midterm Flashcards
- The earliest taxonomies placed human
beings in categories based on
________________.
A) behavioural and psychological
characteristics
B) genetic makeup
C) cultural customs and traditions
D) superficial phenotypic characteristics
D) superficial phenotypic characteristics
- A teacher uses a test of verbal fluency to
determine who will lead a group of children. While
the test may be accurate for children who speak
English as a first language, it may not be accurate
for children who speak English as an additional
language. The application of this test is a/an
______________.
A) item bias
B) response style bias
C) bias of the user of the test
D) bias in the usage of the test
D) bias in the usage of the test
Example Question Chapter 3
* Which of these is not one of Schwartz’s
top values endorsed by Canadians:
A) Universalism
B) Benevolence
C) Achievement
D) Security
D) Security
- Someone says to you, “This is real
interesting” in a sarcastic tone. This
person is using Norman and Rummelhart’s
addition to the Cooperative Principle
maxim of _______________.
A) relations with conversational partner
B) rule violations
C) manner
D) relevance
B) rule violations
- Acculturation is a process that is evident in
____________.
A) only persons who are immigrants
B) immigrants and host culture members
C) only in interpersonal exchanges
D) only persons in the host culture
B) immigrants and host culture members
- If two cultures have a different concept of
intelligence, this means that ______
a) the concept is defined differently in each
culture
b) sample equivalency is a problem
c) response bias is a potential problem
d) there are issues surrounding ethical
measurement of the concept
a) the concept is defined differently in each
culture
In examining a concept in cultures A and B, the researcher
could use a “derived etic” if …
a) there is no communality between cultures A and B
and therefore, comparison is not possible.
b) there is an imposed etic
c) there is communality between cultures A and B and therefore, comparison is possible.
d) no attempt has been made to study the behaviour in both cultures.
b) there is an imposed etic
One problem with naturalistic observation is
A. that the observer’s attitudes can have an
impact on the results of observation.
B. that measuring people’s behaviour in
their natural environments is not
possible.
C. the cultural differences in the way people
behave.
D. lack of reliable information
D. lack of reliable information
Which of the following classifications best
describes a study examining whether the
concept of intelligence is different across
cultures?
A. Hypothesis testing studies
B. Level-oriented studies
C. Structure-oriented studies
D. Contextual studies
C. Structure-oriented studies
Our experience with the environment shapes
our perception by creating perceptual
expectations of what we see. These
expectations are known as _______.
a) Sensory adaptation
b) Perceptual set
c) Visual sensory
d) Perception of colour
b) Perceptual set
The monist view of consciousness believes in the
_______ of the body and soul. The dualist view
believes in ________ of body and soul.
a) independent existence, inseparability
b) mystical aspect, biological aspect
c) mystical aspect, social aspect
d) inseparability, independent existence
d) inseparability, independent existence
Leo fortunes work: dobuans
Human nature
The idea of one “human nature” is misleading
The Dobuans human nature
The dobuans
Anthropological studies by Rio Fortune (1932)
Married to Margaret Mead
Believe in magical thinking, everything associated with magic
Environment influences culture
Dobuans environment
Volcanic island close to New Guinea
They farmed yam but had poor and difficult harvest
Went hungry most of the time because of poor farming environment
Believed yam roots would travel underground at night to neighboring tribe, developed practice to make yam stay
Developed magical practice to bring yam from neighboring farm
Blamed bad harvest on magic
Treated any death as homicide by magic
Dobuans culture
Lacked power to overcome farming problem
Developed magical thinking and complex rituals
Different definitions of culture
Culture is used to describe and explain broad range of activities, events, and structures
There is much confusion and ambiguity about its definition
Debates in the last century
Anthropologists discuss culture as a way of encapsulating their understandings of the relatively small and relatively isolated groups of people
No agreement on the conceptual definition of culture
Definition 1
“Culture is a complex whole which includes knowledge, beliefs, art, morals, laws, customs, and any other capabilities and habits acquired by man as a member of society”- Tylor 1871
Definition 2
