatment for SUD
56
Similarities and differences: ACT
* focus on psychological flexibility * focus on broader than just the addictive behavior * combines CBT with mindfulness * ACT is a relatively new treatment, especially in addiction care
57
Similarities and differences: Minnesota model
* focus on (re)connecting with self and others * based on self-help groups * inegrates the physical, emotional and spiritual processes of addiction * has a worldwide network for a lifelong aftercae * oldest way of treatment * most common way of treatment in the USA and UK (probably rest of world as well)
58
Other 2 EBT treatment approaches/techniques
1) contingency management (desired behavior is 'reinforced' or rewarded) - e.g., paying people to not take drugs, in actuality this is hard to implement 2) motivational interviewing * a technique that is used to elicit motivation in the client to change a specific negative behavior
59
Lee & Cash definition of CBT
It is an umbrella that encompasses a large group of therapies that have in common a focus on cognitions and behavior as both the cause of and the means to resolve, emotional and behavioral dysregulation
60
CBT- based therapies all have in common
a focus on cognitions (thoughts, beliefs, schemas and metacognition)
61
Aaron Beck and Albert Ellis (REBT) developed some of the most well-known models
Aaron Beck: cognitive therapy Albert Ellis: rational emotive behavior therapy --> early cognitive behavioral therapy models grew from behavior therapy and introduced the concept cognition into the behavioral models
62
1950's
psychology shifts from psychoanalytic roots into a science-based discipline --> a branch called behavior therapy began to form driven by scientific enquiry
63
1960's
Aaron Beck and Albert Ellis start to look beyond behavioral principles (role of interpretation of events, ideas from cognitive psychology & social learning theory) --> what people refer to traditional CBT is usually some version of one of these two styles
64
1990's
mindfulness-based therapies such as dialectical behavior therapy (DBT), mindfulness-based relapse prevention (MBRP) and acceptance and commitment therapy are developed (ACT)
65
These therapies that have developed throughout the years have what in common?
they are based on well-researched theoretical models: share an underlying assumption that our thoughts, behaviors and emotional reactions are *learned* and the path to wellbeing is through managing thoughts and beliefs and to some extent behavior
66
CBT's are the most
researched group of therapies in the world and have become a core competency for people in the alcohol and other drug workforce
67
Assumptions behind CBT: thoughts, behaviors and emotions are learned
genetic, biological and temperamental factors are risk factors, not determinants --> instead, alcohol and other drug use dependance are learned behaviors emerging over time, which can be 'unlearned' , they operate within a context of a range of environmental influences (family, friends, availability and sociodemographic circumstances) --> cognitions & emotional responses are also considered to be learned
68
Assumptions behind CBT: Therapeutic alliance is a necessary but not sufficient for change
CBT's do not rely on therapeutic alliance to create change - e.g., TA is an anaesthetic in surgery, it is definitely needed and aids the surgery but alone it is not sufficient for the surgery to go smoothly
69
in which ways do CBT's build alliance
* collaboration and active participation (essential and important) * a good effective treatment experience * CBT's are goal oriented and problem resolution focused --> addressing client's immediate goals through developing problem solving skills is the initial focus --> this naturally creates therapeutic alliance * alleviatin client's problems * good counselling skills * a flexible adaptive style * seeking feedback from client
70
Assumptions behind CBT: focus on the here and now
CBT's emphasize the present, at least initially -> CBT is of little use if the day-to-day issues of drug use are not addressed - e.g., there is little benefit in addressing childhood trauma that may have contributed to the development of a drug problem
71
Assumptions behind CBT: The client as their own therapist and the importane of homework
CBT's focus on developing skills in the client to enable them to be their own therapist in a sense -> e.g., skills in reflection & self-management with an emphasis on usage outside the clinic, hence skill practice sometimes is referred to as 'homework' (very important to practice between sessions)
72
Assumptions behind CBT: guided discovery as a self reflection tool
Guided discovery is the primary tool of to support self-reflection. comes from socratic questioning: asking questions to promote thinking --> difference is that Socrates had an end in mind whilst guided discovery doesn't necessarily see it as necessary --> it assumes that the client has the answer to their problems, or at least the means to find answers (therapist is a guide)
