Midterm II Flashcards
Durkheim and Social Change: Main Intellectual Concern
to analyze the possibilities of securing social solidarity in the face of rapid social and economic change
Durkheim and Social Change: What is Social Solidarity
how people within a society feel connected to one another
Durkheim and Social Change: Major Research Question
What will provide social solidarity in modernity
Features of Modernity: Industrialization
-Increased production by the mechanization of labor
and the use of inanimate energy
-Industrial revolution
—Shift from agrarian to industrial economic
——–Feudalism to capitalism
Features of Modernity: Urbanizations
–Increase in proportion of the total human population living in major cities vs rural areas
–Moving to industrialized areas
Features of Modernity: Secularization
–Social, cultural, and political significance of religion diminishes
–Separation of the church from (state, personal, professional, etc) affairs
–Diminishing of religious authority
–Weber: disenchantment, scientific understanding becomes more important than religious belief, people want evidence
Features of Modernity: Division of Labour
–Increase in occupational differentiation
–Durkheim argues with Adam Smith, the division of labor has increased production
What are the forms of Social Solidarity?
Mechanical & Organic
4 Features of Modernity
Industrialization, Urbanization, Secularization, Division of Labor
Social Solidarity: Mechanical Solidarity
–Characterizes premodern societies
–Some level of worker specialization
–Low degree of occupational differentiation
–Solidarity based on homogeneity
—-People are bound together by ‘commonalities, similitudes, and likenesses’
–Identity of economic interests and pursuits
–Identity of language, customs, and beliefs
Social Solidarity: Organic Solidarity
–High degree of occupational differentiation
–High level of worker specialization
–Solidarity based on heterogeneity
—-People are bound together by functional complementarity and interdependence
—-Society is an organism, everyone has distinct roles that help the society function
–Diversity of language, customs, and beliefs
–Anonymity, superficiality, and segmentation (fractured) of social relations
Durkheim on Anomie: Division of Labour (1883); Anomie is a physical societies:
–Temporary consequence of the division of labor
–Historically specific problems of societies in transition to modernity
–Not a necessary symptom of modernization
–Describes it as a stage of moral or normative deregulation
–Social condition that produces high rates of suicide and crime
Durkheim on Anomie: Division of Labor (1883); Anomie is a psychological state of:
–A malady of infinite aspiration
–Troubling sense of limitless possibility
–Disturbance, agitation, and discontent
–‘Weariness and disillusionment’
–Emotional emptiness and despair
–Sense of futility and a lack of purpose
Durkheim on Anomie: Key Takeaways
–Crime and deviance are, in part, the product of weak moral integration and poor social regulation
–Social change, such as the transition to modernity, can generate anomie and with this an increase in levels of crime and deviance
Merton on Anomie: Book
Merton (1938) Social Structure and Anomie
Merton: Social Structure and Anomie; Research Aims
–Sought to develop a sociological examination for deviant conduct as corrective to biological positivist explanations
–Aimed to demonstrate “how some social structures exert a swiftie pressure on certain persons in the society to engage in a non-conforming rather than conforming conduct”
Merton: Social Structure and Anomie; Arguement
–Argues that high rates of criminal behavior on certain grounds are a normal response to the social situation in which members of the group find themselves rather than indicators of biological pathology
Merton: Social Structure and Anomie; Two Elements of the Social System
Culturally Defined Goals and the Means to achieve those Goals
Merton: Social Structure and Anomie; Merton’s America
the cultural goal is ‘material success,’ ‘financial prosperity,’ and ‘accumulated wealth’
Merton: Social Structure and Anomie; Anomie is the result of:
the lack of symmetry between the cultural and structural components of the social system
Merton: Social Structures and Anomie; Anomie is a symptom of:
–A strain between culturally prescribed aspirations and the socially strucutred avenues for realizing then
–A discrepancy between socially engendered goals and the opportunity structures by which the goals might be achieved
–A contradiction between normative aspirations and lack of access to legitimate means to realize such aspirations
Assessing Merton: Important Features
–Draws attention to the social, cultural, nd economic circumstances that lead to crime
–Points to the necessary relation between forms of social organization and levels of crime
–Highlights the unintended consequences of the overvaluation of individual economic achievement
–Took special interest in the vulnerability of working-class and poorer communities
Assessing Merton: Criticisms
–Exaggerate level of consensus and ‘universal’ normative aspirations
–Tendency to focus on lower-class crime
–Does not explore the structural causes of strain
–Over-predicts lower-class crime
–Overlooks barriers to achievement other than lack of opportunity
–Definition of Anomie changes
–Not well-tested
–Atomistic and individualistic
Durkheim and Criminology: Crime is:
actions that offend against collective feelings or sentimental
Not something that is unchanging
Nation of irm reflect particular social convention which vary according to time and place
Best understood as violation of moral life (conscience collective of society)
Durkheim and Criminology: Crime is:
Actions that offend against collective feelings or sentimental
–Not something that is unchanging
–Reflect particular social convention which varies according to time and place
–Best understood as a violation of moral life (conscience collective of society)
Durkheim and Criminology: Function of Crime
Adaptive function
Introduces new idea and practices in society ensuring that there is change rate htn stagnation
Boundary maintenance
Reingificing social values and norms, crudely through its stimulation of collective action against deviance, it helps to reaffirm the difference between right and wrong
Crime should be considered as a normal element in any properly functioning society
Durkheim and Criminology: Function of Crime
Adaptive Function
–Introduces new ideas and practices in society ensuring that there is a change rate in stagnation
Boundary Maintenance Function
–Reingificing social values and norms, crudely through its stimulation of collective action against deviance, it helps to reaffirm the difference between right and wrong
–Crime should be considered a normal element in any properly functioning society
Durkheim and Social Change: What is an Ideal type of Social Formation?
