Midterm Study Guide Flashcards
what is evidence based dentistry?
3-part harmony, all optimize treatment outcomes
what are the three parts to evidence based dentistry?
best evidence
clinical judgement
patient values
best evidence
evaluation of the best available scientific evidence
clinical judgement
recognition of your own clinical expertise
patient values
understanding patients needs and preferences
why would you not use EBD?
Not simply just reporting the findings of the study or considering just one
study. It seeks to evaluate all scientific evidence on a specific topic. This allows us to broaden our treatment options by using more current evidence.
The steps in developing an evidence based approach to practice is:
- Determining your clinical question (What do you want to know?)
the hierarchy of evidence is based on the ability to
control for bias and demonstrate cause and effect in humans
hierarchy of evidence from top to bottom (7)
meta analysis systematic review randomized controlled trial cohort studies case control studies case series/case report animal studies
types of questions patients ask (6)
prevalence etiology/risk diagnosis therapy prognosis phenomena
prevalence
what is the frequency?
etiology/risk
what causes the problem?
cohort study>case control>case series
diagnosis
does the person have it?
prospective, blind comparison to a gold standard (RCT) or cross-sectional
therapy
what is the best treatment?
randomized control study> cohort study
prognosis
who will get the problem? (group of linked individuals)
cohort study>case control>case series
phenomena
what are the concerns?
PICO
population/patient/problem
intervention
comparison (dont always have this)
outcome
PICO
population/patient/problem
intervention
comparison (dont always have this)
outcome
most common questions of PICO
diagnosis
treatment
etiology/harm
prognosis
doctor uses given info to search for best evidence to answer the question, critically appraising the evidence and applying results in
clinical practice
what key words do you use when searching in pubmed?
PICO keywords
what order do you write your questions?
PICO
in patients with…will…as compared to…result in…
when searching for evidence, what order do you use?
I, C, P, O
what are common barriers to rational decision making?
cognitive biases
research question
presents the idea that is to be examined in a study and is the foundation of the research study
hypothesis
testable prediction; attempts to answer the research question
PICO
clinical question that cannot be tested
searching pubmed
use PICO for ket words during search; indexed with MeSH terms and newer items not indexed for searching
clinical queries
filters out all research not related to clinically related questions
Cochrane library
systematic reviews and Cochrane reviews; they have their own libraries they review
ADA’s EBD site
keeps up with hot topics, great for once you are out of school
TRIP
pulls up reviews easily
CEBD
won’t need as much and is harder to use
limited of databases (5)
language age time period/date gender/sex publication types
publication types (5)
systematic reviews meta RCT practice guidelines reviews
MeSH terms
medical subject headings
puimde is indexed with MeSJ terms and newer items not
indexed for searching
midline is indexed with only
mesh terms for search
MeSH is a
national library of medicines controlled vocabulary thesaurus
terms naming descriptions in hierarchical structure that permits searching at various level
specificity
boolean operators
a connection word or symbol that allows a computer user to include or exclude items in a test search
OR
broadens search
AND
narrows search
NOT
excludes
boolean operators must be — in pubmed
capitalized
internal validity (3) questions
are the results valid for the patients in the study?
was the study performed correctly?
was any difference between groups seen?
threats to internal validity (3)
selection bias
maturation
instrumentation
— — to groups addresses many threats to internal validity, but not all
Random assignment
external validity (2) questions
are the results valid for patients not involved in the study?
does the study population represent the larger group?
external ability to generalize findings beyond (2)
beyond subjects in the study
beyond the environmental constrains of the current study and to other temporal periods