73
Assumptions behind CBT: The scientist-practitioner and collaborative empiricism
Practitioner applies scientific method to understanding and addressing client issues -> constantly evolving cogntive behavioral case formulation with hypotheses that are tested collaboratively (collaborative empiricism)
74
Scientist practitioner requires the terapist to
continually review science to maintain best practice and contribute to sceince through research because the scientist-practitioner approach necessitates undertaking and utilizing research about outcomes, (which is why CBT's are most researched)
75
In practice: length
relatively brief (no more than 12-16 sessions usually) even briefer ones exists: delivery between 1 and 6 sessiosn
76
In practice: structure
structured session plan into 3 or 4 interconencted sessions - tailored to client needs to it is structured but also flexible
77
Carrol's 20-20-20 rule
20 mins for review of the week, homework tassk and issues during week 20 mins for discussion and practice of a skill or topic linked to an issue from initial assessment or something that has arisen - in actuality this usually takes more than 20 minutes and is often the longest part 20 mins for recapping the session, agreeing on homework tasks and planning for the next week
78
Mitcheson et al.'s four part structure:
1. setting agenda and recap of previous session 2. dealing with specific agenda items (focus of session) 3. planning for next session 4. session review setting an agenda: structure is outlined and agreed upon with the client at the beginning of each session - important because clients do not have well-developed skills in structuring their own lives and this can be a model to assist them to learn these skills
79
Why is structuring not inflexible
client needs are incorporated regularly and practitioners still need to use their clinical judgement & skills to determine: * what happens within the structure * when structure needs to adapt to immediate circumstances
80
Purpose of structure is to
both help client learn how to apply it and to focus the session in order to ensure critical therapeutic work is done - e.g., cannot just be chit chatting
81
Key CBT's for alcohol and other drug problems characteristics
moderate effect sizes (d=0,45) - largest treatment effects found for cannabis, cocaine, opioids and polusubstance dependece - effective and long lasting when compared with general counselling - effective in both individual and group formats
82
Relapse prevention
Main goal is to develop skills to identifying and preparing for high-risk situations that lead to the relapse to prolematic alcohol aor other drug guse
82
Relapse is influenced by factors such as (7)
* self-efficacy, * outcome expectancies, * craving motivation, * coping, * emotional states * interpersonal factors * lifestyle factors
83
Relapse prevention has been found most effective in maintaining what in post-treatment
Abstinence, so if abstinence is the goal, relapse prevention may be the best choice -> although other CBT's have lower dropout rates (but also lower abstinence rates)
84
Cognitive therapy vs. CBT and relapse prevention
Cognitive therapy of SU first developed by Aaron Beck on the general cognitive therapy model CBT usually a pure or modified form of cognitive therapy OR a pure or modified version of relapse prevention
85
Theory of Cognitive therapy focuses on
'proximal situational factors' such as cognitive, behavioral, emotional and physiological variables as immediate triggers for alcohol and other drug use 'distal background factors' * personal history * long-standing cognitive and behavioral variables * personality traits --> provide a context or set of vulnerabilities for SU + can also act as maintaining factors
86
Coping skills therapy
1- relapse prevention training 2- social and communication skills training 3- training in coping with urges and cravings 4- mood management project MATCH, use a modified version of Coping skills therapy as the cognitive beharioval arm of the study - **equally as effective and motivational enhancement and 12-step facilitation**
87
Mindfulness-based cognitive behavioral approaches
from Buddhist practice of 'mindfulness' = purposeful attention to the present and an openness to accept things as they are examples: a) MBRP mindfulness-based relapse prevention integrates traditional relapse prevention w/ mindfulness based meditation practices - significant improvements on withdrawal and craving symptoms
88
ACT empirical evidence
only a few well-conducted empirical studies from which to draw conclusions --> outcomes from both traditional CBT's and mindfulness-based therapies are equally equivalent
89
Brief CBT's are best for