“Culture is whatever a person has to know or believe in order to operate in a manner acceptable to the members of a society”- Goodenough 1957
Definition 3
“Culture is the man-made part of the environment”- Herskovits 1955
Definition 4
“Culture is learned ways of coping with experience”- Gregory 1983
Definition 5
“Culture is a relatively organized system of relatively shared meanings”- Rohner 1984- after Geertz 1974
Definition 6
“Culture is the collective programming of the mind that distinguished the members of one group or category of people from another”- Hofstede 2001
Definition 7
“Values and normative systems are the core aspects of societal culture. Culture also includes beliefs and practices”- Schwartz 2014
Definition of cross-cultural psychology;
about comparison between atleast 2 cultures
Cultural psychology
Cultural psychology seeks to discover meaningful links between a culture and the psychology of individuals living in the culture
Cross cultural psychology
Cross cultural psychology focuses on comparing specific behaviour, values, and beliefs across cultures
It examines psychological diversity and the reasons for such diversity
It studies cross-cultural interactions
It establishes psychological universals
Hofstede’s dimensions
The Hofstede Project
It is one of the most influential work in the development of research in cross-cultural psychology
Geert Hofstede, a dutch social psychologist, collected data of IBM employees worldwide in 1960s and 1970s
He reported the results of his analyses of 72,215 respondents from 40 nations in his classic study entitled “cultures consequences” 1980
Dimensions of culture
Hofstede (1980, 1991, 2001)
IBM staff survey
N = 117,000 in 69 countries
Partly matched samples in some nations
Reduced to 5 dimensions of culture related values
Factor analysis = 4(5) dimensions of culture related values:
1. Power distance
2. Uncertainty avoidance
3. Individualism/collectivistic
4. Masculinity/femininity
5. Long term orientation
Power distance (PD)
High vs low countries
Power distance (PD)
It is the extent to which the members of the society accept that power in institutions and organizations is distributed unequally (hofstede 2001)
High Power Distance: malaysia, slovakia, guatemala, panama, philippines
Low power distance: austria, israel, denmark, new zealand, and ireland
Canada and US are mid/low power distance
National differences in PD
Collectivist positively associated with high power difference and warmer climates
Low power distance positively associated with cold climates and individualistic
Exploring PD, china example
Chinas reaction to 2010 nobel peace prize winner
Democracy activist Liu Xiaobo who was imprisoned in china was awarded nobel peace prize, was not allowed to go and receive
China reacted aggressively
Said nobel prize committee was interfering with internal affairs and they did not allow people to watch (tv went black)
Asked countries to not send diplomats to ceremony
Chinese authority felt threatened by indication of power sharing
People from high power distance cultures are comfortables with status differential and hierarchical relationships
Uncertainty Avoidance (UA)
The degree to which the members of a society feel uncomfortable with uncertainty and ambiguity
High uncertainty avoidance: greece, portugal, guatemala, uruguay, malta
Low uncertainty avoidance: singapore, jamaica, denmark, sweden, and hong kong
National differences in UA
Canada and US fall more under low uncertainty avoidance
Individualism and collectivism (IDV)
It refers to the relative importance of individual versus group as an important social unit
High individualistic: the US, the UK, the Netherlands, Canada and Hungary
Low individualistic: Guatemala, Ecuador, Panama, Venezuela, and Colombia
National differences in IDV
Exploring IDV, example old chinese practice
A chinese concept of t’ung-yang-his
Means “daughter-in-law raised from childhood” (wolf 1968)
Based on the great concern for harmony within the chinese family
This practice ensures that a sons loyalty to his mother is not transferred to his wife
Masculinity vs femininity (MAS)
It differentiates nations that value assertiveness from those that value nurturance
High masculinity: slovakia, japan, hungary, austria, venezuela
Low masculinity: sweden, norway, netherlands, denmark, costa rica, finland
Canada and US fall under masculine
Rival explanations cross cultural
Refers to alternative explanations for the observed cultural differences. These differences may not reflect real psychological differences but rather are based on some plausible ecplanations that account for observable differences
Ex: intelligence across cultures
1. Different definitions
To avoid rival hypothesis, we need to ensure that the meaning of constructs are the same in each culture