–Attractions designed to help identify and explain patterns that appear in the real world, rather than a straightforward, factual description of that world
–Used to help understand particular social phenomena by looking at core characteristics
Durkheim and Social Change: The Division of Labour was written after:
the aftermath of the Industrial Revolution
— Research question: What is it that will provide great social solidarity and coherence in these new times?
Durkheim, Suicide, and Anomie: The use of Suicide
Sought to explain how patterns of suicide might be explained by reference to such social cake phenomena in a region. Social, structure, economic conditions, so on
Durkheim, Suicide, and Anomie; Four Ideal Types of Suicide
Type 1: Altruistic (Excessive Integration)
Type 2: Egoistic (Lack of Integrations)
Type 3: Anomic (Lack of Regulation)
Type 4: Fatalistic (Excessive Regulation)
Durkheim, Suicide, and Anomie; Four Ideal Types of Suicide explained by Two degrees of Social Solidarity
–Integration: social cohesions brought about by shared beliefs and practices; the forces of attraction that bring people together
–Regulation: the constraints that limit human behavior and desires
Assessing Durkheim: Criticism of his work
–Underplays the ways in which systems of punishment are shaped by the nature and distribution of power within society
–The assumption of consensus which underpins the notion of conscience collective is precisely that, an assumption
Merton and Anomie: Anomie results:
from the absence of alignment between socially desired aspirations, such as welt, and the means available to people to achieve such objectives
Anomie and The American Dream: What is Stran to Merton
product of the contradiction between the cultural emphasis on pecuniary ambition and the social bars to full opportunity
Anomie and the American Dream: Four Deviant Adaptations
Innovation, Ritualism, Retreatism, and Rebellion
Anomie and the American Dream: Innovation
–The application of legitimate means to the achievement of socially approved ends
–Relatively ineffectual means are rejected (dead-end, low-paying, etc)
–Promising legitimate means are explored
–Many crimes against property are clear examples of innovation in Merton’s sense
eg.) burglaries, robberies, larcenies
Anomie and the American Dream: Ritualism
The cultural goals are rejected but legitimate means are accepted
“The abiding or scaling down of the city corals goals of great pecuniary success and rapid social obesity to the point where one’s aspiration can be stastfied’
Playing by the rules but having no desire to get ahead
Low-level office workers who realize they will never get a promotion but decide to work hard
Anomie and the American Dream: Retreatism
–The cultural goals and legitimate means are both rejected
–Concerts people that are in the society but not of it
—-Psychotics, autists, pariahs, outcasts, alcoholics, drug addicts, tramps, vagrants
–Private, not public, adaptation
–Become a subcultural style in the 1960s with the advent of the hippie movement
—-Turn on, tune in, drop out
Anomie and the American Dream: Rebellion
–Rejecting, and seeking to replace, dominate normative aspiration and oppourtunitic stretches
–Concerns political debates and criminal
–A collective, public adaptation
Later Strain Theory: Albert Cohen: suggests
Instead of anomie, competition and frustration around status are the key to understanding youthful delinquency
Later Strain Theory: Cloward and Ohlin, Delinquency and Opportunity: Main Question/Answer
Q) Under what conditions will people experience stains and tensions that lead to delinquent solutions?
A) In a system that stresses ability as the basis of advancement, the failures who view themselves as equal in ability to those who succeed tend to feel unjustly deprived
-Argue that there are numerous means of resolving the adjustment of strain problems
General Strain Theory: Robert Agnew: Four Reasons why Strain Theory has declining popularity
1)It has tended to focus on lower-class delinquency.
2)It has neglected all but the most conventional goals (middle-class status and wealth).
3)It overlooked barriers to achievement other than social stratification (these might include gender, race, intelligence, and many others).
4)It has found it difficult to explain why some people who experienced strain didn’t turn to criminal activity. Arguably, strain and frustration are experienced by many who continue to conform.
General Strain Theory: Robert Agnew: Two Types of Strain that occur as a result of the failure to achieve one’s goals
First arises from the actual or anticipated loss of positively valued stimuli from an individual
The second form of strain is the result of the actual or anticipated presentation of negative or noxious stimuli such as relationships in the home, workplace, or elsewhere theater abusive
General Strain Theory: Robert Agnew: 5 Factors that increase the likelihood that strain will lead to Crime and Delinquency
1) Where the strain is perceived to be ‘unjust’; where people feel that they have been treated unfairly, they are more likely to become angry, and anger, according to Agnew’s strain theory, is linked with an increased likelihood of offending.
2) When strain is high in magnitude, it is more difficult to ignore and manage in ways that are legitimate.
3) Where the strain is caused by or is associated with, low social control, it is more likely to result in a deviant adaptation.
4) Strains may also lower levels of social control.
5) Where the strain creates pressure to engage in ‘criminal coping’ – such as strain induced by criminal victimization leading to a desire for revenge.