moderate to high-risk use and with people who are dependent but not ready to engage in intensive treatment - effective for alcohol & other drugs also for severely dependent ppl - also effective for drug related problems like insomnia
90
A brief 6-session intervention for cannabis (MI and relapse prevention) sessions include
* goal setting * planning to quit * dealing with lapses and relapses * refusal skills * managing withdrawal skills * cognitive skills * coping skills
91
Brief therapies & interventions for moderate to high risk drinking based on
* social learning * cognitive behavioral therapy principles * coping skills * relapse prevention
92
People with a dependency of _ are difficult to engage and retain in treatment
methamphetamine, so for them a briefer intervention may be more desirable
93
Low intensity CBT's
intensity is in terms of practitioner or service use, not the experienced intensity for clients. - delivered face to face - by non-specialists in the field ( e.g., medical practitioners delivering screening) - psychoeducational groups - self-directed technologies (books, papers, internet)
94
An advantage of low intensity CBT's
increase 'reach', access, flexibility and responsiveness, patient choice and cost-effectiveness of Evidence based intervention
95
why are CBT's often suited to low intensity environments
they are brief, structured and easily manualized
96
barriers to traditional CBT's
* accessibility of services * availability * considerations of anonymity and autonomy * recognizing problematic alcohol and other drug use behaviors * shame
97
Digital CBT's
mitigate some barriers to traditional CBT's - e.g., easier access, reaching a larger proportion of people who would benefit from alcohol & other drug use treatment (90%) - stigma and privacy concerns mitigated as anonymity in accessing and detachment from clinician interaction promising, similar results compared to face-to-face therapy
98
Criticisms towards digital CBT's
* methodological inconsistency issues w existing literature * based on CBT foundations but a lot of variation exists (clinician involvement, frequency, format)
99
effectiveness of digital CBT's hard to establish due to
1. self-efficacy, outcome expectancies, craving motivation, coping, emotional statea and interpersonal factors & lifestyle factors 2. variations in the terminology used to describe these interventions in the literature 3. the degree to which any given intervention is faithfully translating cogni- tive behavioural therapy to a digital application varies current state of the evidence sup- ports a prudent approach be taken to their wide- spread adoption as stand-alone methods of treatment.
100
General application of CBT's to alcohol & other drug treatment
80% in alcohol + other drugs treatments have a comorbid mental health issue 50-80% have some level of functional cognitive impairment CBT's are suited for alcohol and other drug treatment populations with comorbid disorders - highly structured --> those w/ cognitive impairment able to benefit
101
A General Cognitive Behavioural Model for Alcohol and Other Drug Disorders
flexible: accomodates newer cognitive behavioral therapies + allows clinicians to develop a clear formulation of a problem and flexibly implement a variety of strategies and techniques
102
the general CBT model assumed 6 elements
1. early experience - CBT recognizes it to be important in the development of fundamental beliefs (family, social, community, environmental and personal experiences early in life 2. beliefs & schemas - triggered by day to day stimuli 3. triggers 4. cycle of thoughts 5. cycle of feelings 6. cycel of behaviors these are all important and influence each other
103
Triggers are important for what reason
by identifying and understanding triggers or high risk situations we maximise the selction of appropriate interventions - useful first step is managing triggers - this also develops a sense of control e.g., relapse prevention focuses on triggers
104
Thoughts and beliefs
1. analyzing - identifying thoughts & beliefs + their connection to feelings and behavior + considering their helpfulness or unhelpfulness 2. challenging - challenging the thoughts that are analyzed (e.g., asking for evidence for the beliefs) + developing alternative thoughts and beliefs 3. accepting - noticing and accepting thoughts & beliefs without judgement
105
Feelings
if feelings have been identifed as an area requiring intervention, a number of strategies can be utilised * understanding emotions * identifying the relationship between emotions and alcohol and other drug use (including emotions as a trigger for and a consequence of alcohol and other drug use), * emotion regulation * distress tolerance (including mood and urge surfing) * mindfulness.
106
Behavior
Intervening at the behavioural level can focus on the substance using behaviour itself or on behaviours strongly associated with the alco- hol and other drug use.