Similarity-different paradox
Categorization done by diff logics, ex hindu vs italian, canadian, cuban
Ex, sorting as a measure of intelligence, animals vs no animals, portrait vs landscape, relationship and association
2. Misunderstanding the instruction
We should employ formats and tasks that are familiar in both cultures
The extent to which participants are familiar with research or are “testwise” has a significant impact on their performance, ex familiarity with surveys
Confusion about answering abstract questions
3. Meaning of the test situation
We need to ensure that the meaning of the test situation is equivalent
4. Response set bias
We need to identify whether or not participants from one culture use extreme vs. moderate responses ex, extreme responses are rare for canadians but latin americans tend to switch between two extreme response options
5. Sample equivalence
We need to ensure that differences are not due to socio-economic and demographic characteristics of the participants in different cultures, ex normalcy of uni for canadians vs italians
General points in conducting cross-cultural research
- Generate methods (e.g., test items) in all the cultures that are to be compared
- Use more than one method
- Use local scientists
Emics and etics
Emic concepts are culture specific. They are studied within the system in one culture and their structure is discovered within the system
Etic concepts are universal. They are studied outside the system in more than one culture and their structure is theoretical
Geisha is an emic concept unless aspects are compared, ex jesters
Steps in operationalizing emics and ethics
imposed etics
Structure vs level oriented
METHODOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION
3. The distinction between structure-oriented and level-oriented studies.
*In structure-oriented studies the focus is on the meaning of a variable and relationships among variables.
*E.g., cross-cultural study of depression
•Level-oriented studies examine the size of cross-cultural differences.
•E.g., comparing Americans and Chilean school children in test anxiety.
METHODOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION
contextual factors
METHODOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION
1.The inclusion of contextual factors including demographic and socioeconomic characteristics of the participants or their culture.
E.g., comparing Canadians and Vietnamese on self-esteem.
METHODOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION
*Methodological classification of cross-cultural research consists of three dimensions (van de Vijver, 2002).
METHODOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION
1.The inclusion of contextual factors including demographic and socioeconomic characteristics of the participants or their culture.
E.g., comparing Canadians and Vietnamese on self-esteem.
- The distinction between exploratory and hypothesis-testing studies.
*In exploratory studies no prior ideas are formulated about cultural differences and similarities.
*Exploratory studies are helpful in initial stages of research.
*E.g., cross-cultural study of visual illusion (River, 1901)
2.The distinction between exploratory and hypothesis-testing studies.
*In hypothesis-testing studies theories or models about the relationship between psychological and cultural phenomena are specified at beforehand and tested for accuracy.
*E.g., examining generalizability of a Western model of personality, The Five-Factor Model of personality, in a non-Western society.
METHODOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION
3. The distinction between structure-oriented and level-oriented studies.
*In structure-oriented studies the focus is on the meaning of a variable and relationships among variables.
*E.g., cross-cultural study of depression
METHODOLOGICAL CLASSIFICATION
3. The distinction between structure-oriented and level-oriented studies.
*Level-oriented studies examine the size of cross-cultural differences.
*E.g., comparing Americans and Chilean school children in test anxiety.
exploratory vs. hypothesis testing studies
2.The distinction between exploratory and hypothesis-testing studies.
*In hypothesis-testing studies theories or models about the relationship between psychological and cultural phenomena are specified at beforehand and tested for accuracy.
*E.g., examining generalizability of a Western model of personality, The Five-Factor Model of personality, in a non-Western society.
- The distinction between exploratory and hypothesis-testing studies.
*In exploratory studies no prior ideas are formulated about cultural differences and similarities.
*Exploratory studies are helpful in initial stages of research.
*E.g., cross-cultural study of visual illusion (River, 1901)
THE ISLANDS IN TORRES STRAITS
MÜLLER-LYER ILLUSION
Cultural similarities and differences in parent-child interaction
Parental warmth
Socio-emotional development
The family and peers are two of the major social contexts of socio-emotional development for adolescents (chen 1998)
Parental warmth has universal existence but the level of parental warmth is not the same across cultures
Lower expression of warmth in industrialized societies than traditional societies
Lack of parental warmth has universal association with negative psychosocial outcomes
Adolescents in different cultures spend different amounts of time with their peers
Kagitcibasi’s three models of family; definitions and how they are diff
Three models of family-first
The family model of interdependence
This is the case especially in societies with low levels of affluence, particularly with rural agrarian people or low income groups in urban or semi urban areas
It develops in socio-economic contexts where there is an economic utilitarian value is associated with one’s children (e.g., old age security benefits for parents)
This is also the context where fertility is the highest and in context of poverty where child mortality is high
This model is obedience oriented; children are expected to obey what parents want
Intergenerational interdependence is manifested through the family life cycle
Three models of family- second
The family model of independence
It develops affluent contexts where there is an economic cost associated with one’s children
There are psychological values for having children
This is also the context where child fertility and mortality is low
This model is self-reliance and independence oriented
More permissiveness than obedience
Three family models- third
The family model of psychological interdependence
It reflects urbanization and socio-economic development around the world
It reflects psychological (emotional) interdependencies
Child rearing involves control rather than permissiveness and autonomy rather than obedience is valued
The autonomy of the growing child becomes adaptive to urban lifestyles and is no longer a threat to family livelihood, given decreased material interdependencies
Adolescence
A. the universality of adolescence as a distinct life-period
In almost all societies there is a notion of adolescence (schlegel 1991)
In most of the societies, the beginning of adolescence is marked by initiation ceremonies, or rites of passage, that are major public events
Most non-industrialized societies around the world hold rites of passage ceremonies
Themes of initiation ceremonies are typically consistent with the eventual adult responsibilities in the various societies
Some rituals tend to be painful
B. the universality of adolescence as a period of “storm and stress” (hall 1996)
The beginning of adolescence involves major physical transitions
In industrialized societies there is a disjunction between biology and society has the potential to create a difficult transitional period for adolescents (chen, 2002)
In agrarian societies children start early to assume responsibilities
Most adolescents live a life with few serious personal or social problems, but for a minority of adolescents, adolescence still represents the most troubling years. That is the case in industrialized and non-indsustrialized nations
Role of culture
Culture has influence on three areas of adolescent development
Physical development
Cognitive development
Socio-emotional development
Physical development
There is cross-cultural variations in the onset of puberty in girls
The onset of menstruation in girls has been declining in the past 140 years (chen, 2002) every decade girls have their puberty 4 months earlier on average
Nutrition is a major contributor to this variation
Cognitive development
Piaget stage theory of cognitive development
The qualitative aspects of the theory (the sequence of the stages) appear to be valid across cultures (Dasen, 1977). However, quantitative aspects (the timing of progression throught the stages) appears to vary greatly across cultures
Intelligence
Cross-cultural differences have also been found in adolescent school achievement
Adolescents from asian countries such as Japan, Korea, and China perform at a higher level on academic work than their counterparts in other parts of the world
Factors that account for East Asians superior school achievement are the cultural value of education, cultural beliefs in the positive outcomes of hard work (rather than ability), high parental expectations, dynamic classroom instruction, and more time devoted to academic work in and outside of school (Stevenson, 1993)
rites of passage (more likely to happen in non-industrialized societies)
In most of the societies, the beginning of adolescence is marked by initiation ceremonies, or rites of passage, that are major public events
Most non-industrialized societies around the world hold rites of passage ceremonies
Themes of initiation ceremonies are typically consistent with the eventual adult responsibilities in the various societies
Some rituals tend to be painful
Gential operations, female genital circumsision
Extensive tattooing, ex tribes in indonesia
Lip plate, suri women in ethiopia, done a few years before girl is married off, the bigger the lip plate the more cattle given when married
Neck rings, neck stretching of paduang tribe of myanmar, the practice of wearing coil of brass rings around the neck
Extensive tattooing in mentawai tribe in indonesia
Lips and breast augmentation
Butt augmentation
diff views on old age