107
International considerations
CBT's can accomodate cultural and other influences --> has been successful in a number of cultures
108
Chinese and other asian cultures and how CBT's accomodate for them
values: * conformity * certainty & discipline * persistence * strong work ethic * respect for authoritarian system there is a huge stigma around mental health issues and a tendency for somatization CBT's are structured and can be adapted to a more instructive than collaborative style --> it can therefore suit cultural contexts that need a directive style also reduces stigma by using a 'coaching' style of therapy as a nice bonus, the mindfulness aspect that stems from Buddhist ideas is likely to be well received
109
Miller sees addiction as a problem of motivation, what does he mean by this?
addictions involve powerful and often conflicting sources of reinforcement -> there are powerful motivational incentives for drug use
110
substance abuse comes from the activation of the reward system directly, what else is substance use influenced by
social reinforcement and modeling
111
physiological dependence and withdrawals set a pattern of __
negative reinforcement for continued use -> punished (withdrawal) for not using
112
the vast majority of those struggling with self control in addiction recover without treatment, this means that
we view addiction as a matter of choice
113
1980's and 1990's
dominant models of addiction treatment -> belief that addicted individuals had a pathological personality characterized by high levels of immature defense mechanisms (e.g., denial) --> this made therapy approaches that were highly confrontational since it was thought that this is needed for overcoming the denial eventually this belief was discarded to make space for other approaches
114
nowadays we have pharmacotherapy, community reinforcement programs, 12-step programs etc. among them, MI is
just one clinical tool (it is not therapy) within an array of options - it is combined with other EBT methods - increases the efficacy of treatments - can be used in brief health care consultations
115
historically addiction programs have assumed and even required
readiness for change as a **prerequisite** for treatment --> some patients would be left outside care if they were considered not ready for change "come back when you're ready"
115
Dissemination of the transtheoretical model of change suggests that
people's readiness for change is malleable and is actually a part of the clinician's task to help increase it
116
Initial descriptions of MI propose that high levels of "resistance" are a result of
a highly confrontational therapeutic approach - e.g., clients are ambivalent about substance use and clinician strongly voicing prochange arguments --> resistance or counterchange arguments from clients
117
In MI, the purpose of the interviewer is
to arrange the conversation so that the client themselves starts talking about change or motivations --> you are never the one that sets goals for them - when done right this has been effective in treatment outcomes + increases change talk
118
Research indicates what about MI and addiction
there is significant benefit from MI in addressing alcohol, tobacco, and other substance use problems (effect sizes small to medium) even when MI involved fewer sessions, there is no difference in treatment outcomes when compared with other Evidence based methods --> better to use MI than place people on waiting lists when combined with other active treatments MI enhances retention and adherence
119
one proposed reason for why MI has been found to work at some sites and not others?
* therapists are confounded with the sites in which they work * variations in MI skills and fidelity in practice also contribute to variability of findings
120
MI: engaging
understand clients' own experience and perspective on their life situation by OARS skills * open questions * affirmations * reflective lists * summaries
121
MI: Focusing
Exploring what changes people are willing to consider and then developing agreed-upon goals this can be especially challenging if a client comes in for depression but their self report indicates a possible alcohol use disorder, you need to approach the topic carefully by asking permission - example on article
122
MI: Evoking
the point is to evoke the client's own reasons for change involves asking & being curious about what clients themselves perceive as possible reasons for change - open ended questions --> important step as otherwise the client doesn't have any personal motivation to change
123
Particular ways in MI to promote further change talk when you hear it
* ask more about it * reflect the change talk, offer a complex reflection that makes a guess about what the person may mean * affirm it * summarize the change talk you've heard / 2 or 3 themes that favor change
124
decisional balance vs. MI in addiction
Decisional balance is asking and exploring all pros and cons to change or to not change this is not advised in addiction as clients are ambivalent about their SU - there is no theoretical or empirical justification for systematically evoking and exploring all of the person's counterchange motivations if your goal is to encourage change - e.g., considering tgt with client reasons for why continuing substance use would be a pro
125
MI: planning
is planning is done prematurely it can manifest in resistance, unaccomplished homework assignments, low compliance, missing appointments and dropouts on the other hand there is insufficient planning. A good plan seeks to go further and always asks "what would be one good next step?", "when and how will the person do it?" --> people are more willing to go through with an action when they have a specific plan of action and state intentions to accomplish it
126
black-and-white thinking in addiction treatment
the idea that any diversion from a goal is thought of as a "relapse" - this is quite extreme and considering that other disorders do are not looked at this way, it would also make sense that we see relapses as part of the process instead - thinking in black-and-white terms can easily undermine perfectly good progress - --> planning therefore is a continuous process occurring over time sometimes motivation can also fluctuate indicating that returning to previous steps of evoking, focusing or